An experimental investigation of finger agnosia

K. Poeck,Bernt Orgass

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1212/WNL.19.8.801

IF: 9.9

1969-08-01

Neurology

Abstract:THE SYMPTOM of finger agnosia has been the subject of extensive theoretical considerations. The controversial positions defended by various investigators have been recently reviewed by Bentonl and by Kinsbourne and Warrington.2 It appears from the literature that there does not exist an uncontested definition of this peculiar symptom, nor is there agreement on the appropriate method of testing for it. The original concept suggested by Gerstman$ implies that the essential feature is the inability to differentiate single fingers, either on the patient’s own hand or on the hand of another person. Testing procedures include verbal and nonverbal tasks. Most of these have been assembled by Benton‘ into a comprehensive battery of finger tests. Recently, Kinsbourne and Warrington2 have proposed five new tests, four of which are nonverbal in nature. These tasks require the awareness of the order of the fingers and of the structure of the hand. Apparently, however, these methods are not fully comparable with the clinical methods used to test the identification of single fingers. Previous studies of this problem have been based on single cases or on highly selected groups. The latter holds true also for the 32 subjects examined by Kinsbourne and Warrington. Therefore, it appeared useful to carry out another investigation of finger agnosia using various finger tests, verbal and nonverbal, with a large group of unselected braindamaged patients. The starting point was a study of the so-called Gerstmann ~yndrome.~ In agreement with Benton,s we reached the conclusion that the common denominator of these symptoms is an aphasic disturbance. This view has been corroborated in another study of right-left disorientation,G which is another component of the Gerstmann syndrome.