Screening for chronic wasting disease in caribou in northern Quebec.
J. Lapointe,D. Leclair,C. Mesher,A. Balachandran
2002-11-01
Abstract:The caribou (Rangifer tarandus) herds of northern Quebec and Labrador are comprised of hundreds of thousands of animals; estimates of the population in the early 1990s yielded over a million subjects (1,2). Thousands are harvested every year, killed by sport hunters (approximately 19 000 during the 2000–2001 season (3)) or slaughtered for food by native peoples (approximately 7000 animals between 1998 and 2000 (unpublished observations, Makivik Corporation)). Chronic wasting disease (CWD) is a transmissible spongiform encephalopathy, endemic in mule deer, white-tailed deer, and Rocky Mountain elk populations in several Rocky Mountain states of the United States, which has recently been identified in captive elk herds and wild deer in western Canada. The apparent geographic spread of CWD and its potential consequences on animal and human health has led to an interest in screening other cervid populations for CWD.
Between March 7 and 12 of 2000, 100 caribou from the Leaf River herd in northern Quebec (Nunavik) were sampled at the mobile meat plant of Mollet Lakes (55° 37′N, 74° 25′W). Caribou were localized by snowmobiles, killed by rifle shot to the head, and bled by jugular venipuncture. Carcasses were then transported by helicopter to the plant, eviscerated, and butchered under the supervision of a veterinarian from the Canadian Food Inspection Agency. The age of each animal was determined by examining thin longitudinal sections of the incisor teeth and counting annual cementum bands. The brains were extracted by sawing the dorsocaudal aspect of the skull and dissecting out the medulla oblongata. Samples of the medulla were fixed in 10% neutral buffered formalin. One section of each sample was taken at or close to the obex, treated in formic acid for 1 h, and then processed and embedded in paraffin. A 4 μm section was stained with hematoxylin-phloxin-saffron for microscopic examination. Another section was stained immunohistochemically for the abnormal prion protein (PrPsc) by using an automated immunostainer and the primary antibody F99/97.6.1 (kindly provided by Dr. K. O'Rourke, United States Department of Agriculture, Pullman, Washington, USA). This antibody has known reactivity against the abnormal prion protein found in mule deer and Rocky Mountain elk with CWD, and in sheep and cattle with scrapie or bovine spongiform encephalopathy (4,5).
The overall male/female sex ratio was 9/1, due to avoidance of slaughtering pregnant females (mandatory during the spring season). Of the 80 animals whose age could be accurately determined, 6% were less than 1 y old, 61% were between 1 and 5 y old, and 33% were older than 5 y. Of the 100 samples of medulla, 5 were rejected because of excessive tissue destruction due to the bullet wound. Of the remaining 95 samples, 3 had minimal histologic lesions, consisting in 1 small focus of gliosis. The others had no significant changes. No positive PrPsc immunostaining was detected in any of the 95 samples.
This study was, to our knowledge, the first survey of caribou in northern Quebec for CWD. Although no histologic or immunohistochemical evidence of CWD was found in our preliminary study, the sample size was small compared with the size of the population of the Leaf River herd, estimated at 260 000 in 1991 (2). For such a population, a random sample of 95 animals is expected to detect the disease if the population prevalence is 6.6% or more (assuming sensitivity and specificity of 99% for the immunohistochemical detection of CWD). In the United States, estimated prevalences for CWD in endemic areas range from 0.5% for elk to 2.1% and 4.9% for white-tailed and mule deer, respectively (6). If CWD were present at comparable prevalence in caribou in northern Quebec, samples of several hundred randomly selected animals would be needed to conclude reliably that the disease was absent. Such larger samples are impractical, due to the many sampling constraints and difficult working conditions at such latitudes. More focussed screenings, for instance, targeting older or debilitated animals, or both, might be more helpful than large-scale sampling. Since meat (and occasionally brain tissue) from large numbers of caribou is consumed by sport hunters and native people every year, a regular screening program for CWD appears warranted.