Pterosaurs were clad in colorful plumage

Rodrigo Pérez Ortega

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1126/science.abq6110

IF: 56.9

2022-04-22

Science

Abstract:Study suggests feathers arose-and were used for display-well before reign of dinosaurs.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Plumage Color Patterns Of An Extinct Dinosaur

Quanguo Li,Ke-Qin Gao,Jakob Vinther,Matthew D Shawkey,Julia A Clarke,Liliana D'Alba,Qingjin Meng,Derek E G Briggs,Richard O Prum

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1126/science.1186290

IF: 56.9

2010-01-01

Science

Abstract:For as long as dinosaurs have been known to exist, there has been speculation about their appearance. Fossil feathers can preserve the morphology of color-imparting melanosomes, which allow color patterns in feathered dinosaurs to be reconstructed. Here, we have mapped feather color patterns in a Late Jurassic basal paravian theropod dinosaur. Quantitative comparisons with melanosome shape and density in extant feathers indicate that the body was gray and dark and the face had rufous speckles. The crown was rufous, and the long limb feathers were white with distal black spangles. The evolution of melanin-based within-feather pigmentation patterns may coincide with that of elongate pennaceous feathers in the common ancestor of Maniraptora, before active powered flight. Feathers may thus have played a role in sexual selection or other communication.
Pterosaur melanosomes support signalling functions for early feathers

Aude Cincotta,Michaël Nicolaï,Hebert Bruno Nascimento Campos,Maria McNamara,Liliana D’Alba,Matthew D. Shawkey,Edio-Ernst Kischlat,Johan Yans,Robert Carleer,François Escuillié,Pascal Godefroit

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-022-04622-3

IF: 64.8

2022-04-20

Nature

Abstract:Abstract Remarkably well-preserved soft tissues in Mesozoic fossils have yielded substantial insights into the evolution of feathers 1 . New evidence of branched feathers in pterosaurs suggests that feathers originated in the avemetatarsalian ancestor of pterosaurs and dinosaurs in the Early Triassic 2 , but the homology of these pterosaur structures with feathers is controversial 3,4 . Reports of pterosaur feathers with homogeneous ovoid melanosome geometries 2,5 suggest that they exhibited limited variation in colour, supporting hypotheses that early feathers functioned primarily in thermoregulation 6 . Here we report the presence of diverse melanosome geometries in the skin and simple and branched feathers of a tapejarid pterosaur from the Early Cretaceous found in Brazil. The melanosomes form distinct populations in different feather types and the skin, a feature previously known only in theropod dinosaurs, including birds. These tissue-specific melanosome geometries in pterosaurs indicate that manipulation of feather colour—and thus functions of feathers in visual communication—has deep evolutionary origins. These features show that genetic regulation of melanosome chemistry and shape 7–9 was active early in feather evolution.

multidisciplinary sciences
Palaeontology: 'modern' feathers on a non-avian dinosaur.

Mark Norell,Qiang Ji,Keqin Gao,Chongxi Yuan,Yibin Zhao,Lixia Wang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/416036a

IF: 64.8

2002-01-01

Nature

Abstract:Discoveries of integumentary coverings on non-avian theropod dinosaurs are becoming commonplace. But the only definitive evidence so far that any of these animals had feathers as we know them today has come from the oviraptorosaur Caudipteryx and the enigmatic coleurosaur Protarchaeopteryx, both of which are considered by some to be secondarily flightless birds. Here we describe the occurrence of pinnate feathers, which clearly feature a rachis and barbs, on a small, non-avian dromaeosaur from northern China. This finding indicates that feathers of modern aspect evolved in dinosaurs before the emergence of birds and flight.
On the Ancestry of Feathers in Mesozoic Dinosaurs

Nicolás E. Campione,Paul M. Barrett,David C. Evans

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-27223-4_12

2020-01-01

Abstract:Over the last two decades, the dinosaur fossil record has revealed much about the nature of their epidermal structures. These data challenged long-standing hypotheses of widespread reptile-like scalation in dinosaurs and provided additional evidence that supported the deeply nested position of birds within the clade. Moreover, in recent years, the discovery of filamentous structures in numerous species across the dinosaurian evolutionary tree suggests a model of deep feather homology within dinosaurs, with the appearance of feathers hypothesised to coincide with the dinosaur origin. Thanks to phylogenetic comparative methods, these homologies can now be tested empirically and form the basis of this study. Based on a dataset of 77 dinosaur species that preserve integumentary structures, we undertake a series of model-fitting and ancestral state reconstruction analyses to interpret the evolutionary history and ancestral integumentary condition in dinosaurs. Our results provide the first empirical support for the evolution of feathers in an ordered fashion, but reveal that these evolutionary trends were not always towards ‘more complex’ conditions. Ancestral state reconstructions demonstrate that irrespective of the preferred phylogenetic framework, the ancestral pterosaur condition or whether any one major dinosaur lineage had a Late Triassic-feathered representative, support values for a filamentous/feathered dinosaur ancestor are low. More examples of feathered taxa from across the dinosaur tree, and in particular the discovery of as yet unknown feathered Triassic taxa, will be needed in order to overturn current support for a scaly dinosaurian ancestor.
The Early Origin of Feathers.

Michael J. Benton,Danielle Dhouailly,Baoyu Jiang,Maria E. McNamara

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tree.2019.04.018

IF: 20.589

2019-01-01

Trends in Ecology & Evolution

Abstract:Feathers have long been regarded as the innovation that drove the success of birds. However, feathers have been reported from close dinosaurian relatives of birds, and now from ornithischian dinosaurs and pterosaurs, the cousins of dinosaurs. Incomplete preservation makes these reports controversial. If true, these findings shift the origin of feathers back 80 million years before the origin of birds. Gene regulatory networks show the deep homology of scales, feathers, and hairs. Hair and feathers likely evolved in the Early Triassic ancestors of mammals and birds, at a time when synapsids and archosaurs show independent evidence of higher metabolic rates (erect gait and endothermy), as part of a major resetting of terrestrial ecosystems following the devastating end-Permian mass extinction.
Pterosaur integumentary structures with complex feather-like branching

Zixiao Yang,Baoyu Jiang,Maria E. McNamara,Stuart L. Kearns,Michael Pittman,Thomas G. Kaye,Patrick J. Orr,Xing Xu,Michael J. Benton

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41559-018-0728-7

IF: 19.1

2018-01-01

Nature Ecology & Evolution

Abstract:Pterosaurs were the first vertebrates to achieve true flapping flight, but in the absence of living representatives, many questions concerning their biology and lifestyle remain unresolved. Pycnofibres—the integumentary coverings of pterosaurs—are particularly enigmatic: although many reconstructions depict fur-like coverings composed of pycnofibres, their affinities and function are not fully understood. Here, we report the preservation in two anurognathid pterosaur specimens of morphologically diverse pycnofibres that show diagnostic features of feathers, including non-vaned grouped filaments and bilaterally branched filaments, hitherto considered unique to maniraptoran dinosaurs, and preserved melanosomes with diverse geometries. These findings could imply that feathers had deep evolutionary origins in ancestral archosaurs, or that these structures arose independently in pterosaurs. The presence of feather-like structures suggests that anurognathids, and potentially other pterosaurs, possessed a dense filamentous covering that probably functioned in thermoregulation, tactile sensing, signalling and aerodynamics.
The Early Origin of Feathers

Michael J. Benton,Danielle Dhouailly,Baoyu Jiang,Maria McNamara

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tree.2019.04.018

IF: 20.589

2019-01-01

Trends in Ecology & Evolution

Abstract:Feathers are a diagnostic character of birds, and yet new fossils show they likely originated more than 100 million years before the first birds. In fact, feathers probably occurred in all dinosaur groups, and in their cousins, the pterosaurs, as we showed in 2019. This finding confirms current knowledge of the genomic regulation of feather development. Our work stems from ten years of collaboration with Chinese colleagues, during which we set ourselves the taks of understanding fossil feathers. Our first discovery was to answer the question, ‘Will we ever know the colour of dinosaurs?’. In 2010, we were able to announce the first objective evidence for colour in a dinosaur. Using ultrastructural studies of fossil feathers, we identified melanosomes for the first time in dinosaur feathers, and these demonstrated that Sinosauropteryx had ginger and white rings down its tail. Studies of other dinosaurs identified patterns of black, white, grey, brown, and ginger. This is part of a new wave in palaeobiology where we apply objective approaches to provide testable hypotheses, once thought impossible in the historical sciences.
Elaborate plumage patterning in a Cretaceous bird.

Quanguo Li,Julia A Clarke,Ke-Qin Gao,Jennifer A Peteya,Matthew D Shawkey

DOI: https://doi.org/10.7717/peerj.5831

IF: 3.061

2018-01-01

PeerJ

Abstract:Integumentary patterns and colors can differentiate species, sexes, and life changes and can inform on habitat and ecology. However, they are rarely preserved in the fossil record. Here, we report on an extremely well-preserved specimen of the Cretaceous bird Confuciusornis with unprecedented complexity, including small spots on the wings, crest, and throat. Morphological and chemical evidence suggest that these patterns are produced by melanin, but unusual preservation prevents assignment of specific colors. Based on comparisons with extant birds, these patterns were likely used for camouflage, although other functions including sexual signaling cannot be ruled out. Our data show that even more elaborate plumage patterns than the spangles in Anchiornis and stripes in Sinosauropteryx were present at a relatively early stage of avian evolution, showing the significance of coloration and patterning to feather evolution.
Reconstruction of Microraptor and the Evolution of Iridescent Plumage.

Quanguo Li,Ke-Qin Gao,Qingjin Meng,Julia A. Clarke,Matthew D. Shawkey,Liliana D'Alba,Rui Pei,Mick Ellison,Mark A. Norell,Jakob Vinther

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1126/science.1213780

IF: 56.9

2012-01-01

Science

Abstract:Iridescent feather colors involved in displays of many extant birds are produced by nanoscale arrays of melanin-containing organelles (melanosomes). Data relevant to the evolution of these colors and the properties of melanosomes involved in their generation have been limited. A data set sampling variables of extant avian melanosomes reveals that those forming most iridescent arrays are distinctly narrow. Quantitative comparison of these data with melanosome imprints densely sampled from a previously unknown specimen of the Early Cretaceous feathered Microraptor predicts that its plumage was predominantly iridescent. The capacity for simple iridescent arrays is thus minimally inferred in paravian dinosaurs. This finding and estimation of Microraptor feathering consistent with an ornamental function for the tail suggest a centrality for signaling in early evolution of plumage and feather color.
Disassociated feathers in Burmese amber shed new light on mid-Cretaceous dinosaurs and avifauna

Lida Xing,Pierre Cockx,Ryan C. McKellar

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.gr.2019.12.017

IF: 6.1

2020-06-01

Gondwana Research

Abstract:Even in the absence of associated skeletal material, isolated feathers in amber remain of high scientific interest. The remarkable preservation of these delicate structures in amber, implies a potential for significantly improving our knowledge of feather evolution and diversity. A large sample set of 150 Burmese amber specimens (Upper Cretaceous, ~99 Ma) containing feathers is herein described. Several structural types can be differentiated including flight feathers, contour feathers, semiplumes, and filoplumes. In some cases, peculiar pigmentation patterns and structural features can be documented. Additionally, different developmental stages have been captured in this assemblage with some examples of erupting feathers or neoptile plumage. Comparisons with previous studies including skeletal material described in amber, show that Enantiornithes and non avialan dinosaurs are most likely represented in the assemblage as well as unknown taxa.

geosciences, multidisciplinary
Escape behaviors in prey and the evolution of pennaceous plumage in dinosaurs

Jinseok Park,Minyoung Son,Jeongyeol Park,Sang Yun Bang,Jungmoon Ha,Hyungpil Moon,Yuong-Nam Lee,Sang-im Lee,Piotr G. Jablonski

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-023-50225-x

IF: 4.6

2024-01-26

Scientific Reports

Abstract:Numerous non-avian dinosaurs possessed pennaceous feathers on their forelimbs (proto-wings) and tail. Their functions remain unclear. We propose that these pennaceous feathers were used in displays to flush hiding prey through stimulation of sensory-neural escape pathways in prey, allowing the dinosaurs to pursue the flushed prey. We evaluated the escape behavior of grasshoppers to hypothetical visual flush-displays by a robotic dinosaur, and we recorded neurophysiological responses of grasshoppers' escape pathway to computer animations of the hypothetical flush-displays by dinosaurs. We show that the prey of dinosaurs would have fled more often when proto-wings were present, especially distally and with contrasting patterns, and when caudal plumage, especially of a large area, was used during the hypothetical flush-displays. The reinforcing loop between flush and pursue functions could have contributed to the evolution of larger and stiffer feathers for faster running, maneuverability, and stronger flush-displays, promoting foraging based on the flush-pursue strategy. The flush-pursue hypothesis can explain the presence and distribution of the pennaceous feathers, plumage color contrasts, as well as a number of other features observed in early pennaraptorans. This scenario highlights that sensory-neural processes underlying prey's antipredatory reactions may contribute to the origin of major evolutionary innovations in predators.

multidisciplinary sciences
Feathers were the exception rather than the rule for dinosaurs

Matt Kaplan

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/nature.2013.14379

IF: 64.8

2013-12-27

Nature

Abstract:Survey of dinosaur family tree finds that most had scaly skin like reptiles.

multidisciplinary sciences
An Early Cretaceous Enantiornithine Bird with a Pintail.

Min Wang,Jingmai K. O'Connor,Tao Zhao,Yanhong Pan,Xiaoting Zheng,Xiaoli Wang,Zhonghe Zhou

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cub.2021.08.044

2021-01-01

Abstract:Enantiornithes are the most successful group of Mesozoic birds, arguably representing the first global avian radiation,1-4 and commonly resolved as the sister to the Ornithuromorpha, the clade within which all living birds are nested.1,3 The wealth of fossils makes it feasible to comparatively test evolutionary hypotheses about the pattern and mode of eco-morphological diversity of these sister clades that co-existed for approximately 65 Ma. Here, we report a new Early Cretaceous enantiornithine, Yuanchuavis kompsosoura gen. et. sp. nov., with a rectricial fan combined with an elongate central pair of fully pennaceous rachis-dominated plumes, constituting a new tail plumage previously unknown among nonavialan dinosaurs and Mesozoic birds but which strongly resembles the pintail in many neornithines. The extravagant but aerodynamically costly long central plumes, as an honest signal of quality, likely evolved in enantiornithines through the handicap process of sexual selection. The contrasting tail morphotypes observed between enantiornithines and early ornithuromorphs reflect the complex interplay between sexual and natural selections and indicate that each lineage experienced unique pressures reflecting ecological differences. As in neornithines, early avialans repeatedly evolved extravagant structures highlighting the importance of sexual selection in shaping the plumage of feathered dinosaurs, even early in their evolutionary history.
150 million years of sustained increase in pterosaur flight efficiency

Chris Venditti,Joanna Baker,Michael J Benton,Andrew Meade,Stuart Humphries

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-020-2858-8

IF: 64.8

Nature

Abstract:The long-term accumulation of biodiversity has been punctuated by remarkable evolutionary transitions that allowed organisms to exploit new ecological opportunities. Mesozoic flying reptiles (the pterosaurs), which dominated the skies for more than 150 million years, were the product of one such transition. The ancestors of pterosaurs were small and probably bipedal early archosaurs1, which were certainly well-adapted to terrestrial locomotion. Pterosaurs diverged from dinosaur ancestors in the Early Triassic epoch (around 245 million years ago); however, the first fossils of pterosaurs are dated to 25 million years later, in the Late Triassic epoch. Therefore, in the absence of proto-pterosaur fossils, it is difficult to study how flight first evolved in this group. Here we describe the evolutionary dynamics of the adaptation of pterosaurs to a new method of locomotion. The earliest known pterosaurs took flight and subsequently appear to have become capable and efficient flyers. However, it seems clear that transitioning between forms of locomotion2,3-from terrestrial to volant-challenged early pterosaurs by imposing a high energetic burden, thus requiring flight to provide some offsetting fitness benefits. Using phylogenetic statistical methods and biophysical models combined with information from the fossil record, we detect an evolutionary signal of natural selection that acted to increase flight efficiency over millions of years. Our results show that there was still considerable room for improvement in terms of efficiency after the appearance of flight. However, in the Azhdarchoidea4, a clade that exhibits gigantism, we test the hypothesis that there was a decreased reliance on flight5-7 and find evidence for reduced selection on flight efficiency in this clade. Our approach offers a blueprint to objectively study functional and energetic changes through geological time at a more nuanced level than has previously been possible.
Feathers, Dinosaurs, and Behavioral Cues: Defining the Visual Display Hypothesis for the Adaptive Function of Feathers in Non-Avian Theropods

Christopher C. Dimond,Robert J. Cabin,Janie S. Brooks

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1893/011.082.0302

2011-09-01

BIOS

Abstract:With growing evidence for the presence of feathers in theropod dinosaurs, scientists have become increasingly interested in what adaptive function the earliest feathers served. The three predominant hypotheses are 1) flight, 2) thermoregulation, and 3) visual display. While the first two hypotheses have each received considerable attention and analysis, the third has often been mentioned yet has been inadequately described and analyzed. We define the visual display hypothesis as predicting that theropod feathers served primarily in the creation of a visual cue capable of triggering a behavioral response in an individual perceiving this cue. We analyze fossil evidence regarding whether such a cue could have been generated and perceived, discuss plausible scenarios in which this type of visual cue could have developed, and highlight areas where more data are needed to further support or falsify this hypothesis. We hope that by developing and articulating hypotheses such as this, it will provide other researchers a framework in which to place future discoveries in order to better understand the presence of early feathers on theropod dinosaurs.
Trends in Ecology & Evolution

M. Benton,Danielle Dhouailly,Baoyu Jiang,Maria E. McNamara

2019-01-01

Abstract:There are close connections in terms of genomic regulation between numerous regularly arrayed structures in the epidermis, including denticles in sharks, dermal scales in teleost fish, epidermal scales in reptiles, feathers in birds, and hairs in Feathers have long been regarded as the innovation that drove the success of birds. However, feathers have been reported from close dinosaurian relatives of birds, and now from ornithischian dinosaurs and pterosaurs, the cousins of dinosaurs. Incomplete preservation makes these reports controversial. If true, these findings shift the origin of feathers back 80 million years before the origin of birds. Gene regulatory networks show the deep homology of scales, feathers, and hairs. Hair and feathers likely evolved in the Early Triassic ancestors of mammals and birds, at a time when synapsids and archosaurs show independent evidence of higher metabolic rates (erect gait and endothermy), as part of a major resetting of terrestrial ecosystems following the devastating end-Permian mass extinction. mammals.
The molecular evolution of feathers with direct evidence from fossils

Yanhong Pan,Wenxia Zheng,Roger H Sawyer,Michael W Pennington,Xiaoting Zheng,Xiaoli Wang,Min Wang,Liang Hu,Jingmai O'Connor,Tao Zhao,Zhiheng Li,Elena R Schroeter,Feixiang Wu,Xing Xu,Zhonghe Zhou,Mary H Schweitzer,Roger H. Sawyer,Michael W. Pennington,Jingmai O’Connor,Elena R. Schroeter,Mary H. Schweitzer

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1815703116

IF: 11.1

2019-01-28

Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences

Abstract:Significance During the dinosaur–bird transition, feathers of bird ancestors must have been molecularly modified to become biomechanically suitable for flight. We report molecular moieties in fossil feathers that shed light on that transition. Pennaceous feathers attached to the right forelimb of the Jurassic dinosaur Anchiornis were composed of both feather β-keratins and α-keratins, but were dominated by α-keratins, unlike mature feathers of extant birds, which are dominated by β-keratins. Data suggest that the pennaceous feathers of Anchiornis had some, but not all, of the ultrastructural and molecular characteristics of extant feathers, and may not yet have attained molecular modifications required for powered flight.

multidisciplinary sciences
Cellular structure of dinosaur scales reveals retention of reptile-type skin during the evolutionary transition to feathers

Zixiao Yang,Baoyu Jiang,Jiaxin Xu,Maria E McNamara

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-024-48400-3

2024-05-21

Abstract:Fossil feathers have transformed our understanding of integumentary evolution in vertebrates. The evolution of feathers is associated with novel skin ultrastructures, but the fossil record of these changes is poor and thus the critical transition from scaled to feathered skin is poorly understood. Here we shed light on this issue using preserved skin in the non-avian feathered dinosaur Psittacosaurus. Skin in the non-feathered, scaled torso is three-dimensionally replicated in silica and preserves epidermal layers, corneocytes and melanosomes. The morphology of the preserved stratum corneum is consistent with an original composition rich in corneous beta proteins, rather than (alpha-) keratins as in the feathered skin of birds. The stratum corneum is relatively thin in the ventral torso compared to extant quadrupedal reptiles, reflecting a reduced demand for mechanical protection in an elevated bipedal stance. The distribution of the melanosomes in the fossil skin is consistent with melanin-based colouration in extant crocodilians. Collectively, the fossil evidence supports partitioning of skin development in Psittacosaurus: a reptile-type condition in non-feathered regions and an avian-like condition in feathered regions. Retention of reptile-type skin in non-feathered regions would have ensured essential skin functions during the early, experimental stages of feather evolution.
The Distribution of Integumentary Structures in a Feathered Dinosaur

Qiang Ji,Mark A. Norell,Ke-Qin Gao,Shu-An Ji,Dong Ren

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/35074079

IF: 64.8

2001-01-01

Nature

Abstract:Non-avian theropod dinosaurs with preserved integumentary coverings are becoming more common1,2,3,4,5,6; but apart from the multiple specimens of Caudipteryx, which have true feathers2,7, animals that are reasonably complete and entirely articulated that show these structures in relation to the body have not been reported. Here we report on an enigmatic small theropod dinosaur that is covered with filamentous feather-like structures over its entire body.
Rarity of molt evidence in early pennaraptoran dinosaurs suggests annual molt evolved later among Neornithes

Yosef Kiat,Jingmai Kathleen O’Connor

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s42003-023-05048-x

IF: 6.548

2023-07-05

Communications Biology

Abstract:Feathers are a primitive trait among pennaraptoran dinosaurs, which today are represented by crown birds (Neornithes), the only clade of dinosaurs to survive the end Cretaceous mass extinction. Feathers are central to many important functions and therefore, maintaining plumage function is of great importance for survival. Thus, molt – by which new feathers are formed to replace old ones, is an essential process. Our limited knowledge regarding molt in early pennaraptoran evolution is based largely on a single Microraptor specimen. A survey of 92 feathered non-avian dinosaur and stem bird fossils did not find additional molting evidence. Due to its longer duration, in ornithological collections evidence of molt is found more frequently in extant bird species with sequential molts compared to those with more rapid simultaneous molts. The low frequency of molt occurrence among fossil specimens resembles collections of bird species with simultaneous molts. The dearth of molt evidence in the forelimbs of pennaraptoran specimens may have interesting implications regarding molt strategy during early avian evolution, and suggests that the yearly molting cycle may have evolved later, among crown birds.

biology

Pterosaurs were clad in colorful plumage

Plumage Color Patterns Of An Extinct Dinosaur

Pterosaur melanosomes support signalling functions for early feathers

Palaeontology: 'modern' feathers on a non-avian dinosaur.

On the Ancestry of Feathers in Mesozoic Dinosaurs

The Early Origin of Feathers.

Pterosaur integumentary structures with complex feather-like branching

The Early Origin of Feathers

Elaborate plumage patterning in a Cretaceous bird.

Reconstruction of Microraptor and the Evolution of Iridescent Plumage.

Disassociated feathers in Burmese amber shed new light on mid-Cretaceous dinosaurs and avifauna

Escape behaviors in prey and the evolution of pennaceous plumage in dinosaurs

Feathers were the exception rather than the rule for dinosaurs

An Early Cretaceous Enantiornithine Bird with a Pintail.

150 million years of sustained increase in pterosaur flight efficiency

Feathers, Dinosaurs, and Behavioral Cues: Defining the Visual Display Hypothesis for the Adaptive Function of Feathers in Non-Avian Theropods

Trends in Ecology & Evolution

The molecular evolution of feathers with direct evidence from fossils

Cellular structure of dinosaur scales reveals retention of reptile-type skin during the evolutionary transition to feathers

The Distribution of Integumentary Structures in a Feathered Dinosaur

Rarity of molt evidence in early pennaraptoran dinosaurs suggests annual molt evolved later among Neornithes