Abstract:The acquisition of new skills is facilitated by providing individuals with feedback that reflects their performance. This process creates a closed loop that involves feedback processing and regulation recalibration to promote effective training. Functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI)-based neurofeedback is unique in applying this principle by delivering direct feedback on the self-regulation of brain activity. Understanding how feedback-driven learning occurs requires examining how feedback is evaluated and how regulation adjusts in response to feedback signals. In this pre-registered mega-analysis, we re-analyzed data from eight intermittent fMRI neurofeedback studies (N = 153 individuals) to investigate brain regions where activity and connectivity are linked to feedback processing and regulation recalibration (i.e., regulation after feedback) during training. We harmonized feedback scores presented during training in these studies and computed their linear associations with brain activity and connectivity using parametric general linear model analyses. We observed that, during feedback processing, feedback scores were positively associated with (1) activity in the reward system, dorsal attention network, default mode network, and cerebellum; and with (2) reward system-related connectivity within the salience network. During regulation recalibration, no significant associations were observed between feedback scores and either activity or associative learning-related connectivity. Our results suggest that neurofeedback is processed in the reward system, supporting the theory that reinforcement learning shapes this form of brain training. In addition, the involvement of large-scale networks in feedback processing, continuously transitioning between evaluating external feedback and internally assessing the adopted cognitive state, suggests that higher-level processing is integral to this type of learning. Our findings highlight the pivotal role of performance-related feedback as a driving force in learning, potentially extending beyond neurofeedback training to other feedback-based processes.

Modulation of neurocognitive functions associated with action preparation and early stimulus processing by response-generated feedback

Modulation of anticipatory brain activity as a function of action complexity

The effect of feedback timing on category learning and feedback processing in younger and older adults

Modulation of the brain activity in outcome evaluation by the presence of an audience: An electrophysiological investigation.

Neural Correlates of Feedback Processing in Visuo-Tactile Crossmodal Paired-Associate Learning.

Electrophysiological correlates of prediction formation in anticipation of reward‐ and punishment‐related feedback signals

Event-related potential studies of outcome processing and feedback-guided learning

An electrophysiological and behavioral investigation of feedback-based learning in aphasia

Emotional feedback ameliorates older adults' feedback-induced learning

Effects of intermittent visual feedback on EEG characteristics during motor preparation and execution in a goal-directed task

Effects of Feedback Latency on P300-based Brain-computer Interface

Neural Mechanisms of Feedback Processing and Regulation Recalibration during Neurofeedback Training

Brain Activity Elicited by Positive and Negative Feedback in Preschool-Aged Children

The Dominance of Anticipatory Prefrontal Activity in Uncued Sensory–Motor Tasks

Modulation of functional network with real-time fMRI feedback training of right premotor cortex activity.

Performing a Motor Action Enhances Social Reward Processing and Modulates the Neural Processing of Predictive Cues

On the Utility of Positive and Negative Feedback in a Paired-associate Learning Task

Brain Responses in Evaluating Feedback Stimuli with a Social Dimension.

Distinct influence of inter- versus intra-trial feedback on the brain response to subsequent feedback: Evidence from event-related potentials

Functional near-infrared spectroscopy-based neurofeedback training regulates time-on-task effects and enhances sustained cognitive performance

Effects of attentional instructions on the behavioral and neural mechanisms of speech auditory feedback control