First global report of Hyaloperonospora brassicae in commercial broccoli and cabbage microgreens
Emily E Pfeufer,Lohini Padmeshika Suresh,Glen Groben
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1094/PDIS-01-24-0266-PDN
2024-05-22
Abstract:Microgreens are a nutrient-dense enhancement to modern diets (Choe et al. 2018), whose small production footprint in protected systems facilitates rapid crop turnover and distribution to population centers. Eleven of the 25 most broadly grown microgreens are brassicas (Choe et al. 2018). In November 2023, kale, broccoli (H009B), and cabbage (H009C) microgreen crops in Michigan were observed with downy mildew, at disease severities of 3%, 40%, and 20% foliage on 10 x 16 cm seeded blocks of plants, respectively. These crops shared a germination chamber for at least three days, which was maintained at approximately 22℃ in very humid, dark conditions. Chlorosis and grayish, sunken necrosis characterized symptoms on cotyledon surfaces (Fig. 1). In humid conditions, thick, white-light gray sporulation was present on adaxial cotyledon surfaces, accompanied by sparse sporulation on abaxial surfaces and hypocotyls. Severely diseased plants were stunted and approximately 50% gradually succumbed to downy mildew. On microscopic examination, a Hyaloperonospora spp. was tentatively identified, with long sporangiophores that dichotomously branched 3 to 6 times and hyaline sporangia borne singly on flexuous terminal sterigmata (Fig. 2). Sporangia were round to oval, with average length of 23.1 (range 16.0 to 28.3) µm; width of 20.0 (15.0 to 25.6) µm; and average length:width of 1.2 (1.0 to 1.4); (n = 97 for all). Sporangia dislodged rapidly if disturbed or as humidity decreased. Two pathogenicity tests were initiated on two sequential days. Two cotyledons from originally infected broccoli and cabbage were suspended, abaxial-side down, on coarse mesh over an open 60-mm plate of pregerminated brassica seeds on a water-saturated filter, inside a sealed, clear plastic box. Boxes contained only one type of originally diseased host, with 15 to 20 seeds of transfer varieties in unique dishes. Boxes were incubated in the dark for 2 days at 19°C with a wet paper towel atop the cotyledons. Before removal, cotyledons were lightly brushed across the surfaces of the seedlings they were just suspended above. Seedlings were grown in boxes in the presence of indirect, ambient light for 9.5 hr/day for an additional 5 days before pathogen sporulation was apparent. Filter paper was resaturated as needed. Noninoculated control plants, maintained separate from inoculated plants, were asymptomatic throughout the experiments. Total disease incidence in transfer varieties was 43.5% of 'Graffiti' cauliflower, 18.7% and 15.7% of 'Nixon' and 'Blue Vantage' cabbage; 11.8% of 'Red Russian' kale, and 6.0% of 'Ironman' broccoli, combined from two experiments. All varieties listed had at least one plant successfully infected in both pathogenicity tests. Sporulation on transfer hosts was morphologically identical to originally affected crops. Sporangiophores and sporangia were removed from H009B broccoli and H009C cabbage plants using surface sterilized forceps, placed directly into DNA extraction tubes containing buffer CD1 (Qiagen PowerSoil Pro), then kit instructions were followed. Extracts were utilized as template for ITS and cox1 PCR amplification, using DreamTaq Mastermix and ITS4/6 (45 cycles; White et al. 1990) and Levup/Levlo primers (30 cycles; Robideau et al. 2011). Cycling conditions were as published, with the number of cycles indicated by primer set. Each reaction yielded a single amplicon of approximately 1000 and 700 bp, for ITS and cox1, respectively,. Amplicons were cleaned using ExoSap-IT and submitted for Sanger sequencing, using ITS6 and Levup as sequencing primers (Robideau et al. 2011; White et al. 1990). After quality trimming, amplicons shared >98.5% identity with H. brassicae (NCBI Genbank accession MG757792 or reference genome CANTFL010000892.1). Sequences were submitted to Genbank (PP093830, PP093831, PP776812, PP776813). This is the first report of downy mildew, caused by H. brassicae, in commercial brassica microgreens, crops with vast nutritional value and expanding production.