Field Station Spring 1985 Natural tree reproduction in urban environments
J. Boyd
Abstract:Three contrasting urban areas in Milwaukee County were sampled to determine the tree species reproducing and the habitats in which seedlings become established. Habitats most favorable for seedl ing cstabl ishment were shrub hedges and areas along fence lines or adjacent to buildings. Overall. elm and ash were the taxa most successful in establishing seedlings. In the Menomonee Valley, seedlings of boxelder and tree-of-heaven were most abundant with elm and ash close behind, while in Shorewood and Brown Deer, a great variety of seedlings was present. Elm. ash, boxe1der. Norway maple, buckthorn, cherry and mountain ash were the most prevalen~ Successful seedling establishment depends upon availability of sites that offer exposed soil for germination and temporary protection from disturbance. IIITROOUCT ION Most urban dwellers assume that trees growing in the city were either planted there or are leftovers from some distant time. before the city developed. Despite this perception, there are many trees in the city that originate directly from seed. These wild or feral trees are those whose presence was not planned. Trees provide many benefits in the city; they create aesthetically pleasing views, control so11 erosion. provide shade and abate pollution (Landphear 1971. Grey and Deneke 1978). In addition. they help to reduce noise (Cook and VanHaverbeke 1972) and provide habitat for urban wi1dl He (Stearns 1975). Urban trees exist under stress. For successful survival in the city. growing space is required. as well as a modicum of resistance to and protection from the physical. chemical and biological components of the environment. I.e. "bulldozer disease". air pollution, road salting and vandalism. Our knowledge of the development of unplanted trees within the city is limited. lie know little about which species reproduce in urban areas, or in what sites reproduction is successful. This study was conducted to explore those questions and to provide groundwork for further studies on urban arboreal vegetation (Boyd 1983). Study si tes were chosen to represent three types of urban envi ronment in which trees might become established. Sites were selected in a recently 15 developed suburb Brown Oeer, an older suburb Shorewood, and an industrial area the Menomonee River Valley in Mi lwaukee. I'ETHOOS Sampling in the three areas followed a modified stratified random pattern. Brown Oeer sampling sites were selected in one-block units and additional sites were chosen at distances six blocks from the initial sites. A total of fifteen units was sampled. In the Menomonee Valley, site selection was based on three east-west transects. Each site was 161 m long and sites were separated by 300 m or more. Nineteen sites were sampled. Shorewood was divided into two habitats, alleys and front yards, and each type was sampled with 15 alley and 13 front yard sites. At each site in Brown Oeer and Shorewood seedlings were counted along both sides of the street, in front and side yards for the length of a block. Side hedges when encountered, were followed into the side yard but not into the back yard. Where density of seedlings was high, areas were subsampled. In the Menomonee Valley, areas 12 m into the site were sampled, save where a fence prevented access, in which case the fence was followed around the area. Shorewood alleys were sampled on only one side, since they had high densities of seedlings and the samples included the area from the pavement to the limit of the residential back yard, generally a fence or hedge. Vigor, height, distance from the street, distance to the nearest mature individual of that species, and location, were recorded for each seedling as were data on the nearest mature trees, including diameter at breast height (OBH) and vigor, and the nature of the seedli ng establ t shment zone. Oata were coded and key punched and SPSS programs were used for analysis. In all, 3245 seedlings and 1511 mature trees were recorded. Seed Availability and Establishment Sites Many species of urban trees, both native and exotic, are capable of producing seed and do so. In the case of cottonwood (Populus deltoides) for example, heavy seed production results in this useful urban tree often being designated as a nui sance. For a tree to become establ i shed, a suitable site and opportuni ty must be provided. Thus, this study examines establishment and early survtval of urban tree seedlings, without which the production of seed is meaningless. Ava i 1ab1e seed is re 1ated to the number of ma ture trees presen t. The reI ationship Is demonstrated in the three sample sites. Shorewood has a much higher densi ty of mature trees (1.74/100 m2) than the Menomonee 1ndustrl al area (0.22/100 m2) and also has a correspondingly greater density of seedlings (5.57/100 m2 as compared to only 1.10/100 m2 for the Menomonee Valley) (Table n. However, other factors are involved, since Brown Oeer, with an intermediate density of mature trees shows a far smaller seedltng density than even the Menomonee Valley. Presumably, the difference lies in the relative youth of that Table 1 Mature trees and seedlings in Brown Deer, Shorewood and the Menomonee Valley Menomonee Four Brown Deer Industrial Shorewood Shorewood Sites Vall ey Yards All eys Combined Number of spec i es Mature trees 31 12 35 28 38 Seedlings 25 8 20 17 33 Number of seedling species that make up 10 5 5 8 over 2.5':; of total '" population I ndi vi dual s in sample Ma ture trees 838 72 400 201 1511 Seedlings 364 35