Abstract:In a recent issue of the American Journal of Transplantation, Lynch et al. reported on an analysis of 317 deceased donor kidneys that were preserved using HTK solution and concluded that the success rate of these grafts after 3 years was equivalent to that of 317 historical controls preserved with UW solution (1). We were surprised by the authors’ statement that ‘previous comparisons between UW and HTK in renal transplantation have been limited by small sample size and relatively short follow-up’. Six months prior to the first submission of their manuscript, an article was published in Transplantation in which 53 560 UW-preserved kidneys were compared with 9677 HTKpreserved kidneys, also over a 3-year follow-up (2). The journal Transplantation is known to many members of the international transplant community. In that article, we showed that when cold preservation exceeded 24 h, the graft survival result obtained with HTK solution was statistically significantly inferior to that obtained with UW solution (RR 1.14, p = 0.017). The study of Lynch et al. lacked statistical power to detect a significant difference for ischemia >24 h. This is suggested by the analysis of patient survival presented in Table 2, in which the combination of HTK with >24 h of cold ischemia resulted in a hazard ratio of 1.91 in the absence of statistical significance (1). The result of the same analysis for graft survival was not presented. The use of a historical control group by Lynch et al. poses another problem. When overall graft survival results obtained during different transplant periods are compared, the collaborative transplant study data show a hazard ratio of 1.11 for the comparison of transplants performed 1999–2003 with transplants performed 2004–2007 (the time periods relevant in this case). Consequently, observing equivalent graft outcome in an analysis of preservation methods used during different time periods may reflect inferiority of the method used during the more recent period. We have no affiliation with any manufacturer of preservation solutions and we declare that we have no conflict of interest.

Effect of Methicillin-Resistant Staphylococcus aureus Colonization in the Neonatal Intensive Care Unit on Total Hospital Cost

How Long can a Euclidean Traveling Salesman Tour Be?

3DCellAtlas Meristem: a tool for the global cellular annotation of shoot apical meristems

Live imaging of Arabidopsis shoot primordia via a confocal laser scanning microscope

Cell Signaling in the Shoot Apical Meristem

Live Cell Imaging of Microtubule Cytoskeleton and Micromechanical Manipulation of the Arabidopsis Shoot Apical Meristem.

What maintains noncytoplasmic incompatibility inducing Wolbachia in their hosts: a case study from a natural Drosophila yakuba population

Dicumarol therapy of acute coronary thrombosis.

Stem cells within the shoot apical meristem: identity, arrangement and communication

A single-cell analysis of the Arabidopsis vegetative shoot apex

Risk management, Part one. Recommendations for the freestanding oncology center.

Plasmodesmata-Mediated Cell-to-Cell Communication in the Shoot Apical Meristem: How Stem Cells Talk

A high-resolution gene expression atlas links dedicated meristem genes to key architectural traits

Fibrinolytic therapy for thrombosis in cardiac valvular prosthesis short and long term results.

Transcriptomics Using the Enriched Arabidopsis Shoot Apex Reveals Developmental Priming Genes Involved in Plastic Plant Growth under Salt Stress Conditions

Fundamental mechanisms of the stem cell regulation in land plants: lesson from shoot apical cells in bryophytes

Fluorescent imaging of GUS activity and RT-PCR analysis of gene expression in the shoot apical meristem

Differential regulation of meristem size, morphology and organization by the ERECTA, CLAVATA and class III HD-ZIP pathways

Emerging role of the ubiquitin proteasome system in the control of shoot apical meristem function(f)

Shoot apical meristem maintenance: the art of a dynamic balance

Comparison of Histidine‐Tryptophan‐Ketoglutarate and University of Wisconsin Preservation in Renal Transplantation