Theories of Youth Unrest in Cross-Cultural Perspective*

H. Murphy

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3109/00048677409159773

1974-03-01

Abstract:Ever since Hall’s ( 1916) classic work, turbulence and unrest have been accepted as characteristics of adolescence and many theories have been propounded to explain this. At one time most of the evidence regarding this unrest came either from individual cases or from data on delinquency, both difficult sources to interpret. The individual history tends to come from the person with an above-average verbal facility who is perhaps also above average in introspection. Delinquency data tend to come disproportionately from the disadvantages classes. Recently, however, attention has been drawn to another form of adolescent unrest which has neither of these disadvantages the youth protest movement. Such movements are not common, for some societies can run for decades without recording a single instance, but they are exceedingly widespread and they have been commoner than most people realise. Even when they occur it is only a minority of the available youth that participate, but on the other hand it is often true that a majority of the remainder sympathise and feel themselves being spoken for. They often overlap adult movements and when this occurs it may be difficult to distinguish those features which truly derive from the youth themselves, but on the other hand one finds that when one does distinguish these they have a particularly adolescent quality. They have been reported to be completely absent from traditional folk societies and this, if true, could be of considerable significance. For psychiatrists these movements have a double interest. In the first place, it is usual for other forms of adolescent unrest to be accompanied by some mental disturbance, and we need to know whether to expect that with this type also. In the second place the movements provide a possible means of testing or expanding the different theories of adolescence on which our therapeutic approaches are likely to be based. 1 propose, therefore, to review what we know about such movements in different types of