Comparison of Predictive Ability of Arterial Stiffness Parameters Including Cardio-Ankle Vascular Index, Pulse Wave Velocity and Cardio-Ankle Vascular Index0
Daiji Nagayama,Kentaro Fujishiro,Kenji Suzuki,Kohji Shirai
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2147/VHRM.S378292
2022-09-13
Vascular Health and Risk Management
Abstract:Daiji Nagayama, 1, 2 Kentaro Fujishiro, 3 Kenji Suzuki, 3 Kohji Shirai 4 1 Department of Internal Medicine, Nagayama Clinic, Tochigi, Japan; 2 Center of Diabetes, Endocrinology and Metabolism, Toho University, Sakura Medical Center, Chiba, Japan; 3 Research and Development Division, Japan Health Promotion Foundation, Tokyo, Japan; 4 Internal Medicine, Mihama Hospital, Chiba, Japan Correspondence: Daiji Nagayama, Nagayama Clinic, 2-12-22, Tenjin-Cho, Oyama-City, Tochigi, 323-0032, Japan, Tel +81-285-22-0219, Fax +81-285-22-0219, Email Cardio-ankle vascular index (CAVI) was developed to reflect the stiffness of the arterial tree from the aortic origin to the ankle. This arterial stiffness parameter is useful for assessing the severity of cardiovascular disease (CVD) and its risk. However, compared to pulse wave velocity (PWV), the conventional gold standard of arterial stiffness parameter, there has been a concern regarding CAVI that there are fewer longitudinal studies for CVD. Furthermore, the accuracy of CAVI for atherosclerotic diseases compared to other parameters has not been well validated. This review article aims to summarize recent findings to clarify the predictive ability of CAVI in longitudinal studies. First, several large longitudinal studies have found that not only baseline CAVI but also CAVI changes during the observation period predict cardiovascular events. Second, CAVI may have superior discriminatory power for all-cause mortality and major adverse cardiovascular endpoints compared to PWV. Furthermore, one large longitudinal study found CAVI to be a stronger predictor for renal function decline compared to PWV as well as CAVI 0 , a variant of CAVI that mathematically excludes BP dependence. Additionally, CAVI shows the properties that allow the elucidation of specific hemodynamics in aortic valve disease or hypovolemia. In conclusion, CAVI may be a modifiable arterial stiffness parameter not only for predicting and preventing atherosclerotic diseases but also for elucidating specific hemodynamic pathophysiology. Keywords: cardio-ankle vascular index, pulse wave velocity, CAVI 0 , longitudinal study, cardiovascular disease, renal function decline Arterial stiffness reflects the ageing and loss of elasticity in blood vessels, and is used as a predictor of cardiovascular disease (CVD). 1 The most commonly used arterial stiffness parameter is pulse wave velocity (PWV). 2 However, this parameter is inherently influenced by blood pressure (BP) at the time of measurement, 3 and may underestimate the degree of vascular dysfunction due to CVD risks other than hypertension. The cardio-ankle vascular index (CAVI) has been established to address this issue. CAVI reflects the stiffness of the whole arterial tree comprising the aorta, femoral artery and tibial artery. 4 The BP independence of CAVI has been confirmed both theoretically and experimentally. 3–5 CAVI can therefore clarify the intrinsic impact of BP on atherogenesis, 6 and has been reported to be associated positively with a number of CVD risk factors, severity of CVD and future cardiovascular (CV) events. Additionally, appropriate therapeutic interventions to reduce CAVI are expected to contribute to the prevention of future CV events. 7 However, there has been a concern regarding CAVI that there are fewer longitudinal studies for CV events compared to PWV. Moreover, a warning was issued that CAVI may lead to erroneous conclusions because it does not fully correct for BP dependence. Spronck et al 8 have proposed CAVI 0 as a variant of CAVI that theoretically corrects even more strongly for the BP dependence. The accuracy of these aforementioned arterial stiffness parameters has not yet been fully compared. Based on these backgrounds, this review article aims to summarize recent findings about CAVI in longitudinal studies for predicting atherosclerotic diseases. In addition, the predictive ability of the three arterial stiffness parameters (CAVI, PWV and CAVI 0 ) was compared. Table 1 shows large-scale longitudinal studies examining the predictive ability of CAVI in which there were more than 200 participants. In most studies, baseline CAVI was a predictor of future cardiovascular (CV) events or mortality, and was also associated with new-appearance of atrial fibrillation. 21 Table 1 Summary on Association of CAVI with Cardiovascular Outcomes in Prospective Studies Especially, some reports showed that the change in CAVI was also associated with CVD outcomes. Otsuka et al 10 demonstrated that persistent impairment of arterial stiffness was an independent risk for future CV events in 211 subjec -Abstract Truncated-