Understanding how gay men construct 'good' chemsex participation using critical discursive psychology
Siobhán Healy-CullenAdam ShanleyChris Noonea School of Psychology,University of Galway,Palmerston North,New Zealandb MPOWER Programme,HIV Ireland,Galway,Dublin,IrelandDr Siobhán Healy-Cullen's research is located in the critical health and social psychology space – a social justice informed approach that understands psychological issues as located in socio-political,historical contexts. She is therefore invested in questioning taken-for-granted ideas about what 'good' 'healthy' sex/uality is,and has written on topics such as pornography and sexual consent. Siobhán is interested in applying creative and critical research methodologies to explore alternative ways of understanding topics that are often discussed from a medical,clinical lens – such as chemsex. Particularly,she is interested in questioning how power shapes health policy/programme development,including chemsex support strategies.Adam Shanley is an activist,educator,and change-maker. He is the MPOWER Programme Manager at HIV Ireland. MPOWER is a suite of peer-driven interventions he has developed in response to the sexual health and wellbeing needs of gay and bisexual men. Adam is a dedicated advocate for gay men's sexual health. He has pioneered the development of services for his community and advised on national sexual health policy,placing the sexual health issues of gay and bisexual men firmly on the national public health agenda. Adam has been actively involved in Ireland's LGBT+ community for many years. He is committed to social justice and the accessibility of support for both individual and community wellbeing.Dr Chris Noone is a Lecturer in the School of Psychology at NUI Galway,Ireland. His research focuses on health and wellbeing within the LGBT+ community,with a special interest in identity and health among gay and bi men. He co-founded the Irish Sexualities and Genders Research Network in 2019 and is a member of the European Public Health Association Sexual and Gender Minority Health Steering Committee. Chris is also a committee member for the European Health Psychology Society Open Science Special Interest Group and a research associate with Evidence Synthesis Ireland and Cochrane Ireland. Outside of academia,Chris is a board member of the National LGBT Federation.
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/19419899.2024.2308009
2024-01-24
Psychology and Sexuality
Abstract:Research to date has focused on the potential issues arising from chemsex and often seeks to uncover what is 'wrong' with those who are motivated to engage in chemsex. Critical chemsex studies reaches beyond this harm-orientated focus and instead adopts a social justice approach that recognises chemsex participants as legitimate sexual citizens. The present study – comprising eight interviews with gay men living in Ireland – is situated within this critical research praxis. Using a critical discursive psychology framework, our analysis demonstrates how participants draw on various interpretative repertoires to discursively negotiate chemsex identities in a bid to position themselves in a culturally intelligible manner. Participants deployed three key repertoires, centred around (i) harm, (ii) essentialism, and (iii) ethics. These repertoires are deployed in an interweaving manner to ultimately construct a dynamic, hierarchal continuum of chemsex participants – from flourishing, to flailing. Our analysis demonstrates how chemsex participants construct 'other' chemsex users as 'flailing' towards the bottom of the continuum by mobilising repertoires that draw upon prevailing moralistic notions of 'good' sexual citizenship. We argue that the mainstream construction of chemsex as inevitably harmful is restrictive and produces a deficit understanding of chemsex participants, and discuss the possibilities for discursively reimagining chemsex participation.
psychology, multidisciplinary