Abstract:Background: Improving the neighborhood environment may help address chronic disease and mortality. To identify neighborhood features that are predictors of health, objective assessments of the environment are used. Multiple studies have reported on cross-sectional assessments of health-related neighborhood features using direct observation. As study designs expand to better understand causation and predictors of change, there is a need to test whether direct observation methods are adequate for longitudinal assessment. To our knowledge, this is the first study to report on the reliability of repeated measurements of the neighborhood environment, and their stability, over time. Methods: The Pittsburgh Hill/Homewood Research on Neighborhood Change and Health (PHRESH) study conducted longitudinal assessments in two low-income, African American neighborhoods at three waves (years 2012, 2015, 2017). The PHRESH audit tool is a modification of earlier validated tools, with an emphasis on environment features relevant for physical activity, sleep, and obesogenic behaviors. Trained data-collector pairs conducted direct observations of a 25% sample of street segments in each neighborhood. At each wave, we audited a sub-sample of street segments twice and assessed reliability using percentage inter-observer agreement and krippendorf's alpha statistics. Stability of these items was assessed as exhibiting moderate or high agreement at every time point. Results: Across waves, a majority (81%) of the items consistently demonstrated moderate to high agreement except for items such as public/communal space, amount of shade, sidewalk features, number of traffic lanes, garden/flower bed/planter, art/statue/monument, amount of trash, and physical disorder. The list of items with poor agreement includes features that are easy to miss (e.g. flower bed/planter), hard to assess from outside (e.g. public/communal space), or may change quickly (e.g. amount of trash). Conclusion: In this paper, we have described implementation methods, reliability results and lessons learned to inform future studies of change. We found the use of consistent methods allowed us to conduct reliable, replicable longitudinal assessments of the environment. Items that did not exhibit stability are less useful for detecting real change over time. Overall, the PHRESH direct observation tool is an effective and practical instrument to detect change in the neighborhood environment.

Perceptions of greenspace and social determinants of health across the life course: The Life Course Sociodemographics and Neighborhood Questionnaire (LSNEQ)

Neighbourhood Walkability and Greenness Exhibit Different Associations with Social Participation in Older Males and Females: An Analysis of the CLSA

How the Urban Neighborhood Environment Influences the Quality of Life of Chinese Community-Dwelling Older Adults: An Influence Model of “NE-QoL”

Individual and Neighborhood Level Predictors of Children's Exposure to Residential Greenspace

Perceived neighborhood environment walkability and health-related quality of life among predominantly Black and Latino adults in New York City

Perceived Health Status and Leisure-time Utilization among Older Adults Living in Urban and Rural Communities: The Moderating Effect of Neighborhood Social Cohesion

Linking green space to neighborhood social capital in older adults: The role of perceived safety

Multiple Linear Regression-Structural Equation Modeling Based Development of the Integrated Model of Perceived Neighborhood Environment and Quality of Life of Community-Dwelling Older Adults: A Cross-Sectional Study in Nanjing, China

Urban Greenspace and Mental Health in Chinese Older Adults: Associations Across Different Greenspace Measures and Mediating Effects of Environmental Perceptions.

A community cohort study about childhood social and economic circumstances: racial/ethnic differences and associations with educational attainment and health of older adults

Preliminary Insights from a Multi-Level Trial

Conceptual Model among Neighborhood Environment, Personal Competence, and Quality of Life of Older Adults Aging in Place: Based on "the Ecological Theory of Aging"

Objectively-Measured Neighbourhood Attributes as Correlates and Moderators of Quality of Life in Older Adults with Different Living Arrangements: The ALECS Cross-Sectional Study

Sensory Health Among Older Adults in the United States: A Neighborhood Context Approach

Examining Older Adults’ Perspectives on the Built Environment and Correlates of Healthy Aging in an American Age-Friendly Community

An audit tool for longitudinal assessment of the health-related characteristics of urban neighborhoods: implementation methods and reliability results

Perceptions of the Neighborhood Built Environment for Walking Behavior in Older Adults Living in Close Proximity

Association Between Social and Built Environments and Leisure-Time Physical Activity among Chinese Older Adults - a Multilevel Analysis

A Conceptual Model of Leisure Time Physical Activity, Neighborhood Environment, and Sense of Community

Examining the importance of neighborhood natural, and built environment factors in predicting older adults' mental well-being: An XGBoost-SHAP approach

Neighborhood Environments and Healthy Life Expectancy in Older Adults: A 6-year Longitudinal Cohort Study Based on Data from the Japan Gerontological Evaluation Study