Abstract:Explanations of floral adaptation to diverse pollinator faunas have often invoked visitor-mediated trade-offs in which no intermediate, generalized floral phenotype is optimal for pollination success, i.e. fitness valleys are created. In such cases, plant species are expected to specialize on particular groups of flower visitors. Contrary to this expectation, it is commonly observed that flowers interact with various groups of visitors, while at the same time maintaining distinct phenotypes among ecotypes, subspecies, or congeners. This apparent paradox may be due to a gap in our understanding of how visitor-mediated trade-offs could affect floral adaptation. Here we provide a conceptual framework for analysing visitor-mediated trade-offs with the hope of stimulating empirical and theoretical studies to fill this gap. We propose two types of visitor-mediated trade-offs to address negative correlations among fitness contributions of different visitors: visitor-mediated phenotypic trade-offs (phenotypic trade-offs) and visitor-mediated opportunity trade-offs (opportunity trade-offs). Phenotypic trade-offs occur when different groups of visitors impose conflicting selection pressures on a floral trait. By contrast, opportunity trade-offs emerge only when some visitors' actions (e.g. pollen collection) remove opportunities for fitness contribution by more beneficial visitors. Previous studies have observed disruptive selection due to phenotypic trade-offs less often than expected. In addition to existing explanations, we propose that some flowers have achieved 'adaptive generalization' by evolving features to avoid or eliminate the fitness valleys that phenotypic trade-offs tend to produce. The literature suggests a variety of pathways to such 'trade-off mitigation'. Trade-off mitigation may also evolve as an adaptation to opportunity trade-offs. We argue that active exclusion, or floral specialization, can be viewed as a trade-off mitigation, occurring only when flowers cannot otherwise avoid strong opportunity trade-offs. These considerations suggest that an evolutionary strategy for trade-off mitigation is achieved often by acquiring novel combinations of traits. Thus, phenotypic diversification of flowers through convergent evolution of certain trait combinations may have been enhanced not only through adaptive specialization for particular visitors, but also through adaptive generalization for particular visitor communities. Explorations of how visitor-mediated trade-offs explain the recurrent patterns of floral phenotypes may help reconcile the long-lasting controversy on the validity of pollination syndromes.

A functional view of flower-pollinator trait matching. A commentary on 'Mismatching explained: constricted corolla tubes in Roscoea elevate the nectar'

The evolution of flowerâpollinator trait matching, and why do some alpine gingers appear to be mismatched?

Proteomic insights into floral biology

Functional implications of the specialized staminal appendages in alpine ginger (Roscoea spp.: Zingiberaceae)

Effects of anther-stigma position on cross-pollination efficiency in a hermaphroditic plant

Complex interactions underlie the correlated evolution of floral traits and their association with pollinators in a clade with diverse pollination systems

Can trait matching inform the design of pollinator‐friendly urban green spaces? A review and synthesis of the literature

Ginger and the beetle: Evidence of primitive pollination system in a Himalayan endemic alpine ginger (Roscoea alpina, Zingiberaceae)

Armament imbalances: match and mismatch in plant-pollinator traits of highly specialized long-spurred orchids

Reproductive biology of two Himalayan alpine gingers (Roscoea spp., Zingiberaceae) in China: pollination syndrome and compensatory floral mechanisms

Floral morph variation mediated by clonal growth and pollinator functional groups of Limonium otolepis in a heterostylous fragmented population

Mutualist- and antagonist-mediated selection contribute to trait diversification of flowers

Convergent evolutionary patterns of heterostyly across angiosperms support the pollination-precision hypothesis

Mismatch between pollen and pistil size causes asymmetric mechanical reproductive isolation across species

Extensive pollinator sharing does not promote character displacement in two orchid congeners

Trade‐off mitigation: a conceptual framework for understanding floral adaptation in multispecies interactions

Speciation, pattern recognition and the maximization of pollination: general questions and answers given by the reproductive biology of the orchid genus Ophrys

Functional mismatch in a bumble bee pollination mutualism under climate change

Strategies of flowering plants to avoid pollen collection by undesirable flower visitors. A commentary on 'High toxin concentration in pollen may deter collection by bees in butterfly-pollinated Rhododendron molle'

Morphological Trait-Matching in Plant-Hymenoptera and Plant-Diptera Mutualisms Across an Elevational Gradient

Evolution of Autonomous Selfing in Marginal Habitats: Spatiotemporal Variation in the Floral Traits of the Distylous Primula wannanensis