Abstract:Machine learning is increasingly used to study vegetation growth, however, more often than not, predicting and simulating functions are prioritized over quantitative estimates of the drivers of vegetation growth such as climate. In this paper, we, for the first time, systematically investigate the model bias in calculating factor importance of climate on vegetation growth, especially when various kinds of machine learning models are considered. We undertake two case studies to simulate research in remote sensing and ground-based scenarios from which the difference in quantitative relationships between climate and vegetation is evaluated across multiple models. We found that model complexity increased the determination coefficient (R 2 ) but reduced the absolute importance of the preselected independent variables. As the fitting accuracy increases, the absolute factor importance of dominant factor and all the other influencing factors decreases simultaneously, and factor importance calculated by different models tended to be more normally distributed across the study region. The reduction in factor importance was accompanied by the increased effect of model selection; e.g. the model that was used to estimate vegetation growth played a larger role in producing the factor importance (shown by variance analysis, remote sensing scenario, F-statistic = 555.2; ground based scenario, F-statistic = 30.8) than the climate variables (variance analysis, remote sensing scenario, F = 460.8; ground based scenario, F = 28.8). Critically, for those machine learning models with highest fitting accuracy, the resultant factor importance of climate factors had smaller difference with that of random factor. In contrast, the relative factor influence among the selected climate factor is more robust and reliable (in variation analysis, model was detected no significant impact on the resultant factor importance). For 5 of 8 models, the dominant factor (temperature) has relative influence over 0.85, ranging from 0.88 to 0.99. According to the relevant result, we suggest testing the stability of factor contribution in future studies, particularly when using machine learning models in ecological research and dealing with numerous factors, before drawing relative conclusions. The balance between simple and accurate models is contested and we believe that our study will contribute to a better understand of the data behind this debate.

Predicting dominant terrestrial biomes at a global scale using machine learning algorithms, climate variable indices, and extreme climate indices

Predicting future patterns of land cover from climate projections using machine learning

Predicting global patterns of long-term climate change from short-term simulations using machine learning

Bioclimating Modelling: A Machine Learning Perspective

Machine Learning for Global Bioclimatic Classification: Enhancing Land Cover Prediction through Random Forests

Assessing the generalization of forecasting ability of machine learning and probabilistic models for complex climate characteristics

Comparative Analysis of Two Machine Learning Algorithms in Predicting Site-Level Net Ecosystem Exchange in Major Biomes

Model bias in calculating factor importance of climate on vegetation growth

Machine Learning for Bioclimatic Modelling

Predicting years with extremely low gross primary production from daily weather data using Convolutional Neural Networks

Identifying climate thresholds for dominant natural vegetation types at the global scale using machine learning: Average climate versus extremes

Research on Global Climate Change Prediction based on Machine Learning Model

Modelling Species Distributions with Deep Learning to Predict Plant Extinction Risk and Assess Climate Change Impacts

Statistical and Machine Learning Methods Applied to the Prediction of Different Tropical Rainfall Types

Biomes of the world under climate change scenarios: increasing aridity and higher temperatures lead to significant shifts in natural vegetation

Prediction of Regional Forest Biomass Using Machine Learning: A Case Study of Beijing, China

Machine Learning-Based Estimation of Daily Cropland Evapotranspiration in Diverse Climate Zones

Cold threat and moisture deficit induced individual tree mortality via 25-year monitoring in seminatural mixed forests, northeastern China

Using machine learning to analyze physical causes of climate change: A case study of U.S. Midwest extreme precipitation

Predicting and Navigating Environmental Transformations using Machine Learning

Projected Climate Change Effects on Global Vegetation Growth: A Machine Learning Approach