Abstract:Importance: Adverse life experiences have been proposed to contribute to diverse mental health problems through an association with corticolimbic functioning. Despite compelling evidence from animal models, findings from studies in humans have been mixed; activation likelihood estimation (ALE) meta-analyses have failed to identify a consistent association of adverse events with brain function. Objective: To investigate the association of adversity exposure with altered brain reactivity using multilevel kernel density analyses (MKDA), a meta-analytic approach considered more robust than ALE to small sample sizes and methodological differences between studies. Data sources: Searches were conducted using PsycInfo, Medline, EMBASE, and Web of Science from inception through May 4, 2022. The following search term combinations were used for each database: trauma, posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD), abuse, maltreatment, poverty, adversity, or stress; and functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) or neuroimaging; and emotion, emotion regulation, memory, memory processing, inhibitory control, executive functioning, reward, or reward processing. Study selection: Task-based fMRI studies within 4 domains (emotion processing, memory processing, inhibitory control, and reward processing) that included a measure of adverse life experiences and whole-brain coordinate results reported in Talairach or Montreal Neurological Institute space were included. Conference abstracts, books, reviews, meta-analyses, opinions, animal studies, articles not in English, and studies with fewer than 5 participants were excluded. Data extraction and synthesis: Using the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses reporting guideline, 2 independent reviewers assessed abstracts and full-text articles for entry criteria. A third reviewer resolved conflicts and errors in data extraction. Data were pooled using a random-effects model and data analysis occurred from August to November 2022. Main outcomes and measures: Peak activation x-axis (left-right), y-axis (posterior-anterior), and z-axis (inferior-superior) coordinates were extracted from all studies and submitted to MKDA meta-analyses. Results: A total of 83 fMRI studies were included in the meta-analysis, yielding a combined sample of 5242 participants and 801 coordinates. Adversity exposure was associated with higher amygdala reactivity (familywise error rate corrected at P < .001; x-axis = 22; y-axis = -4; z-axis = -17) and lower prefrontal cortical reactivity (familywise error rate corrected at P < .001; x-axis = 10; y-axis = 60; z-axis = 10) across a range of task domains. These altered responses were only observed in studies that used adult participants and were clearest among those who had been exposed to severe threat and trauma. Conclusions and relevance: In this meta-analysis of fMRI studies of adversity exposure and brain function, prior adversity exposure was associated with altered adult brain reactivity to diverse challenges. These results might better identify how adversity diminishes the ability to cope with later stressors and produces enduring susceptibility to mental health problems.

Functional neuroimaging of resilience to trauma: convergent evidence and challenges for future research

Neurobiology and systems biology of stress resilience

The interaction effect of high social support and resilience on functional connectivity using seed-based resting-state assessed by 7-Tesla ultra-high field MRI

An FMRI Meta-Analysis of Childhood Trauma

Neuroimaging of posttraumatic stress disorder in adults and youth: progress over the last decade on three leading questions of the field

Autonomic and Brain Morphological Predictors of Stress Resilience

Extended functional connectivity of convergent structural alterations among individuals with PTSD: a neuroimaging meta-analysis

Structural Brain Correlates of Adolescent Resilience

Adverse Life Experiences and Brain Function: A Meta-Analysis of Functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging Findings

Using fMRI connectivity to define a treatment-resistant form of post-traumatic stress disorder

Neurocognitive Mechanism of Human Resilience: A Conceptual Framework and Empirical Review

Neural network modulation by trauma as a marker of resilience: differences between veterans with posttraumatic stress disorder and resilient controls

What Doesn’t Kill Us Makes Us Stronger: Insights from Neuroscience Studies and Molecular Genetics

Neural signatures of human psychological resilience driven by acute stress

The AURORA Study: a longitudinal, multimodal library of brain biology and function after traumatic stress exposure

Progress in Functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging of Emotion Dysregulation Due to Traumatic Brain Injury

Functional neuroimaging studies of post-traumatic stress disorder

A Multiscale Integrated Approach to Study Functional Connectivity

Cortical morphological changes and associated transcriptional signatures in post-traumatic stress disorder and psychological resilience

Identifying Cortical Structure Markers of Resilience to Adversity in Young People using Surface-Based Morphometry

Neurobehavioral moderators of post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) trajectories: study protocol of a prospective MRI study of recent trauma survivors