New reproductive technologies: the old quest for fatherhood.

Verena Stolcke

Abstract:Synopsis – Science and technology are not value free. For effective political action we need to know, however, whose interests and which values have informed the development of the new reproductive technologies. In this article I argue at two related levels. I analyze the development of the notions of personhood, parenthood, and reproduction in Western class society. I show that a concept of social status, as in the last instance, determined by one’s genes, underlies an individualized biological understanding of parenthood that accounts, in turn, for the obsession with having a “child of one’s own” if necessary through in vitro fertilization (IVF). Because of this naturalization of parenthood in an unequal society, women are subject to men’s control over their procreative capacity. A modern variant is technological motherhood at the service of men’s quest for biological fatherhood. The same ideology of genetic fitness informs aggressive population control practiced in the Third World that equally maintains the dominance of white Western men.