Abstract:We investigate neural and behavioral aspects of the interrelation between 'liking' and 'understanding' when both appraisals are made within one judgment task. Our goal was to explore questions regarding how these appraisals combine, and specifically whether there is an order-effect when both are employed in sequence. To this end, we tested a hypothesis derived from new models in neuroaesthetics, and concerning processing of art, which suggest that perception may involve a natural sequence from first processing for hedonic quality (i.e., liking) followed by processing for understanding. Thus, due to the initial liking assessment's capacity to prime deepened cognitive involvement, a Liking-Understanding order may show key differences in final assessments or brain activation when compared to an Understanding-Liking sequence. Thirty-two participants evaluated a range of paintings, balanced for visual appeal and understandability, in a two-part task in which half evaluated for understanding followed by liking and the other half had question order reversed. Brain activity was recorded via functional Near Infrared Spectroscopy (fNIRS). Results showed no assessment interrelation or order effect in artwork evaluations. However, participants who began with evaluation for liking, and who came to incongruent combinations (i.e., "I like, but I don't understand" or "I don't like, but I understand"), showed significantly higher activation in left medial prefrontal cortex. This area is functionally associated with attention and integration of hedonic/informational elements. Findings provide tentative support for a liking-driven order-effect, as well as for physiological connection between appraisals, which may not appear in behavioral evidence, and suggest need for further consideration of this topic in appraisal research.

More than meets the gut: a prototype analysis of the lay conceptions of intuition and analysis

Meta‐analytic Investigations of the Relation Between Intuition and Analysis

The Nature and Measurement of Intuition: Cognitive and Behavioral Interests, Personality, and Experiences

What Neuroscience Can Tell about Intuitive Processes in the Context of Perceptual Discovery

Women rely on “gut feeling”? The neural pattern of gender difference in non-mathematic intuition

Priming intuition disfavors instrumental harm but not impartial beneficence

The complementary roles of intuition and logic in creative design ideation.

Holistic View of Intuition and Analysis in Leadership Decision-Making and Problem-Solving

The Mechanism, Effectiveness and Working Condition of Intuition-based Decision---A Theoretical Framework

Intuition Versus Deliberation

Pitting intuitive and analytical thinking against each other: The case of transitivity

Intuition & Calibration

Understand after Like, Viewer'S Delight? A Fnirs Study of Order-Effect in Combined Hedonic and Cognitive Appraisal of Art

Intuition Versus Deliberation How Decision Mode Influences Desirability And Feasibility Preferences

Intuitive Decision-making：Research Status and Prospects

Sensation and Being Within the Horizons of Intuition of Essence--An Analysis of Husserl's Thinking of Intuition

Tempering the tension between science and intuition

How to Analyze (Intentional) Consciousness in Terms of Meta-Belief and Temporal Awareness

Intuition and Surprise

Do smart people have better intuitions?

What's Essence and How Intuitive?——A Rethinking of the Phenomenological Idealism