Evaluation and clinical application of a new classification system for Kümmell disease
葛朝元,何立民,郑永宏,刘团江,董亮,贺宝荣,郝定均
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1004-406X.2017.04.04
2017-01-01
Abstract:Objectives:To propose a new system for classifying Kümmell disease,and to evaluate its feasibility for guiding clinical treatment.Methods:A retrospective study of 168 cases of Kümmell disease with complete follow-up data was conducted at our institute.Patients were divided into type Ⅰ-Ⅴ based on a conbination of clinical manifestations and different morphological changes detected by imaging.Type Ⅰ was characterized by bone non-union imaging,percutaneous vertebroplasty(PVP) was the primary treatment option for this basic imaging morphological change in Kümmell disease.Type Ⅱ was characterized by instability imaging,posterior fixation and fusion was the primary treatment option.Type Ⅲ was characterized by spinal stenosis imaging,the primary treatment option was posterior decompression fixation and fusion.Type Ⅳ was characterized by kyphosis imaging,the primary treatment option was posterior osteotomy,fixation,and fusion.Type Ⅴ was characterized by a combination of 3 or 4 of the above imaging signs,the treatment provided was related to the specific responsible types.Treatment outcomes were evaluated based on postoperative visual analogue scale(VAS) and Oswestry disability index(ODI) scores.During the follow-up period,it was observed whether the damaged vertebra exhibited compression or local secondary kyphosis and whether neurological function improved in patients accompanying with neurological symptoms.Results:Each patient received between 12-54(mean,28.4±4.6) months of follow-up.Patients of each type had statistically significant improvements in postoperative VAS and ODI scores compared with preoperative scores.The VAS scores of type Ⅰ-Ⅴ patients improved from preoperative 8.0±1.7,8.2±1.6,8.4±1.4,7.9±1.2 and 8.5±1.3 points respectively,tothe final follow-up of 2.1±1.3,2.2±1.2,2.3±1.4,2.2±1.4,2.3±1.5 points.And the ODI scores of type Ⅰ-Ⅴpatients improved from preoperative 69.5±2.8,68.5±2.6,69.7±2.2,65.6±2.7 and 68.6±2.7 respectively,to thefinal follow-up of 38.1±1.5,37.1±1.3,34.1±1.3,35.2±1.4,33.1±2.1 points.The difference was statistically sig-nificant(P<0.05).During the follow-up period,19 patients(11.3%) exhibited compression of damaged vertebraor local secondary kyphotic deformity.At the final follow-up of patients with neurological deficits,the Ameri-can Spinal Injury Association(ASIA) grade of C in 12 patients improved to grade D in 3 cases,grade E in 9cases,and 3 patients of grade D all improved to grade E.Conclusions:This new classification of Kümmelldisease in type Ⅰ-Ⅴ is objective,simple and easy to perform,and can effectively guide clinical treatment.