Ipsilateral fractures of the scaphoid and radial head
Bin Yu,Huifeng Ding,Xinhua Jiang,Jianming Huang,Baoqing Yu
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3877/cma.j.issn.2095-5790.2016.03.005
2016-01-01
Abstract:Background Ipsilateral fractures of the scaphoid and radial head are uncommon injuries of the incidence about 0.7%-6.5%.Although the scaphoid fracture is the most common fracture of carpal bones,the simultaneous fractures of one forearm are reported less than 10% of cases.The combined fractures include distal radius,radial head and other carpal bones,among which distal radius account for most cases.Clinicians tend to make a missed diagnosis and only give treatment to other fractures by the symptoms of other fractures.If failed to timely find carpal bone fracture in the radial head fractures patients,the adoption of fixed position and early postoperative function exercise are bound to affect the scaphoid fracture healing,and even cause nonunion.Through a retrospective study on the 47 cases of radial head fracture treated in our hospital from January 201 1 to January 201 5,we picked out the patients with ipsilateral scaphoid fractures and observed and analysis the incidence,diagnosis,mechanism and management of them.Methods (1 )General data. There are 47 patients,28 males and 1 9 females aging from 1 6 to 65 years old with the average age 38 years old.Among them 3 patients including 2 men and 1 women,aging from 28 to 47 with an average of 36 years old,are ipsilateral fractures of the scaphoid and radial head(the incidence was 6.4%).One of them was delayed diagnosis.Manson types of radial head fracture:2 cases were type I,1 case was type II.Herbert types of scaphoid fractures:1 case was type A2,1 case was type B1,1 case was type B2.(2 )Treatment and rehabilitation methods.Radial head fractures:after general anesthesia,elbow lateral incision was placed.Then subcutaneous tissue,the deep fascia was cut open.To exposed the joint capsule by separation of the extensor tendon.And joint capsule was incised,radial head was exposed.Radial head fractures with splitting subsidence displacement were shown.After reduction of fractures,one needle was used for temporary fixation and a plate was applied for internal fixation of radial head.Intraoperative inspection of elbow rotation and flexion function is good.Good fractures reduction was shown with postoperative perspective.Scaphoid fracture:wrist metacarpus incision was placed.Then subcutaneous tissue,the deep fascia was cut open.After separation between flexor carpi radialis and radial artery,the wrist joint was show.And after opening the joint capsule and exposing the carpi,scaphoid fracture was shown.One needle was used for temporary fixation after reduction. Intraoperative fluoroscopy confirmed good reduction of the fracture.One cannulated screw was applied to stabilize the fracture.Postoperative perspective is needed for the operation.Three days after surgery,elbow wrist function training was started.Elbow flexion and rotation training were started after swelling subsided. X-ray examination was performed for 1, 3 months after operation. Conservative treatment methods:After immobilization with long cast for 1 month,a spica cast was applied instead of long cast and elbow began to function training at the same time.3 months after injury,the wrist plaster was removed and the function training of wrist joint was started.Therapeutic evaluation:at the last follow-up visit,the visitors adopted the Mayo elbow joint functions evaluation systems,namely,mayo elbow performance score and MEPS.The functions were evaluated from 4 aspects:the pain degree,movement degree,stability and living ability.The full scores are 100 points:90-100 points is excellent,75-89 points is good,60-74 is ok,less than 60 points is poor. According to Cooney wrist function evaluation system,the pain degree,movements of the wrist and the percentage of the contralateral, grip strength and the percentage of the contralateral were evaluated.Each item is 25 points,and the full score are 100 points:90-100 points is excellent,80-89 points is good,65-79 is ok,less than 65 points is poor.Results All patients were followed up for 6-18 months and the average was 13 months.All the fractures became union.In the last follow-up visit,the results of elbow function were:no pain left,the elbow joints extension 10.0°±5.2°,flexion 123.2°±10.3°,movement range 120.0°±10.8°,MEPS evaluation (94.9 ±3.6)points.Three cases were excellent;the excellent and good rate was 100%.The results of wrist function were:no pain left,all patients recovered to preoperative work condition.Average wrist motion:back stretch 84° (82°-90°),palm down 85°(84°-90°);the total activity was 98% of the contralateral (95%-100%). The average grip strength was 40 kg (34-47 kg),and was 98% of the contralateral (95%-100%). The Cooney wrist score averaged 95.4 (range,92 to 100 ).The functional results were ranked as excellent in 3 patients.The excellent and good rate was 100%.Conclusions The incidence of radial head fracture with ipsilateral scaphoid fracture is extremely low,and it is often easy to misdiagnose for combined fracture.Patients with carpal bone fracture or radial head fractures should be effectively ruled out the combined fractures.For undisplaced fracture it is useful of conservative treatments with plaster,and for displaced fracture,the open reduction and internal fixation are needed.The incidence of radial head fracture with ipsilateral scaphoid fracture is extremely low,and it is often easy to misdiagnose for combined fracture.Patients with carpal bone fracture or radial head fractures should be effectively ruled out the combined fractures.For undisplaced fracture it is useful of conservative treatments with plaster,and for displaced fracture,the open reduction and internal fixation are needed.