Parental Refusal of Childhood Vaccines and Medical Neglect Laws

Efthimios Parasidis,D. Opel
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2105/AJPH.2016.303500
American Journal of Public Health
Abstract:Objectives To examine the relation of vaccine refusal and medical neglect under child welfare laws. Methods We used the Westlaw legal database to search court opinions from 1905 to 2016 and identified cases in which vaccine refusal was the sole or a primary reason in a neglect proceeding. We also delineated if religious or philosophical exemptions from required school immunizations were available at the time of adjudication. Results Our search yielded 9 cases from 5 states. Most courts (7 of 9) considered vaccine refusal to constitute neglect. In the 4 cases decided in jurisdictions that permitted religious exemptions, courts either found that vaccine refusal did not constitute neglect or considered it neglect only in the absence of a sincere religious objection to vaccination. Conclusions Some states have a legal precedent for considering parental vaccine refusal as medical neglect, but this is based on a small number of cases. Each state should clarify whether, under its laws, vaccine refusal constitutes medical neglect.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?