In a Preliminary Study on Human Subjects, a Cosmetic Cream Containing a Harungana madagascariensis Plant Extract Induces Similar Anti-Aging Effects to a Retinol-Containing Cream
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2147/CCID.S401290
2023-04-20
Abstract:Clara Gibielle, 1 Lydia Bousseksou, 2 Sabine Guéhenneux, 1 Katell Vié 1 1 Laboratoires Clarins, Pontoise, 95300, France; 2 IEC France, Lyon, 69006, France Correspondence: Clara Gibielle, Laboratoires Clarins, 5 rue Ampère, Pontoise, 95300, France, Tel +33 1 34 35 15 15, Fax +33 1 30 38 41 48, Email Retinoids are the most effective anti-aging ingredients. Yet, their use can result in adverse reactions. Even bakuchiol, a natural functional analog, can lead to contact dermatitis. We previously showed that a Harungana madagascariensis (Lam. ex Poir.) plant extract (HME) presents retinol-like properties in vitro. Therefore, we performed a preliminary analysis of the anti-aging potential of a cream containing HME on 46 subjects. The participants applied a HME cream on half of their face and one forearm. The effects induced were compared to those produced by a retinol cream applied to the contralateral side. Clinical evaluations indicate that the two creams rapidly (28 days) improve wrinkles underneath the eyes, ptosis, color homogeneity, smoothness, plumpness, firmness, and elasticity of the facial skin. The improvement of crow's feet is only significant after 56 days. For all clinical signs, the effects of both creams are indistinguishable. Instrumental measurements of silicon replica from the eye contour region indicate that the wrinkle surface reduction is already noticeable after 28 days with the HME and retinol cream, while it takes 56 days to have a significant depth decrease. Only the retinol cream improves wrinkle length after 56 days. Ultrasound assessment of forearm skin revealed that the HME cream improves superficial dermis density as early as 28 days with further improvement at day 56, timepoint at which improvement is at the limit of significance with the retinol cream. These preliminary results indicate that HME has similar in vivo functional properties to retinol for reducing the severity of aging signs. Future works, including a bona fide clinical study, are needed to confirm these findings. Keywords: retinol, Harungana madagascariensis , anti-aging, cosmetics, in vivo, scoring Age and chronic sun exposure alter the skin, leading to the appearance of visible signs. 1 Because they prevent, even reverse, these signs, retinoids became a staple in dermo-cosmetics. 2,3 Indeed, topically applied retinoids stimulate epidermal differentiation and keratinization, leading to epidermis thickening, reinforcement of the stratum corneum , and enhanced barrier function. 3,4 In the dermis, they improve the extracellular matrix, resulting in better skin elasticity and fine wrinkle reduction. 1,5 Although natural, retinol's widespread use revealed side effects. 1,6 This is also the case with retinoids, even recent ones. There is a need for functional analogs, and there is also a growing demand for natural products. Bakuchiol, a meroterpene isolated from Psoralea corylifolia seeds, is such a compound. Inducing retinol-like genes/proteins expressions, it reduces aging signs. 7–9 Yet, its growing use led to identify contact dermatitis cases. 10,11 Such adverse effects are not unexpected, as intolerance to botanical compounds is frequent. 12 Therefore, finding natural retinoid functional analogs is still of interest. We previously reported that a Harungana madagascariensis (Lam. ex Poir.) extract (HME) could be such an alternative. 13 It induces a retinol-like gene induction profile in isolated fibroblasts and a retinoid-like protein expression in isolated fibroblasts and photoaged skin explants. These results suggested that HME targets pathways similar to those of retinoids. To further investigate the HME potential, we performed a preliminary randomized, double-blind, comparative study to determine if an HME-containing cream could have comparable effects to a retinol containing cream. After a 14-day washout period during which subjects applied (morning and evening) a neutral cream on their face, they used for 56 days (morning and evening) a cream containing HME on half of their face and a retinol-containing cream on the contralateral side. They also applied one of the creams on each forearm. The side onto which each cream was applied was randomly selected, and the application was blind as both creams were similar and provided in identical vials (labeled A or B). Clinical evaluations and data analysis were performed blindly. During the entire study, make-up was restricted to eyes and lips. The only cosmetics allowed were neutral cleansers or make-up removers. Assessments were performed blindly on days 0 (D0), 28 (D28), and 56 (D56) in a dedicated research facility (IEC France, Lyon, France). A diagram of the ma -Abstract Truncated-
dermatology