Analysis on the curative effects of subacromial space drug injection therapy on shoulder impingement syndrome
Kai Yu,Jian Yang,Min Liu,Jie Yang,Renjun Yang,Dianying Zhang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3877/cma.j.issn.2095-5790.2015.03.004
2015-01-01
Abstract:Background The common symptoms of shoulder impingement syndrome include shoulder pain and shoulder activity limitation,and shoulder pain is the chief complaint of majority of patients.There are many causes for shoulder pain,and the common causes include bursitis and tendon degeneration which are resulted from the impingement between subacromial bursa/rotator cuff and humerus/ acromion in the abduction activity of shoulder.The abnormal activity of humeral head and scapula which is resulted from rotator cuff injury may also cause shoulder impingement and generate symptoms.To alleviate pain and increase joint range of motion,such methods as no-load rest,cold compress,physical therapy,oral administration of nonsteroidalanti-inflammatory drugs (NSAID)and injection of cortical hormone are adopted for non-operational treatment of shoulder impingement.An international multicenter study shows that,injection of cortical hormone is an effective means for the patients for whom the other methods such as rest are ineffective without exception.However,the mechanism of its significant effect has not been made clear,and an widely accepted interpretation to its mechanism is that hormone can relieve sterile inflammatory reaction.However,the adverse effects of application of hormone for many times are obvious, and the common adverse effects include spontaneous rupture of supraspinatus tendon, skin atrophy on local injection site and cartilage degeneration at humeral head etc.The reason why local injection of hormone is effective in treatment of shoulder impingement syndrome is that hormone can relieve local inflammatory reaction.Then, whether local injection of NSAID can also avoid the adverse effects resulted from hormone in the mean time of achieving good curative effects thanks to its anti-inflammatory action? It is the objective of this study to know the effects of local injection of parecoxib sodium in reducing shoulder impingement syndrome as well as the advantages and disadvantages of hormone.Methods Ⅰ.Inclusion and exclusion criteria:The patients with shoulder impingement syndrome confirmed in Outpatient department of our hospital were selected.The inclusion criteria:(1 )there exists painful arc when shoulder is abduced by 60°-120°;(2 )Neer′s disease positive;(3 )Hawkin′s disease positive;(4) subacromial bursitis confirmed through B ultrasound or MRI.Exclusion criteria:(1)Age <18 years;(2)course of disease <1 month;(3)has history of shoulder joint injection in the past 3 weeks;(4) has past history of rotator cuff tear;(5)Has past history of shoulder osteoarthritis;(6)Has systemic inflammatory reaction disease;(7 )Has past history of shoulder operation;(8 )has past history of shoulder infection;(9)has past history of shoulder joint adhesion or instability;(10)has past history of alimentary tract ulcer and hematopathy.For each patient included in this study,our hospital described the objective and method of this study,the personal information to be acquired,the probable problems and signed informed consent.This study was performed upon approval by the Ethics Committee of Tianjin No.5 Central Hospital.Ⅱ.Study design:This study is a randomized control test.To ensure double blind trial,after the clinic doctor has issued medical advice for local injection, the patients included in study should take medicine from pharmaceutist;one fixed pharmaceutist should issue and prepare the drug for injection,and randomized evelop method is adopted (envelops randomly drawn by patients).Two kinds of drugs are prepared:(1 )Hormone group:To 40mg Triamcinolone acetonide(provided by Kunming Jida Pharmacy Co.,Ltd),add 2% lidocaine (China Otsuka Pharmaceutical Co.,Ltd),prepare the solution to 5 ml;(2 ) NSAID group:Add 2%lidocaine to Parecoxib sodium (Pfizer Pharmaceuticals Limited),and prepare the solution to 5ml.The drug is sucked into a 5 ml syringe.After the pharmacist has made numbering and recording (the content cannot be seen since envelope is added),the doctor who issued the medical device should complete local injection.Each patient is injected according to standard injection method.The "soft spot" on posterior-lateral side serves as the needle insertion point, and needle is inserted from posterior angle of acromion and inserted downwards by 2 cm and outwards by 1cm,pointing to the direction of coracoid.After completion of injection,pain relief in the abduction of shoulder joint is used as the mark of correct injection position.Ⅲ.Evaluation indicators:For each patient,the first author and the second author of this article respectively make evaluation and recording for the shoulder joint range of motion(abduction),HSS score and ache (VAS score)at 30 min prior to injection,30 min after injection and 3 weeks after injection;After completion of evaluation and recording,for each patient,take the mean value evaluated and recorded by two physicians.Ⅳ.Statistical analysis:For the comparison on the results between two groups,two sided t test is performed.If P <0.05,it is meant that the different has statistical significance.According to the Equation for sample size,calculate the required number of patients in each group.Two groups need to respectively include 14 patients.Results During the period from October 2012 to September 2014,59 patients with confirmed shoulder impingement syndrome entered the study;After evaluation based on inclusion/exclusion criteria,48 patients were incorporated into the study groups.Every 24 cases were randomly divided into hormone injection group and NASID injection group,4 cases lost to follow up (2 cases in hormone group and 2 cases in NSAID group);2 cases failed to receive follow-up visit on schedule (1 case in hormone group and 1 case in NSAID group).Through MRI at 2 weeks after injection,7 case were confirmed as rotator cuff tear (2 cases in hormone group and 3 cases in NSAID group).Finally,37 cases obtained complete follow-up visit (1 9 cases in hormone group and 18 cases in NSAID)and received MRI or ultrasonic examination,and it was made clear that they did not suffer from rotator cuff tear.Both drug injection groups received follow-up visit at 3 week after injection,when both drugs shown obvious ache relief (NSAID group:1.12±2.1 1,P =0.04;hormone group:1.48±2.97,P =0.05). However,there was no difference in ache relief when two kinds of drugs were compared (P =0.1 70).In the 3-week follow-up visit,the difference of shoulder joint HSS score of NSAID injection group in comparison with the value prior to injection has statistical significance (P =0.143 ).Both NSAID group and hormone group shown obvious improvement in abduction function in comparison with the abduction function prior to operation,with both differences having statistical significance (NSAID group:P =0.03;hormone group P =0.04).In the 3-week follow-up visit,the shoulder joint abduction range of NSAID group is greater than that of hormone group,with P =0.03.Conclusion Injection of hormone and NSAID drug under acromion can help relieve the pain of patient with shoulder impingement syndrome.The shoulder joint range of motion and HSS score of NSAID injection group are superior to those of hormone group.