Stress Radiographs in the Diagnosis of Lateral Instability of the Ankle and Hindfoot

M. Harper

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/107110079201300801

1992-10-01

Foot & Ankle

Abstract:Inversion instability of the foot and ankle, although widely studied, remains somewhat of an enigma. Efforts to quantitate normal and abnormal ranges of tilting and shift of the talus within the ankle mortise via stress radiographs have resulted in variable findings. Although usually recommended and commonly used, stress radiographs have been noted by several authors to poorly correlate with clinical syndromes. Rubin and Witten 13 found greater than 10° of talar tilt in only three of 12 patients with symptoms of instability. Johannsen" reported stress radiographs to be normal in 25% of ankles with verified ligament disruptions and Kristiansen10 found only 29% of functionally and clinically unstable ankles to have abnormal inversion stress radiographs. The abandonment of stress radiography with indications for surgery being based on symptoms and clinical evidence has been reported by Chrisman and snook" and others.' ,5 Realizing that severe lateral ligament injuries may disrupt not only the ligamentous support of the ankle but also that of the subtalar joint, investigators have sporadically focused on the hindfoot as a site of possible occult instability. Laurin et at." emphasized the importance of the calcaneofibular ligament as a stabilizer of the subtalar joint and described a special radiographic technique for Visualizing the opening of this joint laterally with inversion stressing. This technique involves positioning the extremity in internal rotation with the x-ray beam centered on the sinus tarsi at an angle of approximately 30° to 40° off the vertical while inversion stress is applied. This socalled stress Broden's view was noted to demonstrate the posterior facet of the subtalar joint, with parallelism of the articular surfaces being maintained in intact cadaver specimens even in extreme inversion. A loss of parallelism with opening of the joint laterally became