Being and becoming a clinician: ethnographic insights

B. Rushforth

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/14739879.2015.11494353

2015-07-01

Education for Primary Care

Abstract:What does the word ethnography conjure up in your mind? Misguided Victorian anthropologists documenting ‘savage’ indigenous tribes? Or the rarefied language of social scientists, irrelevant to humble non-academics? In this short article I hope to show that ethnographic studies can provide useful insights into our development and practice as clinicians, by shining a revealing light on social interactions within healthcare. The evidence-based movement has championed systematic reviews and meta-analyses of randomised controlled trials, but more recently there has been growing interest in research methodologies that can explain why and how interventions to improve healthcare work (or fail) in the context of ‘messy’ real-life practice. Ethnography is one such approach which places an emphasis on understanding social exchanges. But what does this mean in practice and why should clinicians and educators be interested? Traditionally, ethnographic research involved spending prolonged periods with the social group that was being studied and ethnography describes both this process and the written output. The ethnographic researcher, through analysis of both quantitative and qualitative data (the latter often captured through detailed fieldnotes) provides explanations and attributes meanings by being an embedded ‘participant observer’ within a social context, incorporating these subjective understandings within the research findings. In other words, the empirical data are not seen through a positivist lens as some objective truth to be discovered; rather, the interpretation by the participant observer is key. But does this mean that one has to spend months or even years ‘in the field’ collecting data? Not so: healthcare research has used ‘rapid’ or ‘mini’ ethnography – focused, limited time spent with practitioners – to generate useful insights into care processes. So, when we ask learners to spend time in reception, or accompany the palliative care nurses for an afternoon, in one sense we’re encouraging them to gain ethnographic insights by flexing those skills which all good family doctors possess: an ability to view people within the complex personal and social contexts that they inhabit. BOYS IN WHITE