Factors associated with failed epidural blood patch after accidental dural puncture in obstetrics: a prospective, multicentre, international cohort study

Anil Gupta,Marc Van de Velde,Anders Magnuson,Christian von Heymann,Emilia Guasch,Seppo Alahuhta,Frédéric J Mercier,Alexandra M J V Schyns-van den Berg,European Practices in the Management of Accidental Dural Puncture in Obstetrics Investigators,Isabelle Casier,Bart Bryon,Filiep Soetens,Pierre-Yves Dewandre,Geraldine Lambert,Jan Christiaen,Roel Schepers,Patrick Van Houwe,Alain Kalmar,Henk Vanoverschelde,Monique Bauters,Eva Roofthooft,Sarah Devroe,Ana Jadrijevic,Aleksandra Jokic,Damjan Marin,Ivan Sklebar,Slobodan Mihaljević,Martina Kosinova,Petr Stourac,Milan Adamus,Christian Kufa,Ivana Volfová,Blažena Zaoralová,Christina Froeslev-Friis,Bjoern Mygil,Charlotte Krebs Albrechtsen,Tomi Kavasmaa,Anne Mäyrä,Susanna Mennander,Kati Rautaneva,Tuula Hiekkanen,Vesa Kontinen,Kirsti Linden,Sara Toivakka,Emmanuel Boselli,Pierre-Édouard Greil,Olivier Mascle,Aurelie Courbon,Jean Lutz,Thérèse Simonet,Marie Barbier,Tarik Hlioua,Fleur Meniolle d'Hauthville,Christine Quintin,Karim Bouattour,Agnès Lecinq,Frederic Mercier,Marie-Pierre Bonnet,Mathieu Carbonniere,Catherine Fischer,Paola-Carla Picard,Martine Bonnin,Brigitte Storme,Anne-Sophie Bouthors,Thomas Detente,Truong Minh Nguyen,Hawa Keita,Sophie Nebout,Lauranne Osse,Anne Delmas,Florence Vial,Lutz Kaufner,Christoph Hoefing,Stefan Mueller,Karin Becke,Manfred Blobner,Heidrun Lewald,Stefan Josef Schaller,Ellis Muggleton,Birgit Bette,Claudia Neumann,Stefan Weber,Matthias Grünewald,Henning Ohnesorge,Antonia Helf,Yvonne Jelting,Peter Kranke,Sabine Welfle,Chryssoula Staikou,Antonia Stavrianopoulou,Mattheios Stamelos,Konstantina Kalopita,Anastasia Loukeri,Dimitrios Valsamidis,Paraskevi Matsota,Adalbjörn Thorsteinsson,Riad Tome,Leonid A Eidelman,Atara Davis,Sharon Orbach-Zinger,Alexander Ioscovich,Iacob Ramona,Luigi De Simone,Barbara Pesetti,Luca Brazzi,Alessandro Zito,Michela Camorcia,Giorgio Della Rocca,Marco Aversano,Maria Grazia Frigo,Cristina Todde,Andrius Macas,Grazina Keraitiene,Kestutis Rimaitis,Francis Borg,Carl Tua,Agnes Geertje Kuijpers-Visser,Alexandra Schyns-van den Berg,Markus W Hollmann,Tijs van den Berg,Eric Koolen,Ilse Dons,Anouk van der Knijff,Caroline van der Marel,Nele Ruysschaert,Michal Pelka,Christine Pluymakers,Seppe Koopman,Aart-Jan Teunissen,Dick Cornelisse,Nick van Dasselaar,Bastiaan Verdouw,Ingrid Beenakkers,Vegard Dahl,Robert Hagen,Francesco Vivaldi,John Reidar Eriksen,Radovan Wiszt,Naz Aslam Tayyba,Else-Marie Ringvold,Radosław Chutkowski,Tomasz Skirecki,Bartłomiej Wódarski,Maria Aida Faria,Amélia Ferreira,Ana Catarina Sampaio,Irene Ferreira,Bernardo Matias,Joana Teixeira,Rita Araujo,Herminia Cabido,Rosario Fortuna,Paulo Lemos,Carolina Cardoso,Fernando Moura,Cristiana Pereira,Sandra Pereira,Manuel Abecasis,Filipa Lança,Paulo Muchacho,Lucindo Ormonde,Isabel Guedes-Araujo,Vitor Pinho-Oliveira,Paulo Paredes,Carla Bentes,Francisco Gouveia,Ana Milheiro,Cláudia Castanheira,Miriam Neves,Vânia Pacheco,Mara Cortez,Raquel Tranquada,Glória Tareco,Inês Furtado,Estela Pereira,Luísa Marinho,Manuel Seabra,Aleksandra Bulasevic,Mirjana Kendrisic,Lidija Jovanovic,Borislava Pujić,Marija Kutlesic,Monika Grochova,Jana Simonova,Gordana Pavlovic,Ales Rozman,Iva Blajic,Dragan Graovac,Tatjana Stopar Pintaric,Teresa Chiquito,Pablo Monedero,Joaquin De Carlos-Errea,Roque Guillén-Casbas,Leonor Veiga-Gil,Morena Basso,Carolina Garcia Bartolo,Cristian Hernandez,Laura Ricol,Maroto Pinar De Santos,Josep A Gràcia Solsona,Manuel López-Baamonde,Marta Magaldi Mendaña,Ana María Plaza Moral,Marina Vendrell,Lourdes Trillo,Anibal Ricardo Perez Garcia,Clara Alamillo Salas,Enric Moret,Laura Ramió,Jose Luis Aguilar Sanchez,Maria Soler Pedrola,Maria Inmaculada Valldeperas Hernandez,Gorka Aldalur,Estíbaliz Bárcena,Julia Herrera,Fernando Iturri,Alberto Martínez,Leire Martínez,Rosa Serna,Fernando Gilsanz,Emilia Guasch Arevalo,Fabrizio Iannuccelli,Julieta Latorre,Cristina Rodriguez Roca,Osvaldo Ceferino Pérez Pardo,Natalia Sierra Biddle,Ceferina Suárez Castaño,Lourdes Hernández González,Caridad Remacha González,Raquel Sánchez Nuez,Diego Anta,Jose M Beleña,Carmen García-Cuadrado,Irene Garcia,Susana Manrique,Elena Suarez,Anette Hein,Elisabet Arbman,Helena Hansson,Monika Tillenius,Ruaa Al-Taie,Susanne Ledin-Eriksson,Anja Lindén-Söndersö,Ola Rosén,Evija Austruma,Lars Gillberg,Bijan Darvish,Henrik Jörnvall,Johan Nordström,Jan Persson,Jan Rosenberg,Lars Brühne,Johan Forshammar,Malin Ugarph Edfeldt,Håkan Rolfsson,Anna Hellblom,Katarina Levin,Sofus Rabow,Karin Thorlacius,Peter Bansch,Moira Robertson Baeriswyl,Ulrike Stamer,Stanislas Mathivon,Georges Savoldelli,Pia Auf der Maur,Miodrag Filipovic,Alexander Dullenkopf,Maya Brunner,Thierry Girard,Claudia Vonlanthen,Sule Ozbilgin,Berrin Gunaydin D,Pelin Corman Dincer,Ayca Tas Tuna,Sylvia Daamen,Slama Farsi,Prisca Feijten,Pierre Harlet,Brigitte Leva,Benoît Plichon

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.bja.2022.06.040

Abstract:Background: Epidural blood patch is commonly used for management of post-dural puncture headache after accidental dural puncture. The primary aim was to determine factors associated with failed epidural blood patch. Methods: In this prospective, multicentre, international cohort study, parturients ≥18 yr receiving an epidural blood patch for treatment of post-dural puncture headache were included. Failed epidural blood patch was defined as headache intensity numeric rating scale (NRS) score ≥7 in the upright position at 4, 24, or 48 h, or the need for a second epidural blood patch, and complete success by NRS=0 at 0-48 h after epidural blood patch. All others were considered partial success. Multinominal logistic regression was used for statistical analyses with P<0.01 considered statistically significant. Results: In all, 643 women received an epidural blood patch. Complete data to classify failure were available in 591 (91.9%) women. Failed epidural blood patch occurred in 167 (28.3%) patients; 195 (33.0%) were completely successful and 229 (38.7%) partially successful. A total of 126 women (19.8%) received a second epidural blood patch. A statistically significant association with failure was observed in patients with a history of migraine, when the accidental dural puncture occurred between lumbar levels L1/L3 compared with L3/L5 and when epidural blood patch was performed <48 h compared with ≥48 h after accidental dural puncture. In patients having radiological investigations, three intracranial bleeds were diagnosed. Conclusions: Failed epidural blood patch occurred in 28.3% of women. Independent modifiable factors associated with failure were higher lumbar level of accidental dural puncture and short interval between accidental dural puncture and epidural blood patch. A history of migraine was associated with a higher risk of second epidural blood patch. Clinical trial registration: NCT02362828.