Potential of Reusing 3D Printed Concrete (3DPC) Fine Recycled Aggregates as a Strategy towards Decreasing Cement Content in 3DPC

Szymon Skibicki,Karol Federowicz,Marcin Hoffmann,Mehdi Chougan,Daniel Sibera,Krzysztof Cendrowski,Mateusz Techman,João Nuno Pacheco,Maxime Liard,Pawel Sikora
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/ma17112580
IF: 3.4
2024-05-28
Materials
Abstract:This paper explores the new potential strategy of using fine recycled aggregates (fRA) derived from waste 3D printed concrete (3DPC) as a substitute for cement in additive manufacturing. This study hypothesizes that fRA can optimize mixture design, reduce cement content, and contribute to sustainable construction practices. Experimental programs were conducted to evaluate the fresh and hardened properties, printability window, and buildability of 3DPC mixes containing fRA. Mixes with replacement rates of cement with fRA by 10 vol%, 20 vol%, 30 vol%, 40 vol%, and 50 vol% were produced. A comprehensive experimental protocol consisting of rheological studies (static and dynamic yield stress), dynamic elastic modulus determination (first 24 h of hydration), flexural and compressive strengths (2 d and 28 d), and an open porosity test was performed. The obtained results were verified by printing tests. In addition, an economic and environmental life cycle assessment (LCA) of the mixes was performed. The results indicate that up to 50 vol% cement replacement with fRA is feasible, albeit with some technical drawbacks. While fRA incorporation enhances sustainability by reducing CO2 emissions and material costs, it adversely affects the printability window, green strength, setting time, and mechanical properties, particularly in the initial curing stages. Therefore, with higher replacement rates (above 20 vol%), potential optimization efforts are needed to mitigate drawbacks such as reduced green strength and buildability. Notably, replacement rates of up to 20 vol% can be successfully used without compromising the overall material properties or altering the mixture design. The LCA analysis shows that reducing the cement content and increasing the fRA addition results in a significant reduction in mix cost (up to 24%) and a substantial decrease in equivalent CO2 emissions (up to 48%). In conclusion, this study underscores the potential of fRA as a sustainable alternative to cement in 3D printed concrete.
materials science, multidisciplinary,chemistry, physical,physics, applied, condensed matter,metallurgy & metallurgical engineering
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### Problems the paper attempts to solve This paper explores the potential application of fine recycled aggregate (fRA) recovered from waste 3D - printed concrete (3DPC) as a cement substitute in 3D - printed concrete. Specifically, the research aims to solve the problems through the following aspects: 1. **Reduce cement consumption**: By using fine recycled aggregate (fRA) to partially replace cement, the cement content in 3D - printed concrete can be reduced. This not only helps to reduce material costs but also reduces carbon dioxide emissions during the cement production process, thereby improving sustainability. 2. **Optimize mix design**: The research hypothesizes that fine recycled aggregate (fRA) can optimize the mix design of 3D - printed concrete, improve its rheological properties and printability, while maintaining or improving its mechanical properties. 3. **Evaluate technical performance**: Through experiments, evaluate the fresh properties (such as fluidity and printability window) and hardened properties (such as compressive strength and flexural strength) of 3D - printed concrete at different replacement rates (10 vol%, 20 vol%, 30 vol%, 40 vol% and 50 vol%), as well as its building performance (such as green strength and buildability). 4. **Environmental and economic impacts**: Through life - cycle assessment (LCA) analysis, quantify the environmental (such as global warming potential) and economic (such as cost) impacts of using fine recycled aggregate (fRA) to replace cement. ### Research background With the acceleration of the urbanization process and the increase in post - war demolition activities, a large amount of construction and demolition waste (CDW) is generated in Europe. The treatment of these wastes has become the focus of academic attention because they have the potential for secondary use. The European Union has set ambitious goals, aiming to reduce the demand for natural resources and the amount of landfill through the recycling of construction waste. The utilization of fine recycled aggregate (fRA) is usually limited to low - value applications, such as backfilling, which highlights the importance of setting specific goals. Through innovative methods, such as concrete 3D printing, the market expansion of fine recycled aggregate (fRA) in higher - value applications can be promoted. ### Research methods 1. **Materials and preparation**: - Use CEM I 42.5R, fly ash and silica fume as binders. - Process waste 3D - printed concrete into fine recycled aggregate (fRA) by a single - jaw crusher and screen it through a 2 - mm sieve. - Prepare 3D - printed concrete mixtures with different replacement rates (10 vol%, 20 vol%, 30 vol%, 40 vol% and 50 vol%). 2. **Performance testing**: - **Fresh properties**: Evaluate by methods such as slump flow test, static and dynamic yield stress tests, and dynamic elastic modulus determination. - **Hardened properties**: Evaluate by compressive strength, flexural strength and porosity tests. - **Printability and building performance**: Evaluate by actual printing tests. 3. **Life - cycle assessment (LCA)**: - Evaluate the cost and global warming potential (GWP) of different mixtures to quantify the economic and environmental benefits of using fine recycled aggregate (fRA) to replace cement. ### Conclusions The research results show that the proportion of fine recycled aggregate (fRA) replacing cement can be up to 50 vol%, although there are some technical challenges, such as reducing green strength and buildability. When the replacement rate is 20 vol% or less, it can be successfully used without affecting the overall material performance or changing the mix design. Life - cycle assessment shows that reducing the cement content and increasing the addition of fine recycled aggregate (fRA) can significantly reduce costs (up to 24%) and equivalent carbon dioxide emissions (up to 48%). Therefore, this study emphasizes the potential sustainability of fine recycled aggregate (fRA) as a cement substitute in 3D - printed concrete.