The Brown Kelly-Paterson or Plummer-Vinson Syndrome: An Old Score Finally Settled

S. D. Slater

1991-07-01

Abstract:On St Valentine's Day 1990, the Victoria Infirmary of Glasgow, one of the city's teaching hospitals, celebrated its centenary [1]. Among those of its medical staff who have achieved eminence was its first ear, nose and throat specialist, Dr Adam Brown Kelly, who was appointed in 1892 and retired in 1925. He was a gifted clinical researcher with an international reputation. His name is remembered today for having in 1919 [2] described, alongside Donald Paterson of Cardiff [3], the syndrome of dysphagia (due to upper oesophageal spasm or web), glossitis and anaemia. But were they or the Americans, Plummer and Vinson, the first to do so? It's an old argument, but one that must now be finally settled. Major textbooks usually give pride of place to Plumper and Vinson. Some, including a well-known Edinburgh medical text, do not even mention Brown Kelly and Paterson. (Through such omission the reader can perhaps begin to understand the feud between Glasgow and Edinburgh!) Many present-day English colleagues have not even heard of Brown Kelly or Paterson, but one expects better things of Edinburgh. How then does the local challenge on Brown Kelly's behalf stand up to as impartial a scrutiny as is possible? Brown Kelly himself, a big man in every sense of the Word, was never heard to comment on the issue. I was first led up the garden path by the bible of medical bibliography, 'Garrison and Morton'. This accords priority to Plummer and Vinson, but its refer-