The effect of automation trust tendency, system reliability and feedback on users' phishing detection

Ying Zhou,Xinyue Cui,Weina Qu,Yan Ge
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.apergo.2022.103754
Abstract:As a new intrusion method in the security field, phishing poses an enormous threat to network security and personal privacy. Thus, improving the level of network security and preventing phishing are a matter of great concern to both the state and researchers. A 2 (automation trust tendency) *2 (system reliability level) *2 (feedback) between-subjects design was adopted to study the impact of individual characteristics and system features on phishing detection. Three hundred ninety-eight participants completed a phishing email task to identify whether 40 emails were legitimate or fraudulent. The results showed that systems with feedback and high reliability improve users' performance in email identification. Users with a high tendency towards automation trust have a higher risk of phishing. However, feedback from the system helps calibrate a high automation trust tendency. These research results can promote an understanding of phishing prevention mechanisms and provide support for the design of email defence systems.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?