Different Intensities of Evening Exercise on Sleep in Healthy Adults: A Systematic Review and Network Meta-Analysis
Tian Yue,Xuefang Liu,Qi Gao,Yan Wang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2147/NSS.S388863
2022-12-14
Nature and Science of Sleep
Abstract:Tian Yue, &ast Xuefang Liu, &ast Qi Gao, Yan Wang School of Sports Medicine and Rehabilitation, Beijing Sport University, Beijing, People's Republic of China &astThese authors contributed equally to this work Correspondence: Yan Wang, School of Sports Medicine and Rehabilitation, Beijing Sport University, No. 48 Xinxi Road, Haidian District, Beijing, People's Republic of China, Tel +86 15201061266, Email The effects of different intensities of evening exercise on subsequent sleep remain contradictory. Thus, this systematic review and network meta-analysis aimed to compare and rank the effects of different intensities of acute evening exercise on sleep in healthy adults with good sleep. Articles were systematically searched journals indexed in the PubMed, Web of Science, Cochrane Library, Embase, and Scopus databases from inception to the 5th of May, 2022. The basic search terms included exercise, sleep and timing, which were combined with AND. Of the 12,203 retrieved, twenty-eight studies with 325 participants met the inclusion criteria. Results revealed that there were no significant differences in terms of impacts on sleep caused by different intensities of acute evening exercise, except that when compared to no exercise, acute evening high-intensity exercise decreased rapid eye movement sleep (mean difference [MD] = − 1.95%, 95% credible interval [CI] = − 3.58 to − 0.35). Compared to no exercise, acute evening moderate-intensity exercise was ranked as the most potential method to improve sleep, displaying a trend to improve wake time after sleep onset (MD = − 2.50 min, 95% CI = − 8.17 to 1.62), sleep efficiency (MD = +0.41%, 95% CI = − 0.71 to 1.66), the proportion of stage N1 (MD = − 0.72%, 95% CI = − 2.08 to 0.71) and N3 sleep (slow-wave sleep) (MD = +0.84%, 95% CI = − 1.17 to 2.78). Acute evening low-intensity exercise displayed the greatest tendency to shorten sleep onset latency (MD = − 1.02 min, 95% CI = − 4.39 to 2.50) compared to no exercise. Overall, regardless of intensity, acute evening exercise completed before bedtime does not disrupt subsequent sleep in healthy young and middle-aged adults. Keywords: evening exercise, sleep quality, exercise intensity, systematic review, network meta-analysis Sleep and exercise play the vital role in maintaining human health. The prevalence of insomnia ranges from 10% to 30% in the general population, 1 increasing the risk of variable diseases and affecting life expectancy. 2–5 Exercise has been proven to be a low-cost and effective way to improve sleep. 6,7 A previous systematic review and meta-analysis showed regular exercise and daytime acute exercise had beneficial effects on sleep quality. 8 Time-use epidemiology showed that exercising and sleeping time competed with each other in daily life. 9 Lack of time has become an obstacle hindering people's exercise. 10 Exercise in the evening progressively becomes a good option for people burdened with day-to-day work. The appearance of 24-hour gym also provides the environment for evening exercise. 11 Nonetheless, the American Academy of Sleep Medicine (AASM) does not recommend exercising in the evening as it would cause arousal and disrupt subsequent sleep. 12 A cross-sectional study found that most people reported that evening exercise did not disrupt their sleep. 13 Some studies also showed that exercise in the evening did not disrupt sleep but rather had small to moderate beneficial effects on sleep. Dworak et al found that compared to no exercise, only acute evening high-intensity exercise (HIE) made the positive modification to sleep efficiency (SE), sleep onset latency (SOL) and slow-wave sleep (SWS) while evening moderate-intensity exercise (MIE) had no significant effects on sleep in children. 14 Not inconsistent with Dworak et al, Oda and Shirakawa suggested acute evening HIE delayed sleep onset (+ 14 min), shortened total sleep time (TST) and decreased SE in active young adults, whereas evening MIE did not disrupt sleep. 15 The level of delayed sleep onset found by Oda and Shirakawa was greater than that previously reported in the study of Browman and Tepas (+6.5min). 16 Ramos-Campo et al recruited recreational ultra-endurance male runners to conduct acute morning MIE, morning HIE, evening MIE and evening HIE in a random sequence. A significantly higher average time of each awakening was observed in acute evening HIE than in the other three interventions. 17 The result of Ramos-Campo et al study suggested that exercise intensity was as important as training time in the evening or the morning. 17 Actually, the effects of different evening exercise intensities on sleep are still a hot spot, leading to debates. Vla -Abstract Truncated-
neurosciences,clinical neurology