Patient care and clinical outcomes for patients with COVID-19 infection admitted to African high-care or intensive care units (ACCCOS): a multicentre, prospective, observational cohort study
African COVID-19 Critical Care Outcomes Study (ACCCOS) Investigators,Bruce M Biccard,Pragasan Dean Gopalan,Malcolm Miller,William Lance Michell,David Thomson,Adesoji Ademuyiwa,Ernest Aniteye,Greg Calligaro,Maman Sani Chaibou,Hailu Tamiru Dhufera,Mohamed Elfagieh,Mahmoud Elfiky,Muhammed Elhadi,Maher Fawzy,David Fredericks,Meseret Gebre,Abebe Genetu Bayih,Anneli Hardy,Ivan Joubert,Fitsum Kifle,Hyla-Louise Kluyts,Kieran Macleod,Zelalem Mekonnen,Mervyn Mer,Atilio Morais,Vanessa Msosa,Wakisa Mulwafu,Andrew Ndonga,Zipporah Ngumi,Akinyinka Omigbodun,Christian Owoo,Fathima Paruk,Jenna Louise Piercy,Yakob Seman,Elliott H Taylor,Dawid van Straaten,Ahmed Awad,Hend Hussein,Mahmoud Shaban,Merihan Elbadawy,Ahmed O Elmehrath,Ahmed Cordie,Mohamed Elganainy,Mostafa El-Shazly,Mahmoud Essam,Omar A Abdelwahab,Aboubakr Ali,Aliae Mohamed Hussein,Emad Zarief Kamel,Fatma A Monib,Islam Ahmed,Mahmoud M Saad,Mohammed Ali Al-Quossi,Nashwa Rafaat,Islam Galal,Beshoui Labib,Dalia Omran Omran,Ahmed Azzam,Mohammed Azab,Sherief Ghozy,Ahmed Tawheed,Mahmoud Gamal,Mohamed El Kassas,Aml Azzam,Neama Ahmed,Yasmin NasrEldin,Ali Abdelsalam,Omar Abdewahab,Omar Elmandouh,Abebe Addisie,Akine Eshete,Kokeb Desita,Hiruy Araya,Yared Agidew,Addisu Desalegn Andabo,Emnet Tesfaye,Elias Ali Yesuf,Gelaw Hailemariam,Habtamu Sime,Dame Fikadu Keneni,Menbeu Sultan Mohammed,Yemane Gebremedhin,Yoseph Taye,Tamiru Assefa Mebrate,Tirunesh Busha Gemechu,Tigist Tesfaye Bedane,Elias Tewabe Abera,Ayele Teshome,Alfred Doku,Jane Sandra Afriyie-Mensah,Aba Lawson,Daniel Akwanfo Sottie,Emma Addae,Ernest Ofosu-Appiah,William Obeng,Anne Mugera,Caesar Bitta,Mohammed Abdalraheem Huwaysh,Mohammed Mahdi Ali Yahya,Alsnosy Abdullah Khalefa Mohammed,Amrajaa Alsalihin Mohammed Majeed,Amkhatirah Emad Mousay Mohammed,Elsalhein Majeed,Abdurraouf A Abusalama,Ehab Altayr,Taha Abubaker,Akram Mohammed Alkaseek,Butaina Abdulhafith,Zainab Alziyituni,Marwa F Gamra,Mohamed Muftah Anaiba,Samer Khel,Mohammed Abdelkabir,Saedah Abdeewi,Safia Adam,Abdulmueti Alhadi,Ahmed Alsoufi,Muhannad Binnawara,Ahmed Msherghi,Ahmad Elmabri Mohammad Bouhuwaish,Ahmed Sa Taher,Francis Masoo,Singatiya Stella Chikumbanje,Palesa Chisala,Delia Mabedi,Antonio Carlos,Cesaltina Lorenzoni,Jorge Mambo,Isabel Isabel Chissaque,Mouzinho Mouzinho Saide,Maikassoua Mamane,Foumakoye Amadou,Adesoji Ademuyiwa Adesoji Ademuyiwa,Akinyinka Omigbodun Akinyinka Omigbodun,Ademola Adeyeye,Akinola Akinmade,Yakubu Momohsani,John Bamigboye,Donald Orshio,Erdoo Suckie Isamade,Henry Embu,Samuel Nuhu,Samuel Ojiakor,Ahmed Nuhu,Salisu Kwayabura,Adeola Fowotade,Arinola Sanusi,Babatunde Osinaike,Olusola Idowu,Olukemi Adekanmbi,Abdullahi Oteikwu Amali,Sanusi Ibrahim,Adamu Abba Adamu,Ibrahim Kida,Job Otokwala,Olubusola Alagbe-Briggs,Sylvanus Ojum,Juan Scribante,Ismail Sikander Kalla,Aurence Mdladla,Tebogo Mabotja,Ria Naidoo,Roel Matos-Puig,Arisha Ramkillawan,Michelle Smith,Christel Arnold-Day,Jagga Jagga,Jenna Piercy,Lance Michell,Liam Devenish,Nicole Fernandes,Santosh Pershad,Nicola Grabowski,Mapule Rammego,Sabelo Zwane,Masikhanyise Elizabeth Dhlamini,Matthew Neuhoff,Tobisa Fodo,Anthony Usenbo,Busisiwe Mrara,Freddy Kabambi,Estie Cloete,Leonel De Caires,Roger Dickerson,Candice Louw,Alida Theron,Ryan Herselman,Jannes Badenhorst,Godfrey Moletsane,Helene Loots,Frans Christiaan Vorster,Julian Chausse,Melinda Sebastian,Paul Rheeder,Wesley van Hougenhouck-Tulleken,Carin Snyman,Durotolu Adeleke,Jovan Esterhuizen,Leoni de Man,Matema Mosola,Pieter van der Linde,Reinier Swart,Shaun Maasdorp,Tina Martins,Veneshree Govender
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(21)00441-4
2021-05-22
Abstract:Background: There have been insufficient data for African patients with COVID-19 who are critically ill. The African COVID-19 Critical Care Outcomes Study (ACCCOS) aimed to determine which resources, comorbidities, and critical care interventions are associated with mortality in this patient population. Methods: The ACCCOS study was a multicentre, prospective, observational cohort study in adults (aged 18 years or older) with suspected or confirmed COVID-19 infection who were referred to intensive care or high-care units in 64 hospitals in ten African countries (ie, Egypt, Ethiopia, Ghana, Kenya, Libya, Malawi, Mozambique, Niger, Nigeria, and South Africa). The primary outcome was in-hospital mortality censored at 30 days. We studied the factors (ie, human and facility resources, patient comorbidities, and critical care interventions) that were associated with mortality in these adult patients. This study is registered on ClinicalTrials.gov, NCT04367207. Findings: From May to December, 2020, 6779 patients were referred to critical care. Of these, 3752 (55·3%) patients were admitted and 3140 (83·7%) patients from 64 hospitals in ten countries participated (mean age 55·6 years; 1890 [60·6%] of 3118 participants were male). The hospitals had a median of two intensivists (IQR 1-4) and pulse oximetry was available to all patients in 49 (86%) of 57 sites. In-hospital mortality within 30 days of admission was 48·2% (95% CI 46·4-50·0; 1483 of 3077 patients). Factors that were independently associated with mortality were increasing age per year (odds ratio 1·03; 1·02-1·04); HIV/AIDS (1·91; 1·31-2·79); diabetes (1·25; 1·01-1·56); chronic liver disease (3·48; 1·48-8·18); chronic kidney disease (1·89; 1·28-2·78); delay in admission due to a shortage of resources (2·14; 1·42-3·22); quick sequential organ failure assessment score at admission (for one factor [1·44; 1·01-2·04], for two factors [2·0; 1·33-2·99], and for three factors [3·66, 2·12-6·33]); respiratory support (high flow oxygenation [2·72; 1·46-5·08]; continuous positive airway pressure [3·93; 2·13-7·26]; invasive mechanical ventilation [15·27; 8·51-27·37]); cardiorespiratory arrest within 24 h of admission (4·43; 2·25-8·73); and vasopressor requirements (3·67; 2·77-4·86). Steroid therapy was associated with survival (0·55; 0·37-0·81). There was no difference in outcome associated with female sex (0·86; 0·69-1·06). Interpretation: Mortality in critically ill patients with COVID-19 is higher in African countries than reported from studies done in Asia, Europe, North America, and South America. Increased mortality was associated with insufficient critical care resources, as well as the comorbidities of HIV/AIDS, diabetes, chronic liver disease, and kidney disease, and severity of organ dysfunction at admission. Funding: The ACCCOS was partially supported by a grant from the Critical Care Society of Southern Africa.