Abstract:People usually exhibit conditional cooperative behavior during cooperation;that is,they cooperate only when they expect others will cooperate as well.The cognitive computations and the dynamic processes underlying such conditional cooperation in repeated interactions remain underexplored.To this end,this study investigates the cognitive mechanisms behind conditional cooperation,focusing on two hidden mental variables:positive expectation(participants'expected cooperation willingness of the partner)and the perception of social reward(additional reward derived from reciprocity). Using a repeated aversion of Prisoner's Dilemma Game(PDG),we conducted two experiments(n=134 in Experiment 1 and n=104 in Experiment 2)in this study.Nonsocial context(playing PDG with a computer program)was created to test if the effects are specific to social context(playing PDG with a supposed human partner).By manipulating partners'cooperation probabilities and response variability,we explored how positive expectation and social reward evolve during cooperation and to affect participants'behavioral outputs.We systematically developed six models to model participants'decision process during PDG.These models range from baseline model with random choice assumption(Model 1)to more complex formulations incorporating reward-based learning(Model 2),rational choice theory(Model 3),social reward(Model 4),and the integration of different learning rules(Models 5 to 6). The results of two experiments consistently demonstrated that participants dynastically adjust their cooperation decisions in response to their partners'behaviors.After separating the effects that may be brought by the partner's cooperation probability from those of response vocality,we found that participants'cooperation increases with their partner's increased cooperative behaviors,rather than with the partner's response volatility,an effect specific to social context.Model comparisons showed that participants'behaviors in both social and nonsocial contexts were best described by a model assuming social rewards and incorporating a learning algorithm that includes both first-order beliefs(based solely on others'past behavior)and second-order beliefs(considering both others'past behavior and the influence of their own behavior on others)to update their expectations of their partners'cooperation.The results indicated that increasing conditional cooperation is driven by both participants'positive expectation and social reward,effects that were specific to a social context. This study elucidated the cognitive computational dynamics of conditional cooperation,highlighted the roles of positive expectation and social reward,and showed that people applied a complex model with both first-order and second-order beliefs to update their expectations of their partner's willingness to cooperate.These contributions underscore the importance of understanding the mental processes that encourage mutual cooperation.Future studies might explore the neural correlates of these mechanisms or apply these insights to more complex scenarios,bridging the gap between laboratory research findings and real-world collaboration.

Morality in the time of cognitive famine: The effects of memory load on cooperation and honesty

Cognitive load decreases cooperation and moral punishment in a Prisoner’s Dilemma game with punishment option

Limited memory optimizes cooperation in social dilemma experiments

Cognitive-attentional mechanisms of cooperation—with implications for attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder and cognitive neuroscience

The Impact of Cognitive Load on Cooperation and Antisocial Punishment: Insights from a Public Goods Game Experiment

Callousness, exploitativeness, and tracking of cooperation incentives in the human default network

Memory as a cognitive requirement for reciprocal cooperation

Working memory load impairs tacit coordination but not inter-brain EEG synchronization

Shifting prosocial intuitions: neurocognitive evidence for a value-based account of group-based cooperation

The cognitive load effect in working memory: Refreshing the empirical landscape, removing outdated explanations

Social setting, intuition, and experience in lab experiments interact to shape cooperative decision-making

Dissociable contributions of the prefrontal cortex in group-based cooperation

Deliberation’s Blindsight

Unethical amnesia brain: Memory and metacognitive distortion induced by dishonesty

Cognitive Control Promotes Either Honesty or Dishonesty, Depending on One's Moral Default

Unravelling the many facets of human cooperation in an experimental study

A dual-process approach to cooperative decision-making under uncertainty

Co-evolution of Behaviour and Beliefs in Social Dilemmas: Estimating Material, Social, Cognitive and Cultural Determinants

Time pressure increases cooperation in competitively framed social dilemmas

A Cognitive Computational Mechanism for Mutual Cooperation: the Roles of Positive Expectation and Social Reward

Cognitive strategies take advantage of the cooperative potential of heterogeneous networks