Can A Disease Self-Management Program Reduce Health Care Costs?: The Case of Older Women With Heart Disease
John R. C. Wheeler,John Wheeler
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1097/00005650-200306000-00003
2003-06-01
Medical Care
Abstract:Background. There is increasing interest in the potential for chronic disease self-management interventions to provide health benefits while reducing health care costs. Objectives. To assess the impact of a heart disease management program on use of hospital services; to estimate associated hospital cost savings; and to compare potential cost savings with the cost of delivering the program. Research Design. Randomized, controlled study design. Data were collected from hospital billing records during a 36 month period. Multivariate models were used to compare health care use with cost between treatment and control groups. Estimated differences were then compared with the program costs to determine cost-effectiveness. Subjects. Participants were recruited from 6 hospital sites. Screening criteria included: female, 60 years or older, diagnosed cardiac disease, and seen by a physician approximately every 6 months. The study included 233 women in the intervention group and 219 in the control group. The “Women Take PRIDE” program utilizes a self-regulation process for addressing a problematic area of the heart regimen recommended by each woman’s physician. It is tailored to the unique needs of older women. Measures. Hospital admissions, in-patient days, emergency department visits. Results. Program participants experienced 46% fewer in-patient days (P <0.05) and 49% lower in-patient costs (P <0.10) than women in the control group. No significant differences in emergency department utilization were found. Hospital cost savings exceeded program costs by a ratio of nearly 5-to-1. Conclusions. A heart disease self-management program can reduce health care utilization and potentially yield monetary benefits to a health plan. There is increasing interest in the potential for chronic disease self-management programs to improve health benefits while reducing health care costs. 1 Disease self-management education programs in general populations have demonstrated significant health benefits in diabetes, 2 asthma, 3 and a heterogeneous group of patients with a variety of chronic conditions. 4,5 Health related benefits with older adults have been reported in interventions for the management of arthritis 6 and in a comprehensive lifestyle management program for older women with heart disease. 7 Despite the potential health benefits of programs designed to improve older adults’ heart disease self-management abilities, we could find no studies that documented both the costs of, and the potential for cost savings from, such programs. Likely as a result, minimal health insurance coverage is available for such programs. Medicare does not cover the cost of Medicare beneficiaries’ participation in disease self-management programs, nor, generally, do large Blue Cross plans, commercial insurers, or managed care programs. Evidence of the potential of well-designed chronic disease self-management programs to reduce health care use is available. Gibson et al, 8 in a review of more than 20 studies, concluded that self-management education reduced hospitalizations, emergency department visits, unscheduled visits to the doctor, and days off work or school among adults with asthma. Sadur et al 9 found lower hospital in-patient and out-patient utilization among participants in a diabetes management program sponsored by a health maintenance organization. However, very few studies have reported actual cost savings from a disease self-management program compared with the costs of the program. Using a cost-effectiveness analysis, Rossiter et al 10 projected “direct savings to Medicaid of $3 to $4 for every incremental dollar spent providing asthma self-management support to physicians” caring for young, low-income patients. Lorig and colleagues 4 estimated savings in hospital costs from a chronic disease self-management program to be approximately $750 per participant, more than 10 times the cost of the program. The high prevalence and subsequent health care costs associated with cardiovascular disease highlights the need to demonstrate cost effectiveness for heart disease self-management programs. This article presents the results of a randomized, controlled study of the effects on health care utilization and related costs of participating in “Women Take PRIDE” (WTP), a heart disease self-management program for older women. Tailored specifically for older women with heart disease, the WTP program has demonstrated a number of significant health effects. 11 At 12 months follow-up, women in the program, compared with controls, were less symptomatic (P <0.01), scored better on the physical dimension of the Sickness Impact Profile (P <0.01), demonstrated improved ambulation as measured by the 6-minute walk test (P = 0.01), and lost more body weight (P <0.001). 12,13 The specific aims of the study include: assessing the impact of the WTP heart disease self-management program on the use of hospital services by older women; determining the approximate hospital cost savings attributed to older women who participated in the program; and comparing potential cost savings with the costs of operating the disease self-management program.
public, environmental & occupational health,health care sciences & services,health policy & services