Reply: Implementation of a Meningitis Care Bundle in the Emergency Room Reduces Mortality Associated With Acute Bacterial Meningitis.

P. Viale,M. Giannella,S. Tedeschi,M. Bartoletti,F. Pea

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/1060028015615881

Abstract:We thank Dr Pagliano very much for having strengthened the concept that timely administration of antibiotics and immediate supportive management were the key components of the bundle. The observation concerning the management of patients with clear cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) gives us the opportunity to describe the component of the bundle related to these populations, which was not presented in the original article. In all the patients with clear CSF and CSF findings that are not immediately evocative for bacterial meningitis, treatment is started with acyclovir and with high-dose ampicillin. The latter covers specifically Listeria monocytogenes, and this means that there is no risk of inappropriate treatment. The choice of adding levofloxacin to cephalosporins is based mainly on the pharmacokinetic profile of the drug in the central nervous system, with particular regard to the rapid distribution within CSF with favorable area under the curve AUCcsf/AUCserum ratio approximating 0.75 even when the blood brain barrier (BBB) is healing. This choice embraces the concept that appropriateness of antimicrobial therapy should be based not only on the in vitro activity, but also on optimal drug exposure at the infection site, which ultimately represents the modern approach to the management of severe infections. Finally, although we theoretically agree with the methodological concern regarding the use of historical controls, it should not be overlooked that this was the only way we had to carry out a comparison between different modalities of management. In fact, any attempt at randomization was unfeasible, both from ethical and practical points of view. Additionally, when looking at the table comparing demographic, clinical, and laboratory data between the 2 groups at presentation, it appears that no striking differences existed. Therefore, the concern is probably unjustified. The improvement in clinical care management is not to be considered as a bias because it is part of the bundle. Regarding the statement on vaccination policies, we deem that they do not concern meningitis care but rather meningitis prevention. Finally, although we agree with the affirmation that the clinical value of faster treatment has just been demonstrated, we regret to report that the key message of our experience was not fully perceived—namely, that the prompt administration of antibiotics in the emergency department prior to lumbar puncture (LP) did not affect the yield of CSF culture. This finding offers the opportunity of considering that immediate administration of antimicrobial treatment at the first point of care, irrespective of the time needed for having LP, could be the best way to approach every patient with suspected acute meningitis in real life.