THYROID SURGERY INDICATIONS: TO WHAT EXTENT IS THE ULTRASOUND RISK-STRATIFICATION OF THYROID NODULES PERFORMED IN CLINICAL SETTING?
Andreea Borlea,Laura Cotoi,Dan Alin Brebu,Amadeus Dobrescu,Fulger Lazar,Marioara Cornianu,Dana Stoian
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ultrasmedbio.2022.04.127
IF: 3.694
2022-01-01
Ultrasound in Medicine & Biology
Abstract:Objectives Reducing the number of unneeded thyroid surgeries could impact hospitalization costs, but also surgical complications and iatrogenic hypothyroidism. The purpose of the present study was to assess retrospectively the number thyroidectomies which had a complete presurgical clinical and imaging thyroid evaluation and respectively the overlap between the surgical indication and the final pathology result. Materials We included all the patients admitted in the three Surgical Departments in Timisoara Emergency County Hospital for thyroid surgery between January 1st 2018 and December 31st 2019 (2 years) and compared the pre- and post-surgical diagnosis. Results 1036 patients were admitted for thyroid surgery in the three surgical departments of Timisoara County Hospital “Pius Brinzeu” in Romania: 180 unilateral lobectomies, 824 total thyroidectomies and also 32 redo operations for completion of thyroidectomy. 90.3% were females and the mean age was of 53.8±13 years. Out of the total 892 cases with NG, only 218 (24.4%) presented a well-defined indication for surgery: compression, US high-risk, malignant cytology result or hyperthyroidism. Cancer was detected in 32.9% (n=338) of the cases. A higher prevalence of thyroid malignancy in the men (55.6% vs 30.5%, p<0.01) and in woman older than 30 (16% vs. 31.8%). An important finding was the relatively high prevalence of malignancy in the lobectomy group: 22.8%, while 65% of the total thyroidectomies proved to be benign. Important discordances were detected between the clinical diagnosis and the pathology report: 46.2% of cases. The group with associated compressive symptoms presented an important malignancy rate of 42.6%. In 110 cases, the pathology report showed that chronic autoimmune thyroiditis (CAT) was misdiagnosed, clinically or on US evaluation, as nodular goiter. Rare findings included one patient with metastasis from pulmonary neoplasia and 3 cases with lymphomas (before surgery one of them was suspected to be anaplastic thyroid cancer). The number of FNAs performed and documented in the studied surgical cases is very low (121 out of 674 cases with only non-toxic nodules -17.9%). Conclusions We estimated that surgery could have been avoided, with correct presurgical risk stratification algorithms, in up to 46% (473/1027) of the cases. Nevertheless, the important percentage of detected thyroid cancers supports the current radical surgical attitude, given the lack of uniform and precise presurgical diagnosis.
radiology, nuclear medicine & medical imaging,acoustics