- PRELIMINARY AND INCOMPLETE , DO NOT CITE-Does Professor Quality Matter ? Evidence from Random Assignment of Students to Professors Nov 29 , 2007

S. Carrell
Abstract:This study uses the random assignment of college students to professors to examine how professor quality affects student performance free from selection bias into course and section. Results show there are large differences in student performance across professors in the contemporaneous course being taught. A one-standard deviation increase in the professor fixed effect results in a 0.17-standard deviation increase in student grades. We also exploit the fact that students must take numerous follow-on related courses to measure the persistence of the initial course professor fixed effects in follow-on course performance. We find Calculus I professors significantly affect student performance in follow-on courses in mathematics, science and engineering. However, our results offer an interesting puzzle as the professors who produce students that perform well in Calculus I, produce students who perform worse in the follow-on related courses. To explore this finding further, we examine the observable attributes of the calculus professors. Results show that academic rank is negatively correlated with contemporaneous student performance, but positively related to follow-on course performance. That is, the younger, less educated instructors produce students who perform better in calculus, but perform significantly worse in the follow-on advanced mathematics-related courses. The views expressed in this article are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of the United States Air Force, Department of Defense, or the U.S. Government. JEL Classifications: I20
What problem does this paper attempt to address?