Abstract:Marine deforestation combined with growing demands from the alginate market, reliant largely on wild kelp harvesting, has heightened concern for the potential broad and cascading effects of kelp removal on ecosystem functioning and services. Kelps are foundation species providing key habitat and resources for other organisms, including other fished species and thus their overharvest is often anticipated to have important and complex ecological and socioeconomical consequences. However, constructing expectations and strategies as to where, when, how, or how much kelp can be safely removed is often difficult to discern from the array of individual research studies quantifying the effects of kelp removal on kelp populations and associated communities because evidence appears mixed and results could depend on kelp species, removal methods and monitoring scales. This review of observational and experimental studies aims to identify and synthesize the effects of kelp removal, their monitoring, and the trends of significant effects. Here we show that monitoring has focused mainly on kelp populations effects, and effects on the local associated algae and sessile fauna. Almost no experiment assessed spatial patterns resulting from kelp removal. Most statistically tested effects of individual studies (64.3% of total) were non-significant. From those considered statistically significant, most (60.1%) showed decreasing trends (e.g., in kelp size, abundance, reproductive potential and the abundance and diversity of some associated taxa). Long-term studies and evaluated responses to kelp removal at the relatively large spatial scales (in extent and grain size) that include the patchy mosaics of kelp forests and critically match the geographic scale over which management strategies are applied were scarce. We note that temporal and spatial monitoring scales appear limited when compared to kelp's lifespan and dispersal potential, as well as the scale of commercial harvest areas. Thus, we seek to call attention to the need for expanding monitoring scales and metrics to better meet the knowledge required to manage kelp forests and fisheries, which becomes urgent in countries where kelp fisheries control is difficult and as the effects could be magnified by climate change.

Complex drivers of invasive macroalgae boom and bust in Kāne'ohe Bay, Hawai'i

Drivers of spatio-temporal variability in a marine foundation species

Kelp dynamics and environmental drivers in the southern Salish Sea, British Columbia, Canada

Macroalgal vegetation on a north European artificial reef (Loch Linnhe, Scotland): biodiversity, community types and role of abiotic factors

Spatiotemporal variability in population demography and morphology of the habitat-forming macroalga Saccorhiza polyschides in the Western English Channel

Macroalgae exhibit diverse responses to human disturbances on coral reefs

Large-scale shift in the structure of a kelp forest ecosystem co-occurs with an epizootic and marine heatwave

Monthly macroalgal surveys reveal a diverse and dynamic community in an urban intertidal zone

A marine heatwave changes the stabilizing effects of biodiversity in kelp forests

A Unique 100 Meter Underwater Survey Method Documents Changes in Abundance, Richness, and Community Structure of Hawaiʹi Reef Fishes

Inshore coral reef sediment and turf dynamics unaffected by canopy-forming macroalgae

Trophic redundancy and predator size class structure drive differences in kelp forest ecosystem dynamics

Consequences of kelp forest ecosystem shifts and predictors of persistence through multiple stressors

Reef on the edge: resilience failure of marginal patch coral reefs in Eastern Arabian Sea under recurrent coral bleaching, coral diseases, and local stressors

Maturing giant kelp develop depth-specific microbiomes

Abalone recruitment patterns before and after sea urchin barrens formation in northern California: incorporating climate change

Rehabilitation of coral reefs through removal of macroalgae: state of knowledge and considerations for management and implementation

Sea otter recovery buffers century-scale declines in California kelp forests

Shifts in foundation species dominance and altered interaction networks after compounding seismic uplift and extreme marine heatwaves

Exploring the consequences of kelp removal: a review shows we are missing a broader perspective

The ecology of giant kelp colonization and its implications for kelp forest restoration