Crystal structure of Na v AP , an orthologue of the NaChBac voltage-gated sodium channel
Xu Zhang,Wenlin Ren,Paul DeCaen,Chuangye Yan,Xiao Tao,Lin Tang,Jingjing Wang,Kazuya Hasegawa,Takashi Kumasaka,Jianhua He,Jiawei Wang,David E. Clapham,Nieng Yan
2014-01-01
Abstract:Voltage-gated sodium (Nav) channels are essential for the rapid depolarization of nerve and muscle1, and are important drug targets2. A family of bacterial Nav channels, exemplified by NaChBac (Na+-selective Channel of Bacteria)3, provides a good model system for structurefunction analysis. Here we report the crystal structure of NavAP, a NaChBac orthologue from marine bacteria alpha proteobacterium HIMB114, at 3.05 Å resolution. The channel comprises an asymmetric tetramer. The carbonyl oxygen atoms of Thr178 and Leu179 constitute an inner site within the selectivity filter (178TLSSWE183) where a Ca2+ can bind and resides in the crystal structure. The outer mouth of the Na+ selectivity filter, defined by Ser181 and Glu183, is closed, as is the activation gate at the intracellular side of the pore. The voltage sensors adopt a depolarized conformation with all the gating charges exposing to the extracellular side. We hypothesize that NavAP is captured in an inactivated conformation. Comparison of NavAP with NavAb reveals significant conformational rearrangements that may underlie the electromechanical coupling mechanism of voltage-gated channels. Nav channels initiate and propagate action potentials in excitable cells1. Since Nav channels underlie a number of clinical disorders such as epileptic seizures and cardiac arrhythmias, 9To whom correspondence should be addressed. nyan@tsinghua.edu.cn. 8These authors contributed equally to this work. Author Contributions X.Z., W.R., P.D., X.T., D.C., and N.Y. designed all experiments. X.Z., W.R., P.D., C.Y., X.T., L.T., J.W., K.H., T.K., J.H., and J.W. performed the experiments. X.Z., W.R., P.D., C.Y., X.T., J.W., D.C., and N.Y. analysed the data. X.Z., P.D., X.T., C.Y., J.W. and D.C. contributed to manuscript preparation. N.Y. wrote the manuscript. Author Information The atomic coordinates of NaVAP have been deposited in the Protein Data Bank under accession code 4DXW. NIH Public Access Author Manuscript Nature. Author manuscript; available in PMC 2014 April 08. Published in final edited form as: Nature. ; 486(7401): 130–134. doi:10.1038/nature11054. N IH PA Athor M anscript N IH PA Athor M anscript N IH PA Athor M anscript they are important drug targets2. Elucidation of the structures and functional mechanisms of Nav channels will shed light on fundamental ion channel mechanisms and facilitate potential clinical applications. The eukaryotic Nav channels are comprised of a pore-forming α subunit and auxiliary subunits5. It consists of one single polypeptide chain that is organized into four repeated domains (DI–DIV) of six transmembrane-spanning (S1–S6) segments. The S5 and S6 segments from each domain form the pore region of the channel, which are flanked by four voltage sensing domains (VSDs) consisting of S1–S4. The VSD, a relatively independent structural entity6–9, provides the molecular basis for voltage sensing in voltagedependent channels and enzymes. Essential for voltage-dependent gating, VSDs contain the gating charges10 embodied in a set of highly conserved positively charged residues occurring every three residues along the S4 segment. In Kv channels, approximately 12 gating charges per channel are transferred across the membrane from the cytosolic side to the extracellular side11,12. While multiple models of voltage sensor activation have been proposed, it is generally accepted that the outward translation of S4 segments is coupled to pore opening via the interactions between the S4– S5 connecting helices and S6 segments7,8. The activation mechanism is not fully understood. Even more bewildering is the intricate inactivation mechanism for voltage-gated channels. Fast inactivation or N-type inactivation, taking place on millisecond scale, is executed by a cytoplasmic moiety between repeats III and IV of Nav channels13, or by the N-terminus of the Shaker K+ channel14–16. Also during prolonged depolarization, slow or “C-type” inactivation17 is thought to result from a conformational change of the selectivity filter18,19. The prokaryotic homologues of Nav channels, exemplified by NaChBac3, are homotetramers of 6-TM subunits. Interestingly, the sequence of NaChBac is closer to that of Cav channels20. Thus, structural elucidation of NaChBac homologues is expected to provide insights into both Nav and Cav channels. To promote a deeper mechanistic understanding of Nav channels, we determined the crystal structure of a NaChBac homologue, NavAP (Supplementary Fig. 1–5, Tables S1&S2). During refinement of our structure, the atomic crystal structure of NavAb was published4. Compared to NavAb, NavAP reveals a number of distinct and mechanistically informative structural features. As in all the known structures of voltage-gated channels, the VSD of one protomer attaches to the pore-forming unit of the adjacent protomer (Fig. 1a). The activation gate formed by S6 of NavAP is closed, although Leu219, the residue that occludes the gate, is one helical turn above the functionally equivalent Met221 in NavAb (Fig. 1b, right panel)4. Notably, the narrowest point along the pore is at Ser181, which together with Glu183 encloses the entrance to the selectivity filter vestibule (Fig. 1b, right panel). While the selectivity filter of NavAb is open and may allow the conductance of hydrated Na+, that of NavAP is closed (Fig. 1c). Both the pore domain and the VSDs of NavAP exhibit structural variations among the four protomers, resulting in an asymmetric tetramer. The selectivity filter of NavAP (178TLSSWE183) connects P1 (corresponding to the P-helix in K+ channel) and P2 helices (Fig. 2, Supplementary Fig. 6). The side groups of Ser180, Ser181, and Glu183, as well as the carbonyl oxygen atoms of Thr178 and Leu179 constitute the electronegative vestibule of the selectivity filter (Fig. 2a). The entrance to the selectivity filter is negatively charged owing to the side groups of Glu183. The side groups of Ser181 adopt distinctive conformations among the four protomers, leading to the asymmetry of the selectivity filter (Supplementary Fig. 6). Zhang et al. Page 2 Nature. Author manuscript; available in PMC 2014 April 08. N IH PA Athor M anscript N IH PA Athor M anscript N IH PA Athor M anscript Notably, two residues in the selectivity filter of (NavAP Ser180/Glu183 vs. Glu178/Ser181 of NavAb) are swapped in the primary sequences. However, structural superimposition shows that the carboxylate groups of NavAP-Glu183 in are positioned similarly to those of Glu178 in the adjacent protomer of NavAb despite their distinct backbone locations (Fig. 2b). Therefore, NavAP-Glu183 and NavAb-Glu178 appear to be functional equivalents. This structural observation provides a basis to begin to understand the function of the negatively charged residues in the eukaryotic Nav channels that seem to be located at different positions in the selectivity filter (Fig. 2b, left panel). Like many other bacterial channels, NavAP did not yield measurable ion currents when heterologously expressed in insect or mammalian cell lines, or when expressed in E.coli BL21(DE3) purified, reconstituted into lipids (POPE:POPG 3:1 mass ratio) and fused into bilayers with lipid composition of either POPE:POPG (3:1 mass ratio) or DPhPC. In order to test the selectivity of the NavAP channel, we generated a chimera by replacing the selectivity filter of NaChBac with that of NavAP (Supplementary Fig. 7). The chimeric channel was Na+-selective when expressed in HEK-293 cells and measured under voltageclamp (Fig. 2c). Similar to observations with other NaChBac pore mutations21,22, the chimera’s (NaChBac/NavAP-filter) voltage dependence of activation was shifted (+49 mV; Fig. 2d) with an altered rate of inactivation (1.6× increase; Fig. 2d). Similar to NaChBac, the chimera was blocked by the Nav channel antagonist, lidocaine, and the Cav antagonist, nifedipine (Supplementary Fig. 7d), but remained insensitive to tetrodotoxin. During structure refinement, a spherical electron density appeared in the selectivity filter (Supplementary Fig. 8a). We conclude that the electron density is from a calcium ion since: 1) addition of 100 mM CaCl2 was indispensible for obtaining well-diffracting crystals; 2) crystals were also obtained for proteins purified in solutions with RbCl instead of NaCl, and diffracted X-rays at the high remote wavelength for Rb+. After structural refinement, no anomalous signal for Rb+ was observed whereas the omit electron density persisted, suggesting that the electron density was from Ca2+. When Ca2+ was built into the 3.05 Å structure and further refined, the 2Fo-Fc electron density at 1.5 σ had an elongated tail on the side of the ion facing the central cavity (Supplementary Fig. 8b). A water molecule was then built into the appendage that was approximately 2.4 Å away from the ion, fulfilling the geometric restraint of the interaction between water and Ca2+ (Fig. 2e). The Ca2+ ion is caged by the eight carbonyl oxygen groups from Thr178 and Leu179. The distances between Ca2+ and the eight carbonyl oxygen atoms are in the range of 3.5 to 4.6 Å (Fig. 2e). For direct coordination of a Ca2+ by carbonyl oxygen atoms, the distance is usually between 2.3 – 2.5 Å23. The well-defined electron density suggests that the ion is properly stabilized and thus the Ca2+ should be in a fully, or mostly, hydrated state. However, there was no distinguishable electron density for the surrounding water molecules, perhaps due to the moderate resolution of the structure and/or the intrinsic motility of those water molecules. Ca2+ and Na+ effective ionic radii are practically identical (1.00 Å vs. 1.02 Å), but with the primary hydration shell the radii are 2.7 Å for Ca2+ and 2.2 Å for Na+, respectively24. The observation that the inner binding site of the selectivity filter is spacious enough to accommodate a hydrated Ca2+ or Na+ thus provides structural evidence for the hypothesis that Nav channels allow the passage of mostly hydrated