A complication of orbital emphysema

J. Keenan,J. Pearce,N. Huggins

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/eye.1992.90

IF: 4.4563

Eye

Abstract:

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Pediatric vaccine tender scheduling in low- and middle-income countries

Nicholas Uhorchak,Ruben A. Proano,Sandra Eksioglu,Fatih Cengil,Burak Eksioglu

2024-03-12

Abstract:Effective and efficient scheduling of vaccine distribution can significantly impact vaccine uptake, which is critical to controlling the spread of infectious diseases. Ineffective scheduling can lead to waste, delays, and low vaccine coverage, potentially weakening the efforts to protect the public. Organizations such as UNICEF (United Nations Children's Fund), PAHO (Pan American Health Organization), and GAVI (Gavi, the Vaccine Alliance) coordinate vaccine tenders to ensure that enough supply is available on the international market at the lowest possible prices. Scheduling vaccine tenders over a planning horizon in a way that is equitable, efficient, and accessible is a complex problem that involves trade-offs between multiple objectives while ensuring that vaccine availability, demand, and logistical constraints are met. The current method for scheduling tenders is generally reactive and over short planning horizons. Vaccine tenders are scheduled when supply is insufficient to cover demand. We propose an optimization model to dynamically and proactively generate vaccine tender schedules over long planning horizons. This model helps us address the following research questions: What should the optimal sequencing and scheduling of vaccine tenders be to enhance affordability and profit over long time horizons? What is the optimal tender procurement schedule for single or multiple antigen scenarios? We use several real-life data sources to validate the model and address our research questions. Results from our analysis show when to schedule vaccine tenders, what volumes manufacturers should commit to, and the optimal tender lengths to satisfy demand. We show that vaccine tenders tend towards maximum lengths, generally converge over long time horizons, and are robust to changes in varying conditions.

Optimization and Control
Outreach Strategies for Vaccine Distribution: A Multi-period Stochastic Modeling Approach

Yuwen Yang,Jayant Rajgopal

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s43069-021-00064-1

2021-04-27

Operations Research Forum

Abstract:Vaccination has been proven to be the most effective method to prevent infectious diseases. However, in many low- and middle-income countries with geographically dispersed and nomadic populations, last-mile vaccine delivery can be extremely complex. Because newborns in remote population centers often do not have direct access to clinics and hospitals, they face significant risk from diseases and infections. An approach known as outreach is typically utilized to raise immunization rates in these situations. A set of these remote locations is chosen, and over an appropriate planning period, teams of clinicians and support personnel are sent from a depot to set up mobile clinics at these locations to vaccinate people there and in the immediate surrounding area. In this paper, we model the problem of optimally designing outreach efforts as a mixed integer program that is a combination of a set covering problem and a vehicle routing problem. In addition, because elements relevant to outreach (such as populations and road conditions) are often unstable and unpredictable, we address uncertainty and determine the worst-case solutions. This is done using a multi-period stochastic modeling approach that considers updated model parameter estimates and revised plans for subsequent planning periods. We also conduct numerical experiments to provide insights on how demographic characteristics affect outreach planning and where outreach planners should focus their attention when gathering data.

English Else
Optimization of an adult immunization program in Canada

Nathan Locke,Mike Paulden,Shannon E. MacDonald,Stephanie Montesanti,Ashleigh Tuite,Karsten Hempel,Wade McDonald,Ellen Rafferty

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.06.10.24308663

2024-06-11

Abstract:Background Provincial decisions to fund a new immunization program are generally made on a case-by-case basis, without systematic consideration of how the new immunization program may fit within the larger provincial immunization portfolio. Aim The goal of this study was to develop evidence and tools to guide policy-makers in making fiscally and ethically responsible decisions on which adult immunization programs to include in their portfolio under various constrained budgetary scenarios. Methods Using previously published infectious disease models, cost-utility data was estimated for adult pneumococcal, influenza, pertussis, and shingles immunization programs. This data was then inputted into a newly developed constrained optimization model to determine portfolios of immunization programs that maximize either population health or incremental net monetary benefit, subject to a budget constraint. Sensitivity analyses were conducted on model parameters such as vaccine costs, cost-effectiveness thresholds, and the budget constraint. Results Optimized solutions changed dramatically based on the number of immunization programs included, total budget, what was optimized for (i.e., population health or incremental net monetary benefit), the cost-effectiveness threshold and the assumed vaccine prices. Maximal health gains and budget spending was achieved when optimizing based on population health. Reductions in health gains and budget spending were observed at a CAN$50,000 cost-effectiveness threshold, and at a CAN$30,000 threshold, the budget was significantly underutilized and health gains were noticeably reduced. Conclusion If budgets for the adult immunization portfolio are fixed, then shifting to more expensive programs that offer large health benefits may be preferable. However, if budgets can be spread across various public health programs (i.e., childhood immunization, well-baby programs), it may make more sense to optimize based on cost-effectiveness. Constrained optimization tools could improve goals-based decision-making and allow for transparent and effective methods to make allocation decisions.

Health Economics
Optimization of Distribution Network Configuration for Pediatric Vaccines using Chance Constraint Programming

Zahra Azadi,Sandra D. Eksioglu,H. Neil Geismar

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2006.05488

2020-06-09

Applications

Abstract:Millions of young people are not immunized in low- and middle-income (LMI) countries because of low vaccine availability resulting from inefficiencies in cold supply chains. We create supply chain network design and distribution models to address the unique characteristics and challenges facing vaccine supply chains in LMI countries. The models capture the uncertainties of demand for vaccinations and the resulting impacts on immunization, the unique challenges of vaccine administration (such as open vial wastage), the interactions between technological improvements of vaccines and immunizations, and the trade-offs between immunization coverage rates and available resources. The objective is to maximize both the percentage of fully immunized children and the vaccine availability in clinics. Our research examines how these two metrics are affected by three factors: number of tiers in the supply chain, vaccine vial size, and new vaccine technologies. We tested the model using Niger's Expanded Program on Immunization, which is sponsored by the World Health Organization. We make many observations and recommendations to help LMI countries increase their immunization coverage.
How can age-based vaccine allocation strategies be optimized? A multi-objective optimization framework

Hao Wu,Kaibo Wang,Lei Xu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3389/fpubh.2022.934891

IF: 5.2

2022-09-09

Frontiers in Public Health

Abstract:Human life is deeply influenced by infectious diseases. A vaccine, when available, is one of the most effective ways of controlling the spread of an epidemic. However, vaccine shortage and uncertain vaccine effectiveness in the early stage of vaccine production make vaccine allocation a critical issue. To tackle this issue, we propose a multi-objective framework to optimize the vaccine allocation strategy among different age groups during an epidemic under vaccine shortage in this study. Minimizing total disease onsets and total severe cases are the two objectives of this vaccine allocation optimization problem, and the multistage feature of vaccine allocation are considered in the framework. An improved Strength Pareto Evolutionary Algorithm (SPEA2) is used to solve the optimization problem. To evaluate the two objectives under different strategies, a deterministic age-stratified extended SEIR model is developed. In the proposed framework, different combinations of vaccine effectiveness and vaccine production capacity are investigated, and it is identified that for COVID-19 the optimal strategy is highly related to vaccine-related parameters. When the vaccine effectiveness is low, allocating most of vaccines to 0–19 age group or 65+ age group is a better choice under a low production capacity, while allocating most of vaccines to 20–49 age group or 50–64 age group is a better choice under a relatively high production capacity. When the vaccine effectiveness is high, a better strategy is to allocate vaccines to 65+ age group under a low production capacity, while to allocate vaccines to 20–49 age group under a relatively high production capacity.

public, environmental & occupational health
Vaccine network design to maximize immunization coverage

Jarrod Goentzel,Timothy Russell,Henrique Ribeiro Carretti,Yuto Hashimoto

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1108/jhlscm-10-2021-0101

2022-06-12

Journal of Humanitarian Logistics and Supply Chain Management

Abstract:Purpose The COVID-19 pandemic has forced countries to consider how to reach vulnerable communities with extended outreach services to improve vaccination uptake. The authors created an optimization model to align with decision-makers' objective to maximize immunization coverage within constrained budgets and deploy resources considering empirical data and endogenous demand. Design/methodology/approach A mixed integer program (MIP) determines the location of outreach sites and the resource deployment across health centers and outreach sites. The authors validated the model and evaluated the approach in consultation with UNICEF using a case study from The Gambia. Findings Results in The Gambia showed that by opening new outreach sites and optimizing resource allocation and scheduling, the Ministry of Health could increase immunization coverage from 91.0 to 97.1% under the same budget. Case study solutions informed managerial insights to drive gains in vaccine coverage even without the application of sophisticated tools. Originality/value The research extended resource constrained LMIC vaccine distribution modeling literature in two ways: first, endogenous calculation of demand as a function of distance to health facility location enabled the effective design of the vaccine network around convenience to the community and second, the model's resource bundle concept more accurately and flexibly represented complex requirements and costs for specific resources, which facilitated buy-in from stakeholders responsible for managing health budgets. The paper also demonstrated how to leverage empirical research and spatial analysis of publicly available demographic and geographic data to effectively represent important contextual factors.
Optimal Immunization Policy Using Dynamic Programming

Atiye Alaeddini,Daniel Klein

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1910.08677

IF: 14.4

2019-10-19

Artificial Intelligence

Abstract:Decisions in public health are almost always made in the context of uncertainty. Policy makers are responsible for making important decisions, faced with the daunting task of choosing from amongst many possible options. This task is called planning under uncertainty, and is particularly acute when addressing complex systems, such as issues of global health and development. Uncertainty leads to cautious or incorrect decisions that cost time, money, and human life. It is with this understanding that we pursue greater clarity on, and methods to address optimal policy making in health. Decision making under uncertainty is a challenging task, and all too often this uncertainty is averaged away to simplify results for policy makers. Our goal in this work is to implement dynamic programming which provides basis for compiling planning results into reactive strategies. We present here a description of an AI-based method and illustrate how this method can improve our ability to find an optimal vaccination strategy. We model the problem as a partially observable Markov decision process, POMDP and show how a re-active policy can be computed using dynamic programming. In this paper, we developed a framework for optimal health policy design in an uncertain dynamic setting. We apply a stochastic dynamic programming approach to identify the optimal time to change the health intervention policy and the value of decision relevant information for improving the impact of the policy.
Two educational interventions to improve pediatricians' knowledge and skills in performing ankle and knee physical examinations.

A. Hergenroeder,J. Chorley,L. Laufman,A. Fetterhoff

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1001/ARCHPEDI.156.3.225

2002-03-01

Abstract:BACKGROUND Methods are needed to improve pediatricians' skills for physical examination of the ankle and knee. OBJECTIVE To compare the effect of 2 methods of teaching the physical examination of the ankle and knee on the knowledge and skills of pediatricians. DESIGN Prospective intervention trial with preintervention and postintervention tests. SETTING Pediatricians' offices. PARTICIPANTS Twenty-three practice groups of community pediatricians, including 75 pediatricians (74% of the eligible sample). INTERVENTIONS Practice groups were assigned by clustered randomization to 1 of 2 teaching interventions: (1) a videotape showing correct performance of the ankle and knee physical examinations (videotape only; 15 groups) and (2) the same videotape plus a skills building session (18 groups). The randomization was stratified by practice size. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES Knowledge of ankle and knee examinations and ankle and knee physical examination skills, assessed by means of a Clinical Skills Assessment Examination (CSAE), at 18 weeks. RESULTS The pediatricians' baseline mean ankle CSAE score was 26% correct in both groups. These scores improved to 44% and 59% correct in the videotape and videotape plus skills instruction groups, respectively, at 18 weeks (P<.001 for both). The baseline mean knee CSAE score was 25% in both groups and improved to 30% (P =.02, videotape group) and 41% (P<.001, videotape plus skills instruction group) at 18 weeks. The change in CSAE scores was greater in the videotape plus skills instruction group. Written test scores improved significantly in both groups. CONCLUSIONS Pediatricians' skills were lacking at baseline. Both teaching interventions were associated with improved skills and knowledge.
Optimization of vaccination for COVID-19 in the midst of a pandemic

Qi Luo,Ryan Weightman,Sean T. McQuade,Mateo Diaz,Emmanuel Trélat,William Barbour,Dan Work,Samitha Samaranayake,Benedetto Piccoli

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2203.09502

2022-03-18

Abstract:During the Covid-19 pandemic a key role is played by vaccination to combat the virus. There are many possible policies for prioritizing vaccines, and different criteria for optimization: minimize death, time to herd immunity, functioning of the health system. Using an age-structured population compartmental finite-dimensional optimal control model, our results suggest that the eldest to youngest vaccination policy is optimal to minimize deaths. Our model includes the possible infection of vaccinated populations. We apply our model to real-life data from the US Census for New Jersey and Florida, which have a significantly different population structure. We also provide various estimates of the number of lives saved by optimizing the vaccine schedule and compared to no vaccination.

Populations and Evolution,Optimization and Control
Heuristic algorithm tool for planning mass vaccine campaigns

Jessica Rodríguez-Pereira,Helena Ramalhinho,Paula Sarrà

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1108/jhlscm-09-2023-0082

2024-07-06

Journal of Humanitarian Logistics and Supply Chain Management

Abstract:Purpose The planning of massive vaccination campaigns often falls to nongovernmental organizations that have to face the critical challenge of vaccinating the largest number of people in the shortest time. This study aims to provide an easy tool for minimizing the duration of mass vaccination campaigns in rural and remote areas of developing countries. Design/methodology/approach This paper presents a linear mathematical model that combines location, scheduling and routing decisions that allows determining where to locate the vaccination centers, as well as the schedule/route that each medical team must follow to meet the target demand in the shortest time possible. In addition, the paper proposes an heuristic approach that can be integrated in a spreadsheet. Findings As the numerical experiments show, the proposed heuristic provides good solutions in a short time. Due to its simplicity and flexibility, the proposed approach allows decision-makers to analyze and evaluate several possible scenarios for decision-making by simply playing with input parameters. Social implications The integration of the heuristic approach in a spreadsheet provides a simple and efficient tool to help decision-makers while avoiding the need for large investments in information systems infrastructure by user organizations. Originality/value Motivated by a real-life problem and different from previous studies, the objective of the planning is to reduce the length of the vaccination campaigns with the available resources and ensure a target coverage instead of planning for minimizing costs or maximizing coverage. Furthermore, for helping implementation to practitioners, the heuristic can be solved in a spreadsheet.
Dynamic Vaccine Allocation for Control of Human-Transmissible Disease

Mingdong Lyu,Chang Chang,Kuofu Liu,Randolph Hall

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/vaccines12091034

2024-09-10

Vaccines

Abstract:During pandemics, such as COVID-19, supplies of vaccines can be insufficient for meeting all needs, particularly when vaccines first become available. Our study develops a dynamic methodology for vaccine allocation, segmented by region, age, and timeframe, using a time-sensitive, age-structured compartmental model. Based on the objective of minimizing a weighted sum of deaths and cases, we used the Sequential Least Squares Quadratic Programming method to search for a locally optimal COVID-19 vaccine allocation for the United States, for the period from 16 December 2020 to 30 June 2021, where regions corresponded to the 50 states in the United States (U.S.). We also compared our solution to actual allocations of vaccines. From our model, we estimate that approximately 1.8 million cases and 9 thousand deaths could have been averted in the U.S. with an improved allocation. When case reduction is prioritized over death reduction, we found that young people (17 and younger) should receive priority over old people due to their potential to expose others. However, if death reduction is prioritized over case reduction, we found that more vaccines should be allocated to older people, due to their propensity for severe disease. While we have applied our methodology to COVID-19, our approach generalizes to other human-transmissible diseases, with potential application to future epidemics.

immunology,medicine, research & experimental
On the mass COVID-19 vaccination scheduling problem

Chuang Zhang,Yantong Li,Junhai Cao,Xin Wen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cor.2022.105704

2022-05-01

Abstract:The outbreak of COVID-19 dramatically impacts the global economy. Mass COVID-19 vaccination is widely regarded as the most promising way to fight against the pandemic and help return to normal. Many governments have authorized certain types of vaccines for mass vaccination by establishing appointment platforms. Mass vaccination poses a vital challenge to decision-makers responsible for scheduling a large number of appointments. This paper studies a vaccination site selection, appointment acceptance, appointment assignment, and scheduling problem for mass vaccination in response to COVID-19. An optimal solution to the problem determines the open vaccination sites, the set of accepted appointments, the assignment of accepted appointments to open vaccination sites, and the vaccination sequence at each site. The objective is to simultaneously minimize 1) the fixed cost for operating vaccination sites; 2) the traveling distance of vaccine recipients; 3) the appointment rejection cost; and 4) the vaccination tardiness cost. We formulate the problem as a mixed-integer linear program (MILP). Given the NP-hardness of the problem, we then develop an exact logic-based Benders decomposition (LBBD) method and a matheuristic method (MH) to solve practical-sized problem instances. We conduct numerical experiments on small- to large-sized instances to demonstrate the performance of the proposed model and solution methods. Computational results indicate that the proposed methods provide optimal solutions to small-sized instances and near-optimal solutions to large ones. In particular, the developed matheuristic can efficiently solve practical-sized instances with up to 500 appointments and 50 vaccination sites. We discuss managerial implications drawn from our results for the mass COVID-19 vaccination appointment scheduling, which help decision-makers make critical decisions.

computer science, interdisciplinary applications,engineering, industrial,operations research & management science
Design of Targeted Community-Based Resource Allocation in the Presence of Vaccine Hesitancy via a Data-Driven Compartmental Stochastic Optimization Model

Hieu Bui,Sandra Eksioglu,Ruben Proano,Haoming Shen

2024-05-09

Abstract:Vaccines have proven effective in mitigating the threat of severe infections and deaths during outbreaks of infectious diseases. However, vaccine hesitancy (VH) complicates disease spread prediction and healthcare resource assessment across regions and populations. We propose a modeling framework that integrates an epidemiological compartmental model that captures the spread of an infectious disease within a multi-stage stochastic program (MSP) that determines the allocation of critical resources under uncertainty. The proposed compartmental MSP model adaptively manages the allocation of resources to account for changes in population behavior toward vaccines (i.e., variability in VH), the unique patterns of disease spread, and the availability of healthcare resources over time and space. The compartmental MSP model allowed us to analyze the price of fairness in resource allocation. Using real COVID-19 vaccination and healthcare resource data from Arkansas, U.S. (January-May 2021), our findings include: (i) delaying the initial deployment of additional ventilators by one month could lead to an average increase in the expected number of deaths by 285.41/month, highlighting the importance of prompt action; (ii) each additional ventilator in the initial stockpile and in supply leads to a decrease in the expected number of deaths by 1.09/month and 0.962/month, respectively, emphasizing the importance of maintaining a large stockpile and scalable production response; (iii) the cost of ensuring equitable resource allocation varies over time and location, peaking during the peak of a disease outbreak and in densely populated areas. This study emphasizes the importance of flexible, informed public health decision-making and preparedness, providing a model for effective resource allocation in public health emergencies.

Optimization and Control,Physics and Society
Optimizing age specific strategies of vaccination for prevention of cytomegalovirus infection in the US using agent-based simulation

Dawei Wang,Yao-Hsuan Chen,Mario Ventresca

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.epidem.2023.100698

IF: 5.324

Epidemics

Abstract:Background: There is an urgent need to develop a cytomegalovirus (CMV) vaccine as it remains the leading cause of birth defects in the United States. While several CMV vaccine candidates are currently in late-stage clinical trials, the most effective vaccination program remains an open research question. Methods: To take into account the critical uncertainties when evaluating the vaccine impact on both vertical (congenital) and horizontal CMV transmissions, we developed a CMV agent-based model representative of the US population and contact network structures. Results: We evaluated 648 vaccination scenarios under various assumptions of vaccination age, vaccine efficacy, protection duration, and vaccination coverage. The optimal age of vaccination under all scenarios is shown to be during early childhood. However, a relatively modest benefit was also seen with vaccination of females of reproduction age (around age of 25) assuming near universal coverage and long vaccine-mediated protection. Conclusions: This study highlights the important need for a pediatric vaccination program in mitigating CMV in the United States. Our model is poised to investigate further location-based vaccine effectiveness questions in future planning of both clinical trials as well as eventual program implementation.
A network-based model to assess vaccination strategies for the COVID-19 pandemic by using Bayesian optimization

Gilberto González-Parra,Javier Villanueva-Oller,F.J. Navarro-González,Josu Ceberio,Giulia Luebben

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chaos.2024.114695

2024-04-01

Abstract:In this paper we build a network-based model to evaluate and compare vaccination plans in order to find the optimal strategies. The age-structured model is designed to take into account the comorbidity status and vaccination hesitancy of the population. The network-based model is calibrated to reported infected cases and deaths in the USA in order to obtain an approximated realistic scenario to test the vaccination strategies. We adapt an algorithm that is based on Bayesian optimization over permutation spaces with heuristics in order to deal with the discrete space of the vaccination strategies. We also developed an ad-hoc randomized algorithm which has a higher computational cost. Both algorithms provide similar patterns of the best found vaccination strategies. We find that these best vaccination plans prioritize the age-groups 40–59 and 60–69 years old, both with comorbidities. This result shows the highly nonlinear complexity related to the problem and its dependence on social contacts and case fatality rates. The developed network-based model adapts well to the uncertainty and heterogeneity of the real world situation and allows us to assess the efficacy of many vaccination strategies. The stochastic nature of the simulations enables us to explore additional potential scenarios and the findings offer useful information for developing vaccination plans for other future potential pandemics.

mathematics, interdisciplinary applications,physics, mathematical, multidisciplinary
A decision support framework for optimal vaccine distribution across a multi-tier cold chain network

Shanmukhi Sripada,Ayush Jain,Prasanna Ramamoorthy,Varun Ramamohan

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cie.2023.109397

2023-06-24

Abstract:In this paper, we present a decision support framework for optimizing multiple aspects of vaccine distribution across a multi-tier cold chain network. We propose two multi-period optimization formulations within this framework: first to minimize inventory, ordering, transportation, personnel and shortage costs associated with a single vaccine; the second for the case when multiple vaccines with differing efficacies and costs are available for the same disease. We use the case of the Indian state of Bihar and COVID-19 vaccines to illustrate the implementation of the framework. We present computational experiments including what-if scenario and sensitivity analyses to demonstrate: (a) the organization of the model outputs; (b) how the models can be used to assess the impact of cold chain point storage capacities, transportation vehicle capacities, and manufacturer capacities on the optimal vaccine distribution pattern; and (c) the impact of vaccine efficacies and associated costs such as ordering and transportation costs on the vaccine selection decision informed by the model. We then demonstrate how robust optimization versions of the single vaccine model, with box and budgeted uncertainty sets, outperform the deterministic version under multiple levels of uncertainty in key model parameters. Finally, we also consider the computational expense of the framework for realistic problem instances, and suggest multiple preprocessing techniques to reduce computational runtimes. Our study presents public health authorities and other stakeholders with a vaccine distribution and capacity planning tool for multi-tier cold chain networks.

computer science, interdisciplinary applications,engineering, industrial
Optimizing Vaccine Allocation Strategies in Pandemic Outbreaks: An Optimal Control Approach

Sander Tonkens,Paul de Klaver,Mauro Salazar

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2112.11908

2021-12-13

Populations and Evolution

Abstract:Since early 2020, the world has been dealing with a raging pandemic outbreak: COVID-19. A year later, vaccines have become accessible, but in limited quantities, so that governments needed to devise a strategy to decide which part of the population to prioritize when assigning the available doses, and how to manage the interval between doses for multi-dose vaccines. In this paper, we present an optimization framework to address the dynamic double-dose vaccine allocation problem whereby the available vaccine doses must be administered to different age-groups to minimize specific societal objectives. In particular, we first identify an age-dependent Susceptible-Exposed-Infected-Recovered (SEIR) epidemic model including an extension capturing partially and fully vaccinated people, whereby we account for age-dependent immunity and infectiousness levels together with disease severity. Second, we leverage our model to frame the dynamic age-dependent vaccine allocation problem for different societal objectives, such as the minimization of infections or fatalities, and solve it with nonlinear programming techniques. Finally, we carry out a numerical case study with real-world data from The Netherlands. Our results show how different societal objectives can significantly alter the optimal vaccine allocation strategy. For instance, we find that minimizing the overall number of infections results in delaying second doses, whilst to minimize fatalities it is important to fully vaccinate the elderly first.
Vaccination for communicable endemic diseases: optimal allocation of initial and booster vaccine doses

Isabelle J. Rao,Margaret L. Brandeau

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00285-024-02111-x

2024-06-27

Journal of Mathematical Biology

Abstract:For some communicable endemic diseases (e.g., influenza, COVID-19), vaccination is an effective means of preventing the spread of infection and reducing mortality, but must be augmented over time with vaccine booster doses. We consider the problem of optimally allocating a limited supply of vaccines over time between different subgroups of a population and between initial versus booster vaccine doses, allowing for multiple booster doses. We first consider an SIS model with interacting population groups and four different objectives: those of minimizing cumulative infections, deaths, life years lost, or quality-adjusted life years lost due to death. We solve the problem sequentially: for each time period, we approximate the system dynamics using Taylor series expansions, and reduce the problem to a piecewise linear convex optimization problem for which we derive intuitive closed-form solutions. We then extend the analysis to the case of an SEIS model. In both cases vaccines are allocated to groups based on their priority order until the vaccine supply is exhausted. Numerical simulations show that our analytical solutions achieve results that are close to optimal with objective function values significantly better than would be obtained using simple allocation rules such as allocation proportional to population group size. In addition to being accurate and interpretable, the solutions are easy to implement in practice. Interpretable models are particularly important in public health decision making.

mathematical & computational biology,biology
Study of optimal vaccination strategies for early COVID-19 pandemic using an age-structured mathematical model: A case study of the USA

Giulia Luebben,Gilberto González-Parra,Bishop Cervantes

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3934/mbe.2023481

2023-01-01

Mathematical Biosciences and Engineering

Abstract:In this paper we study different vaccination strategies that could have been implemented for the early COVID-19 pandemic. We use a demographic epidemiological mathematical model based on differential equations in order to investigate the efficacy of a variety of vaccination strategies under limited vaccine supply. We use the number of deaths as the metric to measure the efficacy of each of these strategies. Finding the optimal strategy for the vaccination programs is a complex problem due to the large number of variables that affect the outcomes. The constructed mathematical model takes into account demographic risk factors such as age, comorbidity status and social contacts of the population. We perform simulations to assess the performance of more than three million vaccination strategies which vary depending on the vaccine priority of each group. This study focuses on the scenario corresponding to the early vaccination period in the USA, but can be extended to other countries. The results of this study show the importance of designing an optimal vaccination strategy in order to save human lives. The problem is extremely complex due to the large amount of factors, high dimensionality and nonlinearities. We found that for low/moderate transmission rates the optimal strategy prioritizes high transmission groups, but for high transmission rates, the optimal strategy focuses on groups with high CFRs. The results provide valuable information for the design of optimal vaccination programs. Moreover, the results help to design scientific vaccination guidelines for future pandemics.

mathematical & computational biology
A modeling-based approach to optimize COVID-19 vaccine dosing schedules for improved protection

Prashant Dogra,Carmine Schiavone,Zhihui Wang,Javier Ruiz-Ramírez,Sergio Caserta,Daniela I Staquicini,Christopher Markosian,Jin Wang,H Dirk Sostman,Renata Pasqualini,Wadih Arap,Vittorio Cristini

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2022.09.14.22279959

2023-01-31

MedRxiv

Abstract:While the development of different vaccines has slowed the dissemination of SARS-CoV-2, the occurrence of breakthrough infections continues to fuel the pandemic. As a strategy to secure at least partial protection, with a single dose of a given COVID-19 vaccine to maximum possible fraction of the population, delayed administration of subsequent doses (or boosters) has been implemented in many countries. However, waning immunity and emergence of new variants of SARS-CoV-2 suggest that such measures may jeopardize the attainment of herd immunity due to intermittent lapses in protection. Optimizing vaccine dosing schedules could thus make the difference between periodic occurrence of breakthrough infections or effective control of the pandemic. To this end, we have developed a mechanistic mathematical model of adaptive immune response to vaccines and demonstrated its applicability to COVID-19 mRNA vaccines as a proof-of-concept for future outbreaks. The model was thoroughly calibrated against multiple clinical datasets involving immune response to SARS-CoV-2 infection and mRNA vaccines in healthy and immunocompromised subjects (cancer patients undergoing therapy); the model showed robust clinical validation by accurately predicting neutralizing antibody kinetics, a correlate of vaccine-induced protection, in response to multiple doses of mRNA vaccines. Importantly, we estimated population vulnerability to breakthrough infections and predicted tailored vaccination dosing schedules to maximize protection and thus minimize breakthrough infections, based on the immune status of a sub-population. We have identified a critical waiting window for cancer patients (or, immunocompromised subjects) to allow recovery of the immune system (particularly CD4+ T-cells) for effective differentiation of B-cells to produce neutralizing antibodies and thus achieve optimal vaccine efficacy against variants of concern, especially between the first and second doses. Also, we have obtained optimized dosing schedules for subsequent doses in healthy and immunocompromised subjects, which vary from the CDC-recommended schedules, to minimize breakthrough infections. The developed modeling tool is based on generalized adaptive immune response to antigens and can thus be leveraged to guide vaccine dosing schedules during future outbreaks.

A complication of orbital emphysema

Pediatric vaccine tender scheduling in low- and middle-income countries

Outreach Strategies for Vaccine Distribution: A Multi-period Stochastic Modeling Approach

Optimization of an adult immunization program in Canada

Optimization of Distribution Network Configuration for Pediatric Vaccines using Chance Constraint Programming

How can age-based vaccine allocation strategies be optimized? A multi-objective optimization framework

Vaccine network design to maximize immunization coverage

Optimal Immunization Policy Using Dynamic Programming

Two educational interventions to improve pediatricians' knowledge and skills in performing ankle and knee physical examinations.

Optimization of vaccination for COVID-19 in the midst of a pandemic

Heuristic algorithm tool for planning mass vaccine campaigns

Dynamic Vaccine Allocation for Control of Human-Transmissible Disease

On the mass COVID-19 vaccination scheduling problem

Design of Targeted Community-Based Resource Allocation in the Presence of Vaccine Hesitancy via a Data-Driven Compartmental Stochastic Optimization Model

Optimizing age specific strategies of vaccination for prevention of cytomegalovirus infection in the US using agent-based simulation

A network-based model to assess vaccination strategies for the COVID-19 pandemic by using Bayesian optimization

A decision support framework for optimal vaccine distribution across a multi-tier cold chain network

Optimizing Vaccine Allocation Strategies in Pandemic Outbreaks: An Optimal Control Approach

Vaccination for communicable endemic diseases: optimal allocation of initial and booster vaccine doses

Study of optimal vaccination strategies for early COVID-19 pandemic using an age-structured mathematical model: A case study of the USA

A modeling-based approach to optimize COVID-19 vaccine dosing schedules for improved protection