Abstract:This article explores conceptual and methodological challenges surrounding the recovery of patients' voices in the history of medicine. We examine the debate that followed Roy Porter's seminal article, 'The Patient's View: Doing Medical History from Below' (1985). Porter argued that patients should be given a central role in medical history, aiming to restore to patients a voice and agency that is often lost in 'physician-centered' historical narratives. His work carried significant influence but also sparked an ongoing debate about the possibility of conducting 'patient-centered' history of medicine. The growth of the medical humanities has afforded renewed attention to patient narratives, supporting the need to recognise patients' voices in contemporary healthcare and medical education. However, several barriers complicate and problematise the expansion of a patient-centred epistemology across historical periods. Postmodern critics have expressed scepticism that 'the patient's view' can be recovered from history, with some claiming that 'the patient' is a construct of the 'medical gaze' whose subjectivity cannot be reconstituted outside of sociohistorical discourses of knowledge and power. Psychiatry in the mid-20th century presents a particular challenge for patient-centred history. We discuss the influence of postmodern theorists, especially Michel Foucault, whose work is seen as undermining the possibility of a patient-centred epistemology. We argue against Foucault's erasure of the patient, and instead explore alternate constructivist epistemologies, focusing on the hermeneutics of Hans-Georg Gadamer and dialogism of Mikhail Bakhtin, to help address historiographical challenges in recovering 'the patient's view'. To illustrate the value of Gadamerian and Bakhtinian approaches, we apply them to a case study from the Verdun Protestant Hospital (Québec, Canada) from 1941 to 1956, which sheds light on the introduction of the first antipsychotic, chlorpromazine, into clinical practice. We highlight how Gadamer's hermeneutics and Bakhtin's dialogism together offer insights into patient perspectives during this liminal period in the history of psychiatry.

The Power of Images and the Logics of Discovery in Psychiatric Care

The function of structuring images: the concept of epiphany from literature to psychiatry

The power of images: hysteric symptoms as representations of the self

Bildwissenschaft and revolution. The story of Marco Cavallo and its significance in the history of psychiatry

Considering patient narrative-based and medico-scientific epistemologies in framing psychiatric care

From hermeneutics to heteroglossia: 'The Patient's View' revisited

Art for Humanizing Mental Illness When Teaching Diagnosis

[Relationships. Art-affined physicians, gifted artist patients and the debate on art from a psychiatric context after 1945]

Exploring the intersection of psychiatry, art, and medical education through photographic portraits

Clusters, lines and webs-so does my patient have psychosis? reflections on the use of psychiatric conceptual frameworks from a clinical vantage point

Cultural poetics of illness and healing

Reading the self-other drama of the clinical encounter: The role of literary reading and writing as a challenge for psychiatrists.

"Inside Out of Mind": Alternative Realities, Dementia and Graphic Medicine

For a Theory of the Psychotherapeutic Process: Epistemology of Recursion and Relational Fractality

Languaging psychopathology: neurobiology and metaphor

Synchronicity, Acausal Connection, and the Fractal Dynamics of Clinical Practice

Potential Space in Hospitals: Insight From a Health Psychologist

Revisiting Empathy, Motivational Systems, and a Theory of Cure

Social poetics as processual engagement: Making visible what matters in social suffering

When Multispecies Ethnography Encounters a Shelter-Based Clinic: Uncovering Ecological Factors for Cultural Psychiatry

From diagnosis to dialogue - reconsidering the DSM as a conversation piece in mental health care: a hypothesis and theory