Social cost accounting for municipal solid waste incineration in Beijing
SONG Guo-jun,SUN Yue-yang,ZHAO Chang,LIU Shuai,WANG Ying
DOI: https://doi.org/10.12062/cpre.20170413
2017-01-01
China Population Resources and Environment
Abstract:China lacks cost accounting of Municipal Solid Waste (MSW) management.The existence of many kinds of hidden subsidies makes the cost underestimated.MSW incineration cost is defined as the cost borne by the society for the incineration and should be calculated according to the market price.Based on the Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) framework,a social cost accounting method was established.The method divided the cost into subsidized and external costs.The former included fixed cost,variable cost,and tax relief,and were calculated using the direct cost method,opportunity cost method and the comparative method.The latter was calculated by the exposure path analysis of the hot spot analysis plan established by the California Environmental Protection Agency.The external cost was represented by the dioxin carcinogenic risk and could be calculated using the Aerodynamic Model (AERMOD),Air Dispersion Modeling & Risk Tool (ADMRT),and ‘ wages-risk’ method.Using the operational data,emission parameters,terrain and meteorological parameters of the three MSW incineration plants operating in Beijing,the social costs were calculated.The results showed that the social cost of MSW incineration in 2015 was 2.04 billion yuan,equivalent to 1 088.5 yuan/t.In the cost,the subsidy accounted for 30％,equivalent to 324.5 yuan/t,and health loss accounted for 70％,equivalent to 752.8 yuan/t.Waste disposal fees and electricity subsidies accounted for 50.2％ and 20％ of the subsidy respectively,which were the main income of the incineration plants.The cost of the whole process of ‘ collection-transfer-incineration’ of MSW management was 4.22 billion yuan,equivalent to 2 253 yuan/t.The cost was much higher than the 40-300 yuarn/t of the disposal fee.The cost of the MSW incineration was huge but most of which was concealed,and there was no specialized discharge standard and health risk evaluation of the hazardous air pollutants in China,which would make the cost of the MSW incineration out of control.The paper proposed following suggestions:First,establishing a social cost accounting standard for the MSW management to promote the cost transparent.Second,setting a cost reduction target for the MSW management,and carrying out the source classification and measurement fee policy to reduce the amount of MSW collected,transported and incinerated.Third,establishing a dangerous air pollutants quantitative risk assessment system and implementing the dioxin reduction.The findings above are meaningful for the changing of the end-based MSW management and the determining the garbage disposal fee.