Abstract:Background: Over the past decade, overlapping procedures in orthopaedic surgery have come under increased public scrutiny. Central to this discussion is what should constitute a "critical portion" of any surgical procedure-a definition which may differ between patients and surgeons. This study therefore aimed to assess which components of three common foot and ankle procedures are considered "critical" from both the patient and surgeon perspectives. Methods: For this survey-based study, questionnaires were administered to patients who presented to an orthopaedic foot and ankle clinic and separately administered to foot and ankle surgeons through e-mail. The questionnaires broached all steps involved in three common foot and ankle procedures: open reduction and internal fixation of ankle fracture, Achilles tendon repair, and ankle arthroscopy. Respondents were asked to characterize each step as "always critical," "often critical," sometimes critical," rarely critical," or "never critical." A combined "always critical" and "often critical" response rate of greater than 50% was used to define a step as genuinely critical. Patient and surgeon responses were thereafter compared using Mann-Whitney U and Kruskal-Wallis tests ( P -value <0.05 was considered significant). Results: Notably, both patients and surgeons considered informed consent, preoperative marking of the surgical site, preoperative time-out, surgical soft-tissue dissection, and certain procedure-specific steps (critical portions) of these procedures. By contrast, only patients considered skin incision and wound closure to be critical steps. Conclusion: Patients and surgeons were largely in agreement as to what should comprise the critical portions of several common foot and ankle procedures. Certain discrepancies did exist, however, such as skin incision and closure, and both groups were also in general agreement regarding what was not considered a critical component of these operations. Such findings highlight a potential opportunity for improved preoperative patient education and patient-physician communication. Level of evidence: Level IV: Evidence from well-designed case-control or cohort studies.

Surgical interventions for ingrown toenail

Ingrown Toenails: A Survey Among Dermatologists on Current Treatments

Comparison of Wedge Resection (winograd Procedure) and Wedge Resection Plus Complete Nail Plate Avulsion in the Treatment of Ingrown Toenails

Neural modification by paired sensory stimuli

Winograd Wedge Resection Matrixectomy versus Partial Nail Avulsion with Chemical Cautery: A Tertiary Institution’s Clinical Outcomes and Proposed Triaging Protocol

A survey of the treatment and management of ingrown toenails by UK podiatrists: A cross‐sectional survey

A guideline on the management of incisions for the enhanced recovery after orthopedic surgery in China

A Comparative Study on the Efficacy between Omega Toenail Correction and Winograd Procedure for Stage II-III Paronychia

A Study on the Efficacy of Ω Toenail Correction Treating Paronychia

A Modified Management of Implant Associated Postoperative Osteomyelitis With Cierny-Mader Type

A new treatment for ingrown toenail with CO2 laser: a retrospective study

Modified Algorithm for Managing Postoperative Osteomyelitis Following Fracture Fixation with Cierny-Mader Type

Critical Portions of a Foot or Ankle Surgical Procedure From Patient and Surgeon Perspectives

The Concept of Treatment for Surgical Infection in the Hindfoot

Wedge Resection and Nail Groove Reconstruction With Hanging Thread Knot in the Treatment of Onychocryptosis

Clinical analysis of incision infections in patients undergoing emergency trauma surgery and prevention measures

A Review of Surgical Incisions Used for the Excision of Benign Parotid Tumors

Treatment of retronychia: A systematic review and suggested treatment algorithm

Evaluation of the Recurrence Rate of Ingrown Toenail After a 45-Second Matrix Cauterization With Phenol

Evaluation of Foot Deformities in Patients With Ingrown Nails

[Translated article] Postoperative Wound Care in Dermatologic Surgery: Update And Narrative Review