Overcrowding: emergency departments are the canary in the coal mine and overcrowding is the poisonous gas.

A. Boyle,K. Beniuk

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1097/MEJ.0b013e32833821e5

2010-12-01

European Journal of Emergency Medicine

Abstract:In this issue (pp. 349–353) Dr Gilligan and his team describe the problems of overcrowding in their Irish Emergency Department. The problems they describe are from a single centre, but will touch a raw nerve with every emergency physician in the world. We have all experienced the stress and pressure that an overcrowded emergency department creates. It is beyond question that an overcrowded emergency department impairs the quality of medical and nursing care that we can offer to our patients. Performance against several quality indicators is known to deteriorate when a department is crowded. The problems impact on staff; sickness rates rise and experienced staff leave. It is estimated that each year more people die in Australia because of emergency department overcrowding than on the roads. Dr Gilligan’s team used routinely collected electronic data over a 6-month period to identify the main delays in getting a patient through the emergency department and into the hospital. The mean length of stay of a medical patient arriving in the emergency department was 21 h, and it will not surprise many emergency physicians that the majority of the delay occurred after the patients had undergone emergency and in-patient specialty team assessment. Dr Gilligan and his team conclude that the single biggest contributor to delayed admission is lack of hospital capacity and subsequent access block it creates. Our emergency departments are like the caged canaries. The poisonous gas which stops us singing is the lack of acute hospital capacity. Although this is a single-centre study, the findings are likely to be applicable in emergency departments worldwide.