Low testosterone must explain diminished physical performance in the elderly--right?

P. Snyder

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1210/jc.2010-0957

2010-06-01

Abstract:Physicians and the lay public have long been fascinated by the relationship between testosterone and muscle mass,strength,andphysicalperformance.Allassumethat testosterone increases these parameters. Many athletes, from grammar school students to professionals, take testosterone and other androgens to enhance their performance, and the governing bodies for many sports, assuming that these drugs do increase performance and give theseathletesacompetitiveadvantage,havebannedthem. Only a few studies, however, document that higher than normal amounts of testosterone or other androgens actually do increase muscle strength (1), and none document improvement in athletic performance. It is also commonly assumed that a lower than normal serum testosterone concentration in an adult male will result in less muscle mass and lower muscle strength and physical performance than in a normal adult male. The evidence is quite good, in fact, that when men develop testosterone deficiency due to pituitary or testicular disease, theirmusclemassdecreases,andwhenthesemenaretreated with testosterone, their muscle mass increases (2, 3). Some studies also show that testosterone treatment of frankly hypogonadalmenincreasestheirmusclestrength(4),butothers do not (3). No studies show that testosterone treatment of hypogonadal men improves physical performance. Geriatricians have recently wondered whether the fall in testosterone with aging might contribute to the major public health problem of diminished physical function in theelderly.Documentationofsucharelationshiphasalso been inconsistent, as illustrated by two papers in this month’sissueofJCEM.Krasnoffetal.(5)describeastudy in which they determined the relationship between the serumtestosteroneconcentrationandphysicalfunctionin men participating in the Framingham Offspring Study. In a cross-sectional analysis of 1445 men of average age 61 yr, they found a significant association between the serum free testosterone concentration and walking speed and short performance physical battery, but not between the total testosterone concentration and those physical parameters and not between total or free testosterone and self-reported mobility limitation. In a longitudinal analysis, they found a significant association between the free, butnottotal,testosteroneandsubsequentdevelopmentof self-reportedmobilitylimitation.Inshort,therewassome associationbetweenfreetestosteroneandphysicalperformanceinthispopulation,butnoassociationbetweentotal testosterone and physical performance.