Abstract:Background Speech and language therapists (SLTs) regularly use phonetic transcription to record and analyse typical and disordered speech. Phonetic transcription is highly demanding of auditory perceptual skills so researchers are sceptical about its accuracy and reliability. The literature describes how phonetic transcription is prone to auditory illusions and biases, such as a preference to transcribe speech sounds from the transcriber's own language. Few empirical research studies have calculated agreement amongst transcribers where a range of agreement scores have been reported (51%–97%). There is a consensus that agreement rates decrease as phonetic detail increases. Vowels and consonants are characterised by different perceptual features within the International Phonetic Alphabet (IPA) so they may differ in agreement rates, and thus far there is contradictory evidence as to whether vowels or consonants are more agreed upon. Transcription agreement studies to date have most commonly recruited phoneticians rather than SLTs so further research is warranted to determine transcription agreement amongst SLTs and its impact on clinical practice. Aims The study's primary aim was to calculate agreement scores from a group of English‐speaking SLTs who transcribed disordered speech samples in an ecologically valid setting. The study also sought to contribute to the pre‐existing contradictory evidence base regarding whether vowels or consonants may be more agreed upon by comparing their agreement scores. The researcher aimed to comment on SLTs' use of diacritics and non‐native speech symbols (symbols not included in the English phonetic inventory) in terms of their frequency and agreement of use. By analysing transcriptions, the study aimed to discuss the impact transcription variability has on speech sound error patterns and thus its impact on clinical decision‐making such as diagnosis, choice of intervention and therapy targets. Methods Twelve paediatric SLTs were recruited via a convenience sample at two National Health Service trusts, two of whom were specialists in Speech Sound Disorders (SSDs). Participants transcribed 16 words from a video of a boy with disordered speech completing the Diagnostic Evaluation of Articulation and Phonology (DEAP, Dodd et al., 2006) from a telehealth appointment. The use of diacritics and non‐English IPA symbols were manually analysed. A classic agreement score was calculated for each target word using a Python script, and then for vowels and consonants in isolation. Datasets were manually analysed to determine whether differences in transcription resulted in the identification of different speech sound error patterns. The researcher considered the implications this had within clinical practice. Results The average classic agreement score was 56.3%. Consonants were more agreed upon than vowels with agreement scores of 62.8% and 48.6%, respectively. Nine participants (75%) used diacritics (most commonly length marks) and eight participants (67%) transcribed non‐native IPA symbols at least once in their datasets, but generally with low frequencies and agreements amongst their use. Transcriptions captured the occurrence of typical and atypical error patterns but only three error patterns, out of the 20 identified, were present in all 12 participants' transcriptions. Conclusions The agreement score of 56.3% questions the accuracy and reliability of transcription amongst SLTs which is an essential skill of the profession. The findings highlight SLTs should be more cautious of interpreting vowels than consonants given lower agreement rates. The frequency of use of non‐native symbols and diacritics was relatively low which could reflect a low accuracy of their use or reduced confidence in transcribing these. The study discussed how variations in transcriptions can impact phonological and phonetic analysis, which in turn can influence clinical decision‐making such as diagnosing SSDs, selecting further diagnostic assessments and choosing therapy targets and interventions. The Royal College of Speech and Language Therapists‐endorsed transcription guidelines (Child Speech Disorder Research Network, 2017) could be revised to convey realistic expectations of SLTs' transcription skills, or SLTs should be offered more training to improve transcription skills to meet current expectations. Other suggestions to improve transcription accuracy are discussed such as via instrumental methods, yet these come with their own limitations such as practicality, costs and need for specialist training. WHAT THIS PAPER ADDS What is already known on this subject Phonetic transcription is highly demanding of human perceptual skills, and researchers are sceptical about its reliability. There are few empirical research studies calculating agreement amongst transcribers, and a range of agreement scores have been reported (51%−97%) dependent on the res -Abstract Truncated-

Dynamic association between phonemic awareness and disordered speech recognition moderated by transcription training

Learner training for phonetic transcription of typical and/or disordered speech: A scoping review

The agreement of phonetic transcriptions between paediatric speech and language therapists transcribing a disordered speech sample

Investigating Perception to Production Transfer in Children With Cochlear Implants: A High Variability Phonetic Training Study

Sustainable Benefits of High Variability Phonetic Training in Mandarin-speaking Kindergarteners With Cochlear Implants: Evidence From Categorical Perception of Lexical Tones

High variability phonetic training facilitates perception-to-production transfer in Mandarin-speaking children with cochlear implants: An acoustic investigation

Benefits of phoneme discrimination training in a randomized controlled trial of 50- to 74-year-olds with mild hearing loss

Directing Attention During Perceptual Training: A Preliminary Study Of Phonetic Learning In Southern Min By Mandarin Speakers

Evaluation of Benefits from a Computer-Aided Pronunciation Training System for German Learners of Mandarin Chinese

Remediation of a phonological representation deficit in Chinese children with dyslexia: A comparison between metalinguistic training and working memory training

High-Variability Phonetic Training Benefits Lexical Tone Perception: An Investigation on Mandarin-Speaking Pediatric Cochlear Implant Users

Unsupervised Training With Directed Manual Transcription For Recognising Mandarin Broadcast Audio

Auditory Temporal Perceptual Learning and Transfer in Chinese-speaking Children with Developmental Dyslexia.

Grading the Severity of Mispronunciations in CAPT Based on Statistical Analysis and Computational Speech Perception

Perceptual Training Facilitates Mandarin Tone Production for Preschoolers with Cochlear Implants: Evidence from Acoustic Analysis

Computer-based auditory phoneme discrimination training improves speech recognition in noise in experienced adult cochlear implant listeners

Effects of training in voice auditory‐perceptual skills

Cross-linguistic Influence of Phonological Awareness and Phonological Recoding Skills in Chinese Reading Acquisition among Early Adolescent Students

[Relationships of Electrophysiological Characteristic Between Speech Evoked Auditory Brainstem Response and Auditory Mismatch Negativity].

Study about Chinese Speech Synthesis Algorithm and Acoustic Model Based on Wireless Communication Network

Visualization of Speech Perception Analysis via Phoneme Alignment: A Pilot Study