Abstract:Our memories of other people shape how we interact with them. Yet, even when we forget exactly what others said or did, we often remember impressions that capture a general gist of their behavior-whether they were forthright, friendly, or funny. Drawing on fuzzy trace theory, we propose two modes of social impression formation: impressions formed based on ordinal gist ("more competent," "less competent") or categorical gist ("competent," "incompetent"). In turn, we propose that people gravitate toward the simplest representation available and that different modes of memory have distinct consequences for social decisions. Specifically, ordinal impressions lead people to make decisions based on an individual's standing relative to others, whereas categorical impressions lead people to make decisions based on discrete classifications that interpret behavior. In four experiments, participants learned about two groups of individuals who differed in their competence (Studies 1a, 2, and 3) or generosity (Study 1b). When participants encoded impressions as ordinal rankings, they preferred to hire or help a relatively good target from a low-performing group over a relatively bad target from a high-performing group, even though both targets behaved identically and accuracy was incentivized. However, when participants could use categorical boundaries to interpret behavior, this preference was eliminated. In a final experiment, changing the category participants used to encode others' generosity changed their impressions, even when accounting for memory for verbatim details. This work links social impressions to theories of mental representation in memory and judgment, highlighting how distinct representations support divergent patterns of social decision-making. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2023 APA, all rights reserved).

Similarity Among Friends Serves as a Social Prior: The Assumption That "Birds of a Feather Flock Together" Shapes Social Decisions and Relationship Beliefs

Birds of a Feather Flock Together and Opposites Attract: the Nonlinear Relationship Between Personality and Friendship

The social network: How people infer relationships from mutual connections.

Preferential Learning and Memory Resolve Social Dilemma

The Friendship Paradox and Social Network Participation

Thinking you're different matters more for belonging than being different

When Do People Trust Their Social Groups?

Trust in Virtual Ingroup or Outgroup Members Relies on Perceived Self-Other Overlap

Social Learning in Networks of Friends Versus Strangers

Neural Similarity and Synchrony among Friends

Birds of a Feather: Homophily in Social Networks

Two modes of social impressions and their effects on choice.

Preference Effects on Friendship Choice: Evidence from an Online Field Experiment

Sentiment Paradoxes in Social Networks: Why Your Friends Are More Positive Than You?

The Majority Illusion in Social Networks

How Do Friends and Strangers Play the Game Taboo? A Study of Accuracy, Efficiency, Motivation, and the Use of Shared Knowledge

Keeping up with the Joneses: interpersonal prediction errors and the correlation of behavior in a tandem sequential choice task

The effect of similarity perceptions on human cooperation and confrontation

Cognitive impacts of group dynamics: exploring memory errors in observing actions by familiar and unfamiliar individuals

Who resemble you better, your friends or co-visited users

Trust based attachment