The `Dreamy State' as an Epileptic Aura, with Remarks on the Occurrence of Elaborate Mental States at the Beginning of Epileptic Fits

M. Levin
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/jnnp.s1-15.60.289
1935-04-01
Abstract:HUGHLINGS JACKSON, in his later years, paid much attention to a phenomenon occurring early in some epileptic fits and commonly known as an ' intellectual aura ' or 'dreamy state.' Of these terms Jackson preferred the latter, since he thought the phenomenon was not a true aura. In this paper I shall try to show that it is, at least in some cases, an aura. The reader will find a description of the dreamy state in several of Jackson's papers 1 and in Kinnier Wilson's paper,2 and it need not be repeated here. Nor shall I outline Jackson's views on the nature of the epileptic seizure, save briefly to mention two points bearing on this discussion. According to Jackson the aura-the very first manifestation of the fit-occurs during, and is concomitant with, the epileptic discharge. The phenomena occurring after the discharge he divided into two groups: (1) negative symptoms, representing loss of activity of paralysed higher centres, and (2) positive symptoms, representing the activity of intact lower centres released from the control of higher centres. The importance of this distinction is best seen in the slightest seizures, which, as Jackson emphasized, are especially often followed by elaborate actions (positive symptom), occurring in association with some loss of consciousness (negative symptom). Jackson's opinion of the nature of the dreamy state is expressed in the following passages. In 1876 he was reported (I, 274) * as follows: 'Dr. Hughlings Jackson thinks they (dreamy states) are not comparable to ordinary warnings; they are not, he thinks, the result of the epileptic discharge of the highest centre, but are owing to over-activity of next lower centres, as yet
What problem does this paper attempt to address?