‘Exotic’ treatments and Western psychiatry

J. Leff

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/S0033291700056361

IF: 10.592

1975-05-01

Psychological Medicine

Abstract:Psychiatry as a specialty is one of the youngest branches of medicine, although the ailments which are its province are probably as old as consciousness. The historical origins of both medicine and psychiatry lie in magical beliefs and practices, but general medicine has advanced much further from its origins than has psychiatry. The scientific revolution in medicine displaced most of the old remedies, though some, such as digitalis and quinine, resisted its onslaught. The influence of scientific medicine has not extended far outside the medical profession, however, and the public continues to make considerable use of herbal remedies and patent medicines. The total expenditure on medicines in the United Kingdom in 1966, for example, was £267 million, of which £188 million was for medicines prescribed in the National Health Service, and the remaining £79 million was spent by the public mainly on medicines bought without a doctor's prescription (Office of Health Economics, 1968). Apart from the use of herbal and patent medicines, certain kinds of more traditionally magical practice continue to flourish in the United Kingdom alongside the National Health Service, well-used by and well-known to the public even if most doctors are completely oblivious to them. The laying-on of hands, for example, which was used by the kings of England and France throughout the fourteenth to seventeenth centuries to treat scrofula, is still a thriving specialty in Great Britain. Whereas Charles II laid hands on a total of 92,000 people, Harry Edwards, a manual healer now aged 80, claims to have treated well over one million people since the first world war.