Effect of introduction pathways on the invasion success of non-native plants along environmental gradients

Marc Riera,Joan Pino,Llorenç Sáez,Pere Aymerich,Yolanda Melero

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10530-024-03270-0

2024-02-27

Biological Invasions

Abstract:Abstract Our understanding on the role of introduction pathways on plant invasions is incomplete because their interaction with other factors remains poorly studied. We contributed to filling this knowledge gap, by analysing temporal trends in pathway importance, pathway-specific differences in the invaded niche, and the effect of pathways on invasion success. We used the non-native flora of Catalonia (NE Spain) as a study system. The contribution of pathways to the non-native flora interacted with time: from before 1500 to the present, gardening replaced agriculture as the main donor of new plants, while the contribution of unintentional introductions fluctuated without a consistent trend. Among neophytes (plants introduced after 1500), introduction pathways influenced differences mainly in habitat type, and secondarily in elevation: natural habitats and high elevation promoted invasion by gardening plants over unintentionally introduced ones. These nuances were unrelated to interactions between environmental variables. Among neophytes, invasion success was unrelated to pathways and interactions between pathways and traits, but was positively related to minimum residence time: older introductions achieved greater area of occupancy, habitat range, and invaded climatic niche breadth. Our results suggest that non-native plants diversified their niches over time (1500-present), a process that resulted in similar area of occupancy and niche breadth across plants with different introduction pathways. This was accompanied by pathway-specific nuances in the type of invaded environmental conditions.

biodiversity conservation,ecology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### Problems the Paper Attempts to Solve

This paper aims to explore the impact of introduction pathways on the success of non-native plant invasions and analyze how these impacts change over time and environmental gradients. Specifically, the researchers focus on the following aspects:

1. **Temporal Trends of Introduction Pathways**:
- The researchers aim to understand how the contribution of different introduction pathways to the composition of non-native plant communities has changed over the past 1000 years (from 1500 years ago to the present). Specifically, they expect horticultural activities to replace agricultural activities as the main introduction pathway for non-native plants.

2. **Impact of Introduction Pathways on Invasion Niches**:
- The researchers aim to analyze how different introduction pathways shape the invasion niches of non-native plants. Specifically, they focus on how environmental variables such as land use type, degree of urbanization, and elevation affect the invasion success rates of plants introduced through different pathways.

3. **Interaction Between Introduction Pathways and Plant Traits**:
- The researchers aim to explore whether there are interactions between introduction pathways and plant traits (such as minimum residence time, dispersal mode, reproductive mode, plant height, growth form, and native niche breadth) and how these interactions affect the invasion success rates of plants.

### Main Hypotheses

1. **H1**: Over the past 1000 years, horticultural activities will replace agricultural activities as the main introduction pathway for non-native plants.
2. **H2**: Urban land use will promote the invasion of horticultural plants rather than unintentionally introduced plants.
3. **H3**: Non-native plants introduced through horticultural pathways will invade at lower elevations, while unintentionally introduced plants will invade at higher elevations.
4. **H4**: The relationship between introduction pathways and elevation will be influenced by land use, with increased urbanization favoring the invasion of horticultural plants.
5. **H5**: Unintentionally introduced plants will become more successful invaders over time compared to plants introduced through other pathways.

### Methods

To test the above hypotheses, the researchers employed the following methods:

1. **Data Collection and Classification**:
- Using a list of non-native plants in the Catalonia region, including archaeological plants introduced before 1500.
- Classifying non-native plants into three introduction pathway categories: agriculture and forestry, horticulture, and unintentional introduction.

2. **Temporal Trend Analysis**:
- Constructing contingency tables to assess the temporal trends in the relative contribution of each introduction pathway to the composition of non-native plant communities.
- Using chi-square tests and Cramér’s V to calculate significance and effect size.

3. **Invasion Niche Analysis**:
- Conducting field sampling in the province of Barcelona to record the occurrence and abundance of new plants.
- Using generalized linear models (GLM) to analyze the relationship between the proportion of plants introduced through different pathways and environmental variables.

4. **Invasion Success Rate Analysis**:
- Calculating the occupied area, habitat range, and invasion climate niche breadth of non-native plants as indicators of invasion success.
- Analyzing the interaction between introduction pathways and plant traits on invasion success rates.

Through these methods, the researchers hope to gain a more comprehensive understanding of the role of introduction pathways in the plant invasion process, thereby providing scientific evidence for biological invasion management and conservation goals.