Creating technological momentum: lessons from American and Danish wind energy research

Benjamin Sovacool,J. Sawin
Abstract:Are researchers, public policymakers, and political scientists aware of the factors that lead to the successful diffusion of energy technology? In attempting to address energy and climate challenges, the research process in the United States and other industrialized countries has often been rooted in distinct assumptions concerning science, technology, methodology, scale of implementation, and agents of action.1 Many researchers, directors, and even scholars have implicitly promoted a linear model of technological development that views government-funded programs as the ideal means of developing new technologies and systems and prioritizes economies of scale and centralization of the research process to achieve ever-larger units. According to this paradigm, the government’s role is to eliminate obstacles to energy development and work with large corporations to prepare new technologies for entry into the market. However, the evolution of wind energy technology in Denmark, represents an exception to this linear approach to energy research and diffusion. Denmark’s scientists pursued a bottom-up, decentralized research strategy that was more flexible and involved transparency, information sharing, and experimentation by those in the field. This led to the creation of more advanced and cost-effective wind turbines. Between 1975 and 1988, the US government spent twenty times as much as Denmark on wind power research, funding highly centralized and hierarchical programs. Yet, by 1990, Danish manufacturers were making better turbines than US manufacturers and dominated the world market, supplying 45 percent of the world’s turbine capacity.2 Direct US government expenditures on wind energy research from 1970 to 2007 totaled $1.4 billion, exceeding spending by all other countries. During this same period, US-made turbines, however, accounted for less than 18 percent of global installed capacity.3 General Electric, the largest turbine manufacturer in the United States, purchased a patent from the German manufacturer Tacke, rather than use domestic turbine designs.4 Today, Denmark is the uncontested world leader in
What problem does this paper attempt to address?