Risks of Long‐Term Urethral Catheterization
T. Yoshikawa
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1532-5415.1994.tb06518.x
1994-12-01
Journal of the American Geriatrics Society
Abstract:I n the paper in this issue of the Journal entitled Long-term Urethral Catheterization Increases Risk of Chronic Pyelonephritis and Renal lnflammation,' we learn yet another complication associated with chronic indwelling urethral catheterization: pathological evidence of chronic inflammatory reactions in the kidneys with scarring, calyceal damage, interstitial fibrosis, and tubular atrophy. These investigators, as well as others, have already demonstrated the more well known morbidity associated with long-term urinary catheters, ie, acute pyelonephritis, bacteremia/sepsis, urethritis, nephrolithiasis, cystolithiasis, epididymitis, vesicourethral reflux, catheter obstruction, and death.5 Despite these relatively new findings of chronic pyelonephritis and inflammation in patients with long-term urinary catheters, they are not totally surprising. Using the method of antibody-coated bacteria as evidence of upper tract (or deep tissue invasion) urinary infection, earlier reports confirm that bacteriuria of renal origin is not unusual with chronic urinary catheterization." 7 Furthermore, the demonstration by Warren and his colleagues of the high association of chronic pyelonephritis and chronic renal inflammation with long-term obstruction, ie, ureteral dilatation, renal stones, and hydronephrosis, confirms earlier findings that chronic bacteriuria rarely leads to chronic pyelonephritis in the absence of chronic obstruction." Indeed, the patients in Warren et al's study who developed chronic pyelonephritis and renal inflammation were those who had the longest duration of catheterization, ie, those who are at greatest risk of urinary obstruction. From the clinician's perspective, how do these findings translate into any change in clinical practice since many questions remained unanswered or were not addressed? Does chronic urinary catheterization ultimately lead to chronic renal failure? Is there a greater risk of obstruction and, therefore, chronic pyelonephritis with certain bacteria, eg, Proteus sp? Would elimination of organisms that are more likely to cause chronic pyelonephritis reduce this complication? Is there a correlation between frequency of catheter obstruction and chronic pyelonephritis? Despite these unanswered but clinically relevant issues, this study and numerous others provide overwhelming and convincing evidence on the dangers of chronic urinary catheterization to patients, be they young or old. Too often, patients or nursing home residents are catheterized for convenience of care