HIV and AIDS, the internet pornography industry and safer sex
S. Green
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1258/095646204322916704
2004-03-01
Abstract:Sir: Reporting two cases of HIV infection resulting from relationships arising out of internet `chat room’ encounters, Tashima and colleagues expressed rightful concern about the lack of HIVprevention efforts targeting internet sex-seekers1. The problem is clearly an important one, and Tashima et al.’s observations should be broadened to include the undeniable reality that the chat room phenomenon is only one part of a much larger entity: the internet sex industry, of which pornography (aka `adult content’) is probably a major part. The ® nancial stakes are huge. In 2000, it was estimated that the internet pornography industry (IPI) accounted for more than 30% of internet traf® c and generated up to US$900 billion in revenues, thus accounting for 13% of all revenue generated on the internet2. However, to quote the 3G Newsroom web site, .̀ . . The adult entertainment industry has to be one of the most odd businesses in the world. It is all about one of the most natural things in the world between being born and dying yet practically no one wants to admit having any knowledge of ever having been near it and to top it all someone is spending tens of billions of Euros a year on it’3. From the British perspective, in 1995 Professor Harold Thimbleby of Middlesex University estimated that around half of all nonacademic internet searches were aimed at locating pornography4,5. Marketing of IPI web sites is relentless, and most people’s e-mail boxes regularly contain `spam’ e-mails advertising pornography. Indeed, even mainstream television and cinema is moving inexorably towards using this type of material. However, despite the enormity and ubiquity of the IPI, scienti® c research into content and its in ̄ uence on behaviour appears relatively scanty (e.g. ref. 6); in particular, there is little or no research regarding the extent to which issues like HIV/ AIDS, sexually transmitted diseases (STDs), safer sex and condom usage feature, if at all, and whether this makes any difference. It was much the same in the past with prostitution, where it took new and imaginative approaches in order to uncover the reality of services offered, the true extent of the HIV transmission risk, and the close links with drug injecting7. Given the modern culture of evidencebased medicine, which is rightly being encouraged8, evidence gathering and analysis are essential before appropriate responses can be planned. There are two parallel adult-content IPIs, the `mainstream’ and the `amateur’. In the USA, the mainstream version has clearly been associated with HIV infection since reports emerged recently of several cases among its star heterosexual performers, and the US `Adult Industry Medical Group’ has been seeking to limit the damage by establishing a robust system of HIV testing and contact tracing9. Similar issues have been the subject of discussion in the UK10. However, the advent of increasingly affordable digital camcorders has lead to the development of a substantial `amateur’ dimension to the industry, even to the extent of people `off the street’, and apparently unknown to each other, joining in with the action. The amateur IPI has enjoyed very little scienti® c attention to date. To start assessing whether or not safer sex messages and/or condom usage are included as part of easily available amateur IPI content, sequential searches (on a standard 800 MHz desktop computer and using GoogleTM 11, currently the UK’s most popular internet search engine) utilizing very simple search strategies to select out appropriate web sites, were conducted intermittently in 2002± 3. The only web sites subjected to study ful® lled the following criteria: (a) Amateur content; (b) Randomly accessible through GoogleTM; (c) Specializing only in mutually consenting adult heterosexual activity; (d) Offering no-cost downloadable material; (e) English language. The results are presented in Table 1. The eight web sites listed are among the commonest `hits’ resulting from simple search strategies, or are linked to the commonest sites. Only these sites were studied in any detail: a great many other web sites of similar type came up, but analysis would require adequate time and resources. No attempt was made to access material for which a fee was being demanded, so this area remains unstudied. All except two of these sites not only generated income through direct payments (usually via credit or debit cards) but also through advertising on the site. In addition, websites synergized by offering links to other, presumably similar, sites. Placing the country of origin of web sites can be dif® cult or impossible, but no sites apparently located outwith of Western Europe or the USA (e.g. in Asia, Eastern Europe, South Africa, or Latin America) appeared to ® t the above criteria. Furthermore, no UK web sites ful® lling the above criteria emerged with simple search strategies, although paying sites do exist. However, web sites do compete vigorously to get selected preferentially by the most important internet search engines, and web masters earn their money by ensuring that their own or their employer’s web sites are most likely to be so favoured, and they employ proven strategies to achieve this aim. International Journal of STD & AIDS 2004; 15: 206–212